From MS NOW:
A DOJ division was built to protect communities from environmental danger — then it started dropping cases
The Trump administration gutted the Justice Department division responsible for enforcing laws that protect Americans’ air, water and lands, and walked away from vulnerable communities in need of help.
Justice Denied is a series examining how the Justice Department under President Trump shuttered investigations and cases — and what happened to the people and communities who say they were denied justice.
In late 2024, Justice Department prosecutors learned of insiders with a jaw-dropping claim about Southern Coal and its sister companies, a powerful mining conglomerate found to have polluted waterways near its mostly Appalachian mine sites for years.
Former employees said they had information that this coal empire, owned by Republican Sen. Jim Justice of West Virginia and largely run by his son, had falsified lab tests meant to detect water pollution from its operations, according to two people familiar with the case. The people who spoke to MS NOW were granted anonymity in order to speak freely about a DOJ investigation.
This worrisome new lead, the details of which have not been previously reported, set off alarm bells for members of the Justice Department division that enforces environmental laws, according to the sources.
In February 2025, DOJ prosecutors opened a criminal investigation, concerned that Southern Coal officials might be intentionally violating the law and a settlement the company struck with the Justice Department in 2016. In that deal, Southern Coal avoided paying a maximum of $880 million in fines for more than 23,000 alleged pollution violations across five states — by agreeing to pay a $900,000 fine, upgrade pollution controls and comply with the law.
But just when the Justice Department team was poised to check the insiders’ claims, the office of then-Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche ordered the prosecutors to withdraw subpoenas they had just issued for company records. The team was told to shut down the criminal investigation entirely, the sources told MS NOW.
The order, they said, came soon after James McDonald, an attorney from Sullivan & Cromwell, a Manhattan law firm representing Southern Coal, contacted Blanche’s office to raise objections. Blanche and McDonald had both worked as personal lawyers defending Donald Trump against a New York hush money case that had resulted in his 2024 criminal conviction.
Former Justice Department officials say the sudden intervention of top appointees to withdraw subpoenas and close the Southern Coal case deviates dramatically from the department’s norm.
“It’s unheard of,” said Rick Mountcastle, a former U.S. attorney in the Western District of Virginia, whose office helped bring the civil lawsuit against Southern Coal and its affiliates.
“To have a case shut down before the investigation is anywhere near completion,” he said, “it’s really troubling.”
In an email, the Justice Department told MS NOW it “did not shutter any investigation.”
Steven Ruby, a lawyer for Sen. Justice’s family businesses, said that the companies believe the allegations came from disgruntled former employees and that after Southern Coal and related businesses gave the Justice Department evidence refuting its claims, it “found no basis to continue an investigation.”
Sullivan & Cromwell did not reply to MS NOW’s request for comment.
But the probe’s quick death is part of a broader pattern in President Trump’s second term, a six-month investigation by MS NOW has found.
Since early 2025, Trump’s political lieutenants in the Justice Department have shut down numerous investigations when the subject has been a powerful corporation or a well-heeled ally of the president and his administration. This story focuses on a string of environmental cases in which those lieutenants ordered federal prosecutors and career attorneys to walk away from compelling leads and evidence of potential wrongdoing and environmental danger. Legal experts told MS NOW that in prior administrations the department would have normally pursued those leads.
To have a case shut down before the investigation is anywhere near completion … it’s really troubling.”
Rick Mountcastle, former U.S. attorney
In the early weeks after Trump’s return to office, the division canceled a long-planned trial of a chemical company emitting the carcinogen chloroprene, which was blamed for dramatically increased cancer rates in the adjoining neighborhood. Over the ensuing months, it shut down criminal probes into Southern Coal and its affiliates as well as a major commercial fishing operator in North Carolina. When Trump ally Elon Musk’s company opened an unpermitted power plant, considered one of the largest sources of air pollution in the nation, Trump’s DOJ not only declined to act, but tried to block citizens from suing Musk’s company.
The Southern Coal example showcases the ways Trump appointees have gutted the Justice Department’s efforts to enforce environmental laws that seek to protect American’s air, water and, ultimately, public health, former department officials told MS NOW.
Laura Thoms, a supervisor and an attorney who departed DOJ’s Environment and Natural Resources Division last year, calls Trump’s second presidency an “open season for polluters” and finds “the consequences for polluting have all but vanished.” Enforcement cases brought by the section have “fallen off a cliff” since Trump’s inauguration, she found in a review, less than a third of the previous year.
And the civil penalties collected against polluters have quickly cratered too. In 2024, the DOJ collected $1.88 billion in civil environmental penalties. In 2025, after Trump took office, his DOJ collected $15 million — less than 1% of the previous year.
Since Blanche officially renamed it the Energy and Natural Resources Division in September, the once powerful unit is estimated to be down to almost half its staff since Trump took office, due to forced exits and departures.
In the faraway Appalachian mountain towns of southern West Virginia, residents say they are paying the price for what they believe is the Justice Department’s retreat from enforcing environmental laws — and a full investigation of Southern Coal and its affiliated companies. Without probing for answers, experts tell MS NOW, neither the government nor the public can determine whether a coal empire owned by a Trump ally and one of the Senate’s richest members is polluting the local drinking water, or whether it’s another company in the area. These communities will not learn who is responsible for their tainted water and the ailments they say they continue to suffer.
Residents MS NOW interviewed in West Virginia’s Wyoming County said they have been unable to safely drink or bathe in the water that comes from their faucets at home. They said independent water tests had found high levels of heavy metals, including lead, arsenic and manganese, sometimes 10 or even 100 times higher than what the Environmental Protection Agency considers safe.
Richard Altizer, a resident and community advocate, showed MS NOW places where creeks and rivers had turned bright orange, white and even black from suspected mine contamination. He said the community was relying on the DOJ probe to get answers — and protection.
“So somewhere along the line, these places have contaminated people’s drinking water and shower water. We know that,” he said. “But dropping that investigation … The Justice Department was the only hope we had.”
Residents and their family members have been diagnosed with cancers, liver failure, thyroid dysfunction and other diseases often associated with heavy metal exposure. Many pay hundreds of dollars a week for water to drink and cook with.
“From the water, I have third-stage kidney failure,” said Pansy Keene, a local resident who said she also suffered from rashes and a high risk of liver disease. She and many fellow residents blame the polluted drainage from local mining sites, including those owned by the Justice companies.
But dropping that investigation … The Justice Department was the only hope we had.”
Richard Altizer, community activist in Wyoming County, West Virginia
Residents complain that they backed Trump for president but feel he turned his back on them.
“I’m 100% in support of Donald Trump. But I want to say this much: Show me you care,” said resident Barry Brooks. “The people in this state backed you, backed you to the hilt. Now it’s time for you to back us.”
“He should be ashamed of himself,” Keene said. “He wouldn’t want not one member of his family to have to live like we are.”
Kate Waldeck, a West Virginia pediatrician, said that among the local children she treats, there is a high frequency of ailments often linked to heavy metals. Local water tests reveal a toxic risk, she said; her most urgent advice to local parents is not to use tap water to make infant formula.
She said the Justice Department owed the people of West Virginia a full investigation.
“If the federal government thought that there was sufficient evidence to meet the bar of criminal activity affecting the people’s health in the state and nothing is being done about it, I think that that is unethical,” Waldeck said.
The first hint of what Trump and his team planned for the Justice Department’s efforts to curb pollution and enforce environmental laws came within days of his inauguration. A string of supervisors were reassigned or demoted.
Tom Mariani, a 40-year veteran and well-respected chief of the environmental enforcement section of the Environment and Natural Resources Division, had spent considerable time trying to assure career attorneys in his section that he would try to shield them if he had to so they could continue their mission. But hours later, he was notified that he was being transferred to a “sanctuary cities” project that had no actual duties.
The next blow came a few short weeks later. ENRD attorneys had been preparing for their upcoming civil trial against a company called Denka, which operated a neoprene plant releasing the probable carcinogen chloroprene in a Louisiana industrial corridor known as “Cancer Alley.” A public health survey in 2021 titled “Waiting to Die” found residents of this census tract in St. John the Baptist Parish had the nation’s highest risk of cancer from air pollution due to the chloroprene emissions from the Denka plant.
Robert Taylor, founder of a parish advocacy group seeking to hold polluters accountable and inform residents, said that for years he and his neighbors saw community members die from cancer without understanding the risk in their community. He said he didn’t learn the cancer risk from the Denka plant emissions until EPA officials shared their air toxics study of the area in 2015.
“I could go on endlessly talking about the horrors of watching my close relatives die of cancer,” he said. “It’s a horrible way to die.”
In 2023, under the Biden administration, the Justice Department filed an emergency lawsuit against Denka under the Clean Air Act, after the EPA determined that the plant created an “imminent and substantial” risk to the adjoining neighbors, most of whom were Black.
But in March 2025, on the eve of a preparatory hearing on the Denka trial that was to start in April, DOJ supervisors notified the trial team attorneys that political appointees concluded their case was too “novel,” according to people with knowledge of the discussions. The case would be dismissed, they said.
The trial team, as well as attorneys across the DOJ, were stunned by the department press release that quickly followed the same day.
It claimed that the dismissal helped fulfill Trump’s promise to eradicate “radical” race-based policies. In the release, the division’s acting assistant attorney general, Adam Gustafson, said the DOJ would now enforce environmental laws “fairly, without regard to race.”
“We do not regulate through litigation, nor do we stretch statutes beyond their plain meaning to advance political agendas,” his statement read.
In a statement, a DOJ spokesperson said the complaint against Denka “relied on the Clean Air Act’s rarely invoked ‘Emergency Powers’ provision,” based on the EPA finding “imminent and substantial” danger to the public.
But the spokesperson said the department dismissed the Denka case after finding that the Biden administration used that provision to further its “ongoing effort to advance environmental justice.”
The DOJ also said that while it “sympathize[s] with anyone who has lost a loved one,” it had “no information attributing any particular illness or mortality to neoprene production.”
Early in 2025, prosecutors at ENRD believed they had a solid factual basis to launch a criminal investigation into Southern Coal and the mining empire of Sen. Justice. A key part of the case came from whistleblowers.
In the previous six years, records show, the Justice Department had been going to court to get Southern Coal and its affiliates to comply with the settlement agreement the Justice family companies had promised to abide by in 2016. The government argued that the company had violated the agreement in several ways, including failing to pay penalties and to meet a deadline for promised pollution controls in Tennessee.
Most importantly, DOJ said, Southern Coal companies were flouting the law by letting some of its pollution discharge permits expire and not properly reporting pollution leaking into waterways. Southern Coal responded that the consent decree did not expressly state that it had to renew its pollution permits.
A federal appellate court called out the “absurdity” of Southern Coal’s logic, saying that the settlement broadly required the company to comply with pollution laws. It couldn’t do an “end-run” to ignore the law by letting its permits expire, the court ruled.
Amid this battle, the DOJ learned of two former employees who said they had information indicating that Southern Coal or its sister companies were falsifying some water test results, people familiar with the discussions said. Such tests were supposed to detect whether and when the companies’ mining operations violated pollution limits.
If you look at Jim Justice and how he loves the people of West Virginia, and how he’s treated the people of West Virginia, that is so blatantly false at some point.”
Sen. Jim Justice, R-W.Va., responding to claims that his family businesses have harmed his state’s residents
ENRD’s environmental crimes section swung into action in early 2025, and later that year sent subpoenas for internal company records, which the office of Assistant Attorney General Stanley Woodward approved, the people said. Prosecutors issued a second set of subpoenas, this time to obtain the lab test results. Southern Coal went to court to block the request for its records, claiming they should be withheld because of attorney-client privilege.
In February 2026, attorneys later learned, while prosecutors awaited the judge’s decision on getting the company records, McDonald contacted Blanche’s office to object. Shortly after, Blanche’s deputies ordered the ENRD supervisors to have their team withdraw the subpoenas for the company records and the water test results. They were also told to shut down the criminal probe, the people said.
Representatives for Southern Coal and the DOJ both said in statements to MS NOW that there was not sufficient evidence to pursue a criminal probe.
An attorney for the Justice family said it had a “nearly 20-year professional relationship” with Sullivan & Cromwell “that has nothing to do with President Trump.”
“We take seriously our duty to ensure all Americans have clean air and water,” a DOJ spokesperson said. “We work with investigating agencies to follow the facts of any case and ensure any violations are appropriately addressed.”
In an interview outside his Capitol Hill office, Justice said questions about Southern Coal should be directed to his son, who runs the business. But the senator disputed that any water tests were falsified.
“I think every bit of that is bogus as bogus can be,” he said. “There is no chance, no chance whatsoever, that we’ve been involved in anything like that.”
Justice said his family business would not harm residents of his state.
“And do I believe that we’re the cause of people having bad water or we’re the cause that people having water that they can’t bathe in and everything else?” Justice said. “If you look at Jim Justice and how he loves the people of West Virginia, and how he’s treated the people of West Virginia, that is so blatantly false at some point. “
He declined to answer additional questions and left with his staff to prepare for a birthday party he was hosting for his beloved bulldog, Babydog.
But the residents in West Virginia say they feel abandoned by the DOJ decision. They say they considered the federal investigation their only hope for a solution.
Community members told MS NOW they couldn’t move away because it’s too hard to sell homes with undrinkable water. Altizer, the community advocate, has spent his own money testing water to show the problem. He said the Trump administration’s decision made him feel his work and research had been a waste.
“Because if you’re not going to hold the people accountable, then why even try to fix the problem?” Altizer said. “And that just gives [the company] a license to create anything they want to do back here.”
Stephen New, an attorney for some residents who are suing companies owned by the Justice family, said the Trump administration had a duty to first protect West Virginians who can’t safely drink from their faucet, not the company profits of a wealthy Republican politician.
“We’re spending a billion dollars a day in a war in Iran that doesn’t need to be fought,” New said, “while our people live in a Third World country situation.”
In the early spring of 2026, ENRD prosecutors had taken a big step in a long-simmering criminal probe of a major commercial fishing operation in North Carolina and a man known in the area as “the King of Shrimp.”
They drafted a criminal indictment of Brent Fulcher and his company, Beaufort Inlet Seafood, according to two people familiar with the plan. The prosecutors proposed charging Fulcher with wire fraud and obstruction of justice, based on evidence that he and his firm fraudulently underreported their fish catches to avoid violating limits.
It is a federal crime to underreport fish catches that exceed legal quotas set for some fish. Underreporting allows dishonest operators to flood the market with cheaper, undocumented seafood, and such secret overfishing can lead to the collapse of a fishing stock.
The investigators had video evidence of Fulcher and other company officials on his company docks, from November 2021 to January 2022, to receive fish catches as they were hauled out of the fishing boats and weighed.
Then, one morning in late January 2022, federal investigators raided the offices of a Fulcher seafood business and carried out boxes of records.
The federal team found that thousands more pounds of fish were delivered onto Fulcher’s docks, as seen on the video, than the amount his company reported it had received to regulators, according to people with knowledge of the case. Fulcher and his company, the team concluded, had underreported $1 million and $2 million worth of fish.
The investigation stretched on for several years, exploring different leads, and neared the end in early 2026, when prosecutors drafted their indictment. But on June 11, as the DOJ team considered when to bring charges, its prospective defendant appeared on television as an Oval Office guest of Trump’s in a public ceremony about marine fisheries. The event was held for Trump to sign a proclamation to reopen some Pacific waters for commercial fishing.
“I’m from North Carolina but support you 100%,” Fulcher said as video cameras broadcast his effusive praise for the president. “You have done more for this nation in the seafood space than any president before you in my lifetime. Thank you, sir.”
In the next several weeks, Justice Department supervisors told their team they were reviewing the merits of the Fulcher case, people familiar with the discussion said. Then, in August, supervisors told prosecutors that political appointees had decided against pursuing criminal charges. Investigators were frustrated, believing the evidence warranted prosecution. Instead, the people said, DOJ leaders proposed civil penalties against Fulcher and his company.
A White House spokesperson denied any improper political interference by the White House in the DOJ case.
A DOJ spokesperson said the department “pursues or declines to pursue cases based on the facts and the law,” and “is unwavering in its commitment to working on behalf of the American people and upholding federal law.”
Separately, a White House official, who declined to be named in order to discuss internal planning, told MS NOW that the White House was “not aware of any investigation into Fulcher” and that the U.S. Department of Agriculture recommended he be invited to the Oval Office event.
Fulcher did not respond to email requests for comment, but as he attended a North Carolina seafood festival in Morehead City in September, MS NOW asked him in person about the DOJ’s proposed indictment and evidence.
“I really don’t have any comments,” Fulcher said. “But I think a lot of what you just told me, I don’t think is exactly correct. … I don’t have any comment about it until it’s all resolved.”
Days after we spoke with Fulcher, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration sent him and his company a letter concluding that they had violated federal fishing laws and imposing a $1.2 million fine.
Fulcher’s legal team declined our questions on the matter.
But North Carolina fishermen and conservation advocates say they find the DOJ’s closure of the criminal case a terrible message to alleged scofflaws — and to the broader public.
“If you don’t enforce the laws, then … the resources don’t restore or recover,” said Louis Daniel, the former director of the state’s Division of Marine Fisheries. “And so any time you get a case that’s dismissed for whatever reason, that sends a message that it’s OK or it’s the cost of doing business.”
“I can’t describe how important it is to me as a Marine that we have justice, because everything is meaningless without it,” said Steven Brewster, a veteran, recreational fisherman and advocate for local fisheries. “And what you’re telling the people of North Carolina is that you don’t need to follow the rules.”
In 1970, when Congress passed the landmark Clean Air Act, lawmakers recognized that the federal government might fail to enforce environmental laws, so the public needed special protection in that case. They created a special right for citizens to sue polluters on their own if the government was sitting on the sidelines.
Former Attorney General Ramsey Clark said at the time that years of experience had taught Americans that “government will never have the manpower, the techniques or the awareness necessary to enforce the law for all.”
“It will be impossible for government enforcement to control all significant acts of pollution,” Clark said. “Private enforcement of those laws is the only way the individual can be assured that the rights cannot be violated with impunity.”
Congress added similar rights for citizens to sue to several environmental statutes that followed, including the Clean Water Act and the Toxic Substances Control Act.
That would prove important after Thoms, the former DOJ attorney, left ENRD in 2025 and joined the legal team of Earthjustice, a nonprofit environmental public interest group.
An interesting case came to her attention not long into her tenure at her new job: the enormous power plant that xAI, one of Elon Musk’s companies, was building in Mississippi to help power his data centers nearby. The company did not obtain air permits before installing methane gas turbines, which regulators normally deem illegal. It began with 27 turbines and later grew to 69 turbines.
Musk’s company said it was exempt from permitting because the turbines were movable and temporary. It later obtained permits for some of the turbines.
Earthjustice said the plant is one of the largest sources of air pollution in the nation, and pollutants from turbine engines, including nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter and formaldehyde, are associated with increased cases of asthma, heart disease, respiratory illnesses, certain cancers and premature death.
A new study from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology found that the plant’s turbines release nitrogen oxides at levels 19 times higher than what is allowed under the law. MS NOW has reached out to xAI for comment on the study but has not yet received a response.
Thoms knew a Clean Air Act violation when she saw one. She and Earthjustice colleagues joined with the Southern Environmental Law Center to file a citizens’ suit on behalf of the NAACP and the predominantly Black communities surrounding the power plant.
Then Trump’s DOJ took an unprecedented step. It filed to intervene in the case and to block the NAACP’s citizens’ suit from going forward. The government claimed that the suit could harm national security by cutting power to data centers for artificial intelligence that supports the Defense Department.
In mid-October the district court judge handling the xAI case denied the government’s motion to dismiss the case and said there was “no ‘fairly possible’ interpretation of the Clean Air Act that would give the United States the right to unilaterally dismiss a citizen suit once it intervenes.”
As the Southern Environmental Law Center put it: “The District Court ruled that the DOJ does not have the right to unilaterally block the case and rejected the department’s argument that xAI should be allowed to break the law solely because the Trump administration says so.”
Thoms says she is heartened that the court recognized the citizens’ right to sue. She and national legal experts remain floored that Trump’s DOJ didn’t just fail to enforce the law, it denied residents’ right to protect themselves.
“This is an administration that not only refuses to enforce bedrock environmental laws, it’s shutting down lawsuits against the president’s allies and donors,” Thoms said. “Now, Trump’s DOJ is trying to take away the right of ordinary people to protect themselves from illegal pollution when the government fails to act.”
“All communities deserve clean air,” she added, “and whether the protections promised by environmental law are real shouldn’t depend on if a powerful industry or friend of the president is involved.”
You can see more of this reporting on “State of Play” on MS NOW on Thursday, Nov. 19, at 11 a.m. ET.

Kay Guerrero
Kay Guerrero is a senior producer of newsgathering for MS NOW.


No comments:
Post a Comment