Ethics Complaints Considered for Probable Cause
During the Executive Session meeting, 6 ethics complaints were considered for probable cause.
Probable Cause Found Against West Palm Beach City Commission Candidate and Current Manager of the Orlando Utilities Commission
The Commission found probable cause to believe that Matthew Ferrer, a candidate for the West Palm Beach City Commission and current manager of the Orlando Utilities Commission, failed to accurately disclose secondary sources of income and real property on his 2024 Form 1 filing. Although probable cause was found, the Commission determined that no further action was warranted based upon the circumstances presented.
No Probable Cause Found in Flagler County Matter
The Commission found no probable cause on allegations that Flagler County Commission Chairman, Andy Dance, abused his position or provided a disproportionate benefit when evaluating the County Administrator while the Administrator employed his wife as an Executive Assistant. After reviewing the investigative record, the Commission concluded that the evidence did not support moving the case forward.
No Probable Cause Found in Chattahoochee City Manager Misuse Allegation
The Commission found no probable cause to believe that Robert Presnell, City Manager of Chattahoochee, misused his public position or violated the constitutional prohibition against abuse of office for a disproportionate benefit by exchanging City services for sexual favors. After reviewing the investigative materials, the Commission concluded the evidence was insufficient to justify moving the matter to a public hearing. This determination ended the Commission’s investigation without a finding of an ethics violation.
Voting Conflict Case Involving Bloomingdale Special Taxing District Board Member
The Commission found probable cause that Thomas Leech, President of the Bloomingdale Special Taxing District Board of Trustees, failed to file the required memorandum of voting conflict (Form 8B) after abstaining from a vote involving a staffing company employing his spouse. At the same time, the Commission found no probable cause on three additional voting-conflict allegations arising from the same matter and elected to take no further action on the Form 8B allegation based on the circumstances.
No Probable Cause Found Regarding Social Media Posts Made by Miami-Dade County Tax Collector
The Commission also found no probable cause on allegations that Miami-Dade County Tax Collector, Dariel Fernandez, misused his office by appearing in social media videos that endorsed local businesses while identifying himself by his public title and displaying the Tax Collector’s seal. Although the complaint raised questions regarding the use of official office in connection with private businesses, the Commission determined that the evidence did not establish a violation warranting further proceedings.
Probable Cause Found Regarding Financial Disclosure Allegations Against Community Development District Official
The Commission found probable cause on allegations that Julianne Giella failed to accurately disclose real property on her 2023 and 2024 Form 1 financial disclosure filings and failed to certify completion of the required ethics training on her 2024 disclosure. However, the allegation that she failed to complete the required ethics training for calendar year 2024 was dismissed with a finding of no probable cause.
Complaint Withdrawn
The Commission granted the complainant’s request to withdraw a complaint filed against Altamonte Springs City Manager, Franklin W. Martz II, thereby terminating the matter without further proceedings.