It takes a village!
Thanks to the Florida Governor and Cabinet, who sit as the Board of Directors of the Florida Internal Improvements Trust, and thanks to FIIT's former Executive Director for his wise counsel and sage advice ---the Honorable I. Henry Dean, County Commissioner, who wrote Amendment 1, helping make Florida Forever funds available to buy land and water for conservation, working with two UF professors and Sierra Club.
Thanks to Matanzas Riverkeeper Jen Lomberk, former City Archeologist Carl Halbirt and former St. Augustine Beach Mayor. S. Gary Snodgrass, among 50 witnesses at PZB hearings last year who helped stop D.R. Horton's proposed gated community on this land.
Thanks for support to Mayors Nancy Shaver and Tracy Upchurch, Vice Mayor Leanna Freeman and Commissioners Nancy Sikes-Kline, Roxanne Horvath and John Valdes, and City Manager John Patrick Regan, P.E., the Northeast Florida Land Trust, James McCarthy, James Sutton and the St. Augustine Record for coverage and editorials.
Some 50 people showed up and spoke at the August 7, 2018 PZB or July 3, 2018 hearings, also including: Joe Blewett, Amy Koch, Tim Lyman, Rhonda Lovett, Adam Morley, Gregg Feldman, Steve Parkin, J.R. Valentine, Brandon Murawski, Dr. Virginia Quelch, Dr. Greg Smith, Marsha Chance, Tammy Johns, Brian Paradise, Susan Hill, Jon Hodgin, Sara Bailey, Trey Asner, Richard Hardy, Erin Finney, Patricia Scott, Genarro Schiavelli, Kay Lee, Craig Williams, Karen Carter Lewis, Carl Halbert, Dorothy Barrett, Marcia Daniels, Logan Williams, Karen Lane, Gina Burrell, Carolyn Smith, Eric Smith, George Ellis, Tonya Salyer, Alex Barr, Tim Lyman, Tom Brinton, Christopher Wiggin, Lisa McGreevy, Diane Lewitt, Bob T, Ed Slavin, BJ Kalaidi, Doug O’Conner.
Three cheers for all who spoke, including Sierra Club and Audubon Society witnesses who photographed the active bald eagles’ nest, subject of possible developer perjury that would be prosecuted if we had more ethical officials.
Thanks also to D.R. Horton, Inc., Fish Island Development LLC, Jim Young, and RogersTowers Attorneys at Law lawyer Ellen Avery-Smith for not appealing from PZB’s wise final decision.
============
By Sheldon Gardner
Posted at 10:04 AM
Updated at 10:10 AM
St. Augustine Record
Gov. Ron DeSantis and the Cabinet approved the purchase of Fish Island in St. Augustine for $6.5 million in Florida Forever funds.
The decision came during this morning’s Florida Cabinet meeting.
The land is about 57 acres south of the State Road 312 bridge and on the east side of the Matanzas River. St. Augustine residents have pushed for Fish Island’s preservation, including fighting development of the property by D.R. Horton.
The city of St. Augustine has agreed to manage the property as a passive park.
St. Augustine Vice Mayor Leanna Freeman and Jim McCarthy, president of the North Florida Land Trust, spoke at the Cabinet meeting in support of the purchase. The land trust helped make the purchase happen.
“I believe that when we look back 50 years from now that we will be very excited for the legacy that we leave for generations to come,” Freeman said.
Check back later for more details.
-----------
Here is my column from the St. Augustine Record from Sunday, September 23, 2018:
GUEST COLUMN:
All aboard for Fish Island Park
By Ed Slavin / St. Johns County
Posted Sep 21, 2018 at 10:57 AM
Updated Sep 21, 2018 at 10:57 AM
St. Augustine woke up to wonderful news on Sept. 8, 2018, our 453rd anniversary. No appeal was filed by the developer of the proposed Fish Island gated community.
Thanks to Matanzas Riverkeeper Jen Lomberk and everyone else who organized, attended and spoke at the July 3 and Aug. 7 PZB hearings, and to those who tried to attend and speak. It was standing room only Aug. 7, with dozens waiting/watching TV on the loggia.
Decisions are made by people who show up. Three cheers for all who spoke, including Sierra Club and Audubon Society witnesses who photographed the active bald eagles’ nest, former St. Augustine Beach Mayor S. Gary Snodgrass and former St. Augustine City Archaeologist Carl Halbirt.
Thanks also to D.R. Horton, Inc., Fish Island Development LLC, Jim Young, and RogersTowers Attorneys at Law lawyer Ellen Avery-Smith for not appealing from PZB’s wise final decision.
For doing their jobs independently, based upon the law and facts, without fear or favor of vast corporate power and wealth, thanks and praise to PZB Chair Sarah Ryan and PZB members Grant Misterly, Karen Zander, Susan Agresta and Matthew Shaffer — the five PZB members who unanimously voted down the PUD. Thanks also to PZB member Carl Blow, who bailed on voting/participating after staff stigma/pressures in response to his asking questions of the applicant, in one of those ex parte meetings city officials must stop holding with developers.
Three cheers for PZB members’ independence, despite pestilential pressures from certain city staff and commissioners, some of whom expect PZB members to be louche lapdogs, not watchdogs (as when Commission adopted 4-1 Ordinance 2018-11, allowing “at will” firing of PZB. members).
What’s next? Preserving Fish Island as a public park. The City of St. Augustine Beach bought two parks with available state funds.
Why does it matter? Your future Fish Island Park embraces beautiful, natural waterfront and iconic viewshed; pristine, 75-acre Matanzas River wildlife habitat; homes for our bald eagles and other threatened and endangered species; historic site of Florida’s first citrus agriculture industry (mid-1700s), the burial place of Jesse Fish and his slaves, the site of remains of Fish’s mansion and some eight slave cabins; the last undeveloped, unprotected property bordering our pristine Matanzas River, a prime oyster-growing waterway (and perhaps Florida’s only remaining pristine estuary).
Prediction: Our Fish Island Park will become part of the St. Augustine National Historical Park and National Seashore, first proposed by Mayor Walter Fraser in 1939, introduced by then-Sens. Claude Pepper and Charles Andrews and Rep. Joseph Hendricks. Fish Island Park will help protect us from floods amidst ocean level rise, preserve Matanzas River water, wildlife and oyster quality and enhance environmental and historic tourism,
Do it for your grandchildren, and for their grandchildren: Now’s the time for organizing and action to help create Fish Island Park. Help out. Contact commissioners at both St. Augustine and the Beach, your five county commissioners, your state and federal legislators, and candidates — today.
Comments
Edward Adelbert Slavin
Some 50 people showed up and spoke at the August 7, 2018 PZB or July 3, 2018 hearings, also including: Joe Blewett, Amy Koch, Tim Lyman, Rhonda Lovett, Adam Morley, Gregg Feldman, Steve Parkin, J.R. Valentine, Brandon Murawski, Dr. Virginia Quelch, Dr. Greg Smith, Marsha Chance, Tammy Johns, Brian Paradise, Susan Hill, Jon Hodgin, Sara Bailey, Trey Asner, Richard Hardy, Erin Finney, Patricia Scott, Genarro Schiavelli, Kay Lee, Craig Williams, Karen Carter Lewis, Carl Halbert, Dorothy Barrett, Marcia Daniels, Logan Williams, Karen Lane, Gina Burrell, Carolyn Smith, Eric Smith, George Ellis, Tonya Salyer, Alex Barr, Tim Lyman, Tom Brinton, Christopher Wiggin, Lisa McGreevy, Diane Lewitt, Bob Lane, Ed Slavin, BJ Kalaidi, Doug O’Conner.
In a result that some call ‘a miracle,’ state approves purchase of Fish Island in St. Augustine
By Sheldon Gardner
Posted Jul 25, 2019 at 10:04 AM
Updated Jul 25, 2019 at 6:48 PM
The decision Thursday by Gov. Ron DeSantis and the Florida Cabinet to buy Fish Island in St. Augustine didn’t take long, maybe several minutes.
But the events leading up to the state’s decision to spend $6.5 million in Florida Forever funds to buy the land took extensive work. Now, 57 acres on the eastern edge of the Matanzas River south of the State Road 312 bridge are headed for preservation instead of development.
The area became the focus of developers in 2018, though the site had been unsuccessfully targeted for development before then.
That year, city residents banded together and successfully fought for the city’s Planning and Zoning Board to reject a residential development at the the site. Residents argued that the land was worth saving for its wildlife, natural beauty and history — it was a citrus plantation in the 1700s.
People formed a group called the Friends of Fish Island and worked with nonprofit Matanzas Riverkeeper, and people flooded the state with letters of support for the purchase.
The state’s decision also came from a hefty amount of coordination and work by environmental and land preservation officials, St. Augustine officials, elected officials and representatives of the property.
“In many ways it was a miracle,” said Jim McCarthy, president of the North Florida Land Trust, one of the key players in the deal. “I think that might be one way to describe it, to be able to pull this off. But we did a lot work, and by a lot of people. ... It truly is a great day.”
As for the site’s future, the city of St. Augustine has agreed to manage it as a passive park.
St. Augustine Vice Mayor Leanna Freeman spoke to DeSantis and the Cabinet in support of the purchase.
Freeman said at the meeting that while many things are divisive these days, preserving Fish Island has likely received wider support than any other project she’s seen.
“I believe that when we look back 50 years from now that we will be very excited for the legacy that we leave for generations to come,” Freeman said.
McCarthy said the state has about four months to close the purchase. That will provide time to do a routine review of the land.
While that’s happening, the city is expected to develop a management plan for the park before the sale closes. McCarthy said that’s an extensive process that typically takes the North Florida Land Trust six months to a year, but the organization offered to help the city get it done.
St. Augustine City Manager John Regan said the city will engage the community in developing the plan and will give everyone a chance to participate. After the closing, a community celebration needs to be held, he said.
On Tuesday, several people got a taste of what’s to come.
A representative of property owner Fish Island Development LLC, which is led by Jim Young, allowed a visit to the site. Several Friends of Fish Island, and some other visitors, explored the land.
The group walked along dirt paths through a wooded area toward the water, causing fiddler crabs to scurry across the ground. People pointed out sights along the way — a snake here, a collection of deer tracks there. The group moved past a pond where a group of egrets had gathered, and then walked toward the marshy area facing the Matanzas River.
Archaeologist Marsha Chance helped lead the way. About 15 years ago, she conducted archaeological research on Fish Island. Some artifacts are from when Jesse Fish made his home there and ran his citrus plantation with slave labor.
According to the North Florida Land Trust, “At one time, there were approximately 3,000 orange trees on the island, and the citrus was exported to England and Spain.”
For some of the Friends of Fish Island, their work was their first introduction to the history of the site and Jesse Fish. Some dedicated many hours of research to the work.
“We became historical advocates,” said Susan Hill, one such resident.
Chance added, “That’s one of the outstanding things about this whole project, is that people who’ve been involved may be our best historical advocates in the future for other things.”
As the group began to walk back to their cars, they discussed what it would feel like to win their battle for Fish Island. At that point on Tuesday, they were confident the state would approve the deal.
Matanzas Riverkeeper Jen Lomberk, who also visited the site, described it as surreal.
“You fight a lot of environmental fights where you’re the underdog, and you go into it knowing you’re going to lose but hoping you can just slow them down in the process, so to catch a high-profile win is fantastic,” she said.
Susan Hill said Jim Young deserves thanks.
“Without a willing seller this would never have happened, and he’s left an unbelievable legacy and an example of how you can leave conservation to the community and to the future,” Hill said. “And there’s a lot of parcels around here, a lot of beautiful parcels, and maybe other people will get the same idea. That’s what we hope.”
No comments:
Post a Comment