VoteWaater mailing:
ALLIGATOR ALCATRAZ: ‘EFFICIENT, LOW-COST’ DEBACLE IS UTHMEIER’S FOLLY
On July 1, 2025, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier posted on X to celebrate his masterpiece.
“Alligator Alcatraz = efficient and cost effective. It’s a one stop shop for immigration enforcement,” he crowed.
One stop shop for fleecing Florida taxpayers is more like it.
This week the New York Times reported that the state plans to shut the whole thing down as officials with the federal Department of Homeland Security “have concluded that the Everglades center is ineffective and too expensive to run.” The detention center Uthmeier built in the heart of the Everglades is costing Florida more than $1 million a day to operate; some vendors say the state hasn’t paid invoices for months. The federal government was supposed to cover at least some of the costs but the money hasn’t arrived. No one seems to know when — or whether — it will.
Uthmeier must be so proud.
All last summer Uthmeier, the alleged mastermind behind Alligator Alcatraz, was its most ardent promoter. The world first heard the phrase “Alligator Alcatraz” when Uthmeier appeared on Fox Business on June 17, 2025. Two days later he posted a minute-long video on X extolling the “efficient, low-cost opportunity to build a temporary detention facility” at the Dade-Collier Training and Transition Airport.
“Efficient.” “Low-cost.” File those away.
The name was the whole game: pithy and engineered to enrage liberals. You had to wonder whether they chose the name to match the site, or the site to match the name. Either way, the merchandise sold like hotcakes.
It was all very Trumpian — and indeed, when the President visited on July 1, he had warm words for Uthmeier, a DeSantis appointee who just happened to be running for election and badly needed the name recognition. Alligator Alcatraz delivered. A brand was born. A political career was briefly turbocharged.
Then reality showed up with an invoice.
Lawsuits multiplied. Costs ballooned. Vendor weren’t getting paid. State officials assured Floridians the feds would pony up; Florida applied for nearly $1.5 billion in FEMA grants. FEMA approved $608 million. The check has not arrived. And when it does, it may prove a point in the ongoing lawsuit by Friends of the Everglades and allied conservation groups — who argue that federal funding makes this a federal facility, subject to the National Environmental Policy Act and its requirement that agencies assess environmental impacts before acting.
Uthmeier insists NEPA doesn’t apply. But in February, his own lawyers conceded in an 11th Circuit filing that “The State took the risk (and still does) that federal funding will not materialize.”
Translation: if Washington doesn’t pay, Tallahassee does. And if Tallahassee pays, you do.
Efficient. Low-cost.
At a press conference last week Governor DeSantis insisted the federal money was coming. But tellingly, during that press conference the Governor spoke about the facility for almost six minutes straight without ever once using the term “Alligator Alcatraz.”
Uthmeier, for his part, has gone conspicuously quiet on the detention center. His political star has dimmed; one recent poll has him trailing presumptive Democratic nominee (and VoteWater endorsee) Jose Javier Rodriguez.
Turns out that the more the public knows about Uthmeier — “Hey, isn’t he the guy behind Alligator Alcatraz?” — the less they like him.
What began as a propaganda coup has curdled into a costly, litigation-soaked embarrassment — one that deserves to hang around Uthmeier’s neck like a millstone.
Florida deserves an Attorney General who treats the law, the environment, and the public treasury as things to be protected rather than sacrificed for a punchline. Jose Javier Rodriguez is that candidate.
Uthmeier promised a one-stop shop. He delivered: one environmentally damaging facility, one huge political miscalculation, one attorney general who bet the public’s money on a stunt and lost.
The question for Florida voters is simple: Why would you rehire the guy who sold you this?
No comments:
Post a Comment