Dr. JAMES MICHAEL GRIMES, M.D. must answer a Florida environmental regulatory demand letter asking about a 10x30 foot hole carved in a protected sand dune in violation of Florida environmental law, asking him to restore it. The dune, at #2 Twelfth Lane, is east of GRIMES' beach cottage controlled by an LLC of which GRIMES is the only listed manager.
FDEP inspected on September 17th. It sent GRIMES a September 27th letter directing him to restore the dune or face consequences. The dune destruction was a featured story on Jacksonville tv news stations and the St. Augustine Record. Florida law forbids destruction of dunes by a coastal property owner. The law helps protect our homes from storm surge, protect wildlife and enjoy our beaches.
Will Florida law enforcement be tough on any environmental crimes? Will there be kid gloves treatment of environmental crimes allegedly committed, suffered or permitted by GRIMES and his LLC. The damage was done during hurricane season, at a time when it could have caused flooding.
While gaps in dunes were temporally filled during the storm to prevent storm surge, were GRIMES, et ux busy creating a hole in the dune that could have flood his own and other properties? Why?
Under F.S. 163.051, what GRIMES did (or someone working on his property did) is both a nuisance and potentially a first degree misdemeanor.
"Health care is not a 'right.' It is not guaranteed to citizens by the U.S. Constitution or God." What blasphemy -- GRIMES speaks for God?! Read full GRIMES letter here or here.
I wrote by e-mail this morning and asked GRIMES for comment, and to identify his partners.
NO RESPONSE from GRIMES.
Jesus preached in Nazareth, "Physician, heal thyself." (Luke 4:23).
To orthopaedic physician Dr. JAMES MICHAEL GRIMES, I say, "Physician, heal this dune."
One news report alleged that GRACE GRIMES, co-owner, and Dr. GRIMES' wife, denied knowing about the dune bulldozing while a witness established she had a conversation with the bulldozer operator. (read news stories below).
Dr, JAMES GRIMES, M.D. and wife GRACE: She allegedly denied knowledge of bulldozer, while witness allegedly saw her speaking to bulldozer operator
Here is the correspondence that FDEP sent Dr. GRIMES received from FDEP this week:
Florida Department of Environmental Protection
Northeast District
8800 Baymeadows Way West, Suite 100 Jacksonville, Florida 32256
8800 Baymeadows Way West, Suite 100 Jacksonville, Florida 32256
Rick Scott Governor
Carlos Lopez-Cantera Lt. Governor
Noah Valenstein Secretary
September 27, 2017
BNE SRGN Investments 2 Twelfth Lane, LLC
c/o James M. Grimes, Manager
49 Dolphin Drive
St. Augustine, Florida 32080
RE: Compliance Assistance Offer 2 12th Lane
DEP File Number: VSJ 17-17 St. Johns County
Dear Mr. Grimes:
c/o James M. Grimes, Manager
49 Dolphin Drive
St. Augustine, Florida 32080
RE: Compliance Assistance Offer 2 12th Lane
DEP File Number: VSJ 17-17 St. Johns County
Dear Mr. Grimes:
On September 18, 2017, a complaint inspection was conducted on your property located at 2 12th Lane, St. Augustine, in St. Johns County. During this inspection, potential non-compliance of Section 161.053, Florida Statutes (“F.S.”) was observed. The purpose of this letter is to offer you compliance assistance as a means of resolving this matter.
Specifically, activities have been conducted seaward of the Coastal Construction Control Line (“CCCL”) on the subject property that do not appear to have been authorized by a CCCL permit from the Department, in potential non-compliance with the requirements of Section 161.053(2)(a), F.S. Please see the attached Compliance Inspection Report for a full account of Department observations and recommendations.
We request you review the items of concern noted in the Department’s report and respond within 10 days of receipt of this Compliance Assistance Offer. Your response should include one of the following:
We request you review the items of concern noted in the Department’s report and respond within 10 days of receipt of this Compliance Assistance Offer. Your response should include one of the following:
- Describe what has been done to resolve the apparent non-compliance issue or provide a schedule describing how and when the issues will be addressed (see "Recommendations for Corrective Action” section of the attached inspection report),
- Provide information that either mitigates the concerns or demonstrates them to be invalid, or
- Arrange for one of our inspectors to visit your site to discuss the items of concern.
BNE SRGN Investments 2 Twelfth Lane, LLC DEP File Number: VSJ 17-17
Compliance Assistance Offer
Page 2 of 2
It is the Department’s desire that you are able to adequately address the items of concern so that this matter can be closed. Your failure to respond appropriately may result in the initiation of formal enforcement proceedings.
You are requested to contact Chrissy Sellers of the Northeast District Office at (904) 256-1626, or via e-mail at Christina.Sellers@dep.state.fl.us, within 10 days of receipt of this Compliance Assistance Offer to arrange a conference call to further discuss this matter. You may include anyone with you to the meeting that you feel could help resolve this matter.
We look forward to your cooperation.
Sincerely,
James R. Maher, PE
Assistant Director
Enclosures: Compliance Inspection Report
cc: Alex Reed, Deputy Director, DWRM Jim Martinello, DWRM
Trey Hatch, FDEP-Northeast District
David Kriger, DWRM
Mary Duncan, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission
Tara Dodson, St. Johns County Growth Management
Bill Ward, City of St. Augustine Beach Code Enforcement
Compliance Assistance Offer
Page 2 of 2
It is the Department’s desire that you are able to adequately address the items of concern so that this matter can be closed. Your failure to respond appropriately may result in the initiation of formal enforcement proceedings.
You are requested to contact Chrissy Sellers of the Northeast District Office at (904) 256-1626, or via e-mail at Christina.Sellers@dep.state.fl.us, within 10 days of receipt of this Compliance Assistance Offer to arrange a conference call to further discuss this matter. You may include anyone with you to the meeting that you feel could help resolve this matter.
We look forward to your cooperation.
Sincerely,
James R. Maher, PE
Assistant Director
Enclosures: Compliance Inspection Report
cc: Alex Reed, Deputy Director, DWRM Jim Martinello, DWRM
Trey Hatch, FDEP-Northeast District
David Kriger, DWRM
Mary Duncan, Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission
Tara Dodson, St. Johns County Growth Management
Bill Ward, City of St. Augustine Beach Code Enforcement
Florida Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) Northeast District 8800 Baymeadows Way West, Suite 100 Jacksonville, Florida 32256 (904) 256-1700 COMPLIANCE INSPECTION REPORT | ||||||
Inspection Date: 09/18/2017 | Inspection Time: 4:00 pm | Permit File number (if applicable): | City (if applicable): St. Augustine Beach | County: St. Johns | ||
DEP Monument Number (distance and direction): 105’ to 150’ north of R-143 | Distance of activity seaward of control line: ~330’ to 380’ | |||||
Property Owner’s Name: BNE SRGN Investments 2 Twelfth Lane, LLC | Address and Phone Number: 2 12th Lane St. Augustine, FL 32080 | Email: | ||||
Other Names (if applicable): James M. Grimes, Manager | Address and Phone Number: 49 Dolphin Drive St. Augustine, FL 32080 | Email: | ||||
Description of Alleged Non-Compliance Activities: Apparent excavation resulting in the removal of a portion of the frontal vegetated dune, using heavy equipment seaward of the Coastal Construction Control Line (“CCCL”) without benefit of a Department permit. | ||||||
Inspector’s Comments: Inspection revealed that an approximate 10-foot wide (shore-parallel) by an approximate 30-foot long (shore-normal) portion of the vegetated dune had been cut through, with the excavated dune material apparently having been pushed seaward towards the beach. There is evidence of bulldozer tracks, and the dune appears to be recently plowed. This activity was conducted during sea turtle season and St. Johns County Government environmental staff have also advised the affected area is known for a dense population of federal and state protected beach mice. | ||||||
Recommendations for Corrective Actions: As provided for in Section 161.053(2)(a), Florida Statutes (“F.S.”), native vegetation shall not be damaged, removed, or destroyed seaward of the CCCL without specific prior authorization from the Department, nor shall excavation or alteration of existing ground elevations be conducted seaward of the CCCL without specific prior Department authorization. The dune and dune vegetation damage that has occurred will need to be corrected to the Department’s satisfaction. To resolve this matter, the property owner must agree to conduct the recommended activities listed below. A response is requested within 10 days (See the Department’s Compliance Assistance Offer letter for additional details).
| ||||||
Inspector’s Signature: Kimberly Mann | Date: 09/19/2017 | |||||
DEP Form 73-301 (Revised 5/04) Page 1
FOR TALLAHASSEE OFFICE USE (Routing, Review, Comments):
This Compliance Inspection Report and the Compliance Assistance Offer reviewed by:
Jim Martinello Environmental Administrator DWRM
September 26, 2017
This Compliance Inspection Report and the Compliance Assistance Offer reviewed by:
Jim Martinello Environmental Administrator DWRM
September 26, 2017
Photographs (including brief location description):
View from dune facing west. Evidence of vehicle tracks leading towards the dune.
View from the beach facing west. Dune in front of property is lower and less vegetated than the surrounding dunes.
View from dune facing west. Evidence of vehicle tracks leading towards the dune.
View from the beach facing west. Dune in front of property is lower and less vegetated than the surrounding dunes.
DEP Form 73-301 (Revised 5/04) Page 2
View from the house facing east. Evidence of tracks and absence of vegetation.
DEP Form 73-301 (Revised 5/04) Page 3
|
ST. AUGUSTINE BEACH, Fla. (WTLV) -- There is now a large gap in one of the protective dunes along a St. Johns County Beach.
The city believes the dunes were bulldozed to give someone an ocean view near 12th Lane in St. Augustine Beach. Police said this type of dune destruction could lead to a first-degree misdemeanor.
The city believes the dunes were bulldozed to give someone an ocean view near 12th Lane in St. Augustine Beach. Police said this type of dune destruction could lead to a first-degree misdemeanor.
According to a St. Augustine Beach police report, about a half-dozen feet of sand was cut out of this dune. Now neighbors worry about their homes which are normally protected by an intact dune.
"If you do that, the sea comes through," Bill Holcomb said.
The results of removing a section of the dune are pretty obvious for Bill Holcomb, who lives nearby.
According to the police report, a witness spotted bulldozers near the dunes last week. That witness said he tried to talk to the operator, but they loaded up and left.
The results of removing a section of the dune are pretty obvious for Bill Holcomb, who lives nearby.
According to the police report, a witness spotted bulldozers near the dunes last week. That witness said he tried to talk to the operator, but they loaded up and left.
"Not really the thing you should be doing, with a Bobcat," Holcomb said.
Noah Baxter lives on 12th Lane in St. Augustine Beach. He filed the police report on Tuesday.
Baxter told police he witnessed Grace Grimes, who owns the property right in front of the damaged dunes, speaking with a construction crew regarding work behind her home.
Grimes denied causing the damage, telling police she did not know who could have done that.
Noah Baxter lives on 12th Lane in St. Augustine Beach. He filed the police report on Tuesday.
Baxter told police he witnessed Grace Grimes, who owns the property right in front of the damaged dunes, speaking with a construction crew regarding work behind her home.
Grimes denied causing the damage, telling police she did not know who could have done that.
First Coast News reached out to Grimes for comment, but she refused to talk.
"We just had a hurricane, it blew a lot of things around so it's a bit silly of someone to take it upon themselves to do this though," Holcomb said.
Holcomb doesn't know how someone could do something like this right after Hurricane Irma.
"If everybody did that, there'd be no sand dune left because everyone would want to see the beach instead of the end of a sand hill, but that's what it's there for," Holcomb said.
"We just had a hurricane, it blew a lot of things around so it's a bit silly of someone to take it upon themselves to do this though," Holcomb said.
Holcomb doesn't know how someone could do something like this right after Hurricane Irma.
"If everybody did that, there'd be no sand dune left because everyone would want to see the beach instead of the end of a sand hill, but that's what it's there for," Holcomb said.
© 2017 WTLV-TV
from WOKV:
ST. AUGUSTINE BEACH POLICE INVESTIGATING AFTER DUNES BULLDOZED FOR OCEAN VIEW
Photo Credit: Action News Jax
No comments:
Post a Comment