Monday, November 06, 2023

ANNALS OF DeSANTISTAN: 3-2 GQP Vote Continues Developers' Deforestation Orgy in St. Johns County

Update: these three corporate cat's paws support overdevelopment in St. Johns County.  Unjust stewards of worker and environmental protection -- it's time for them to go! 


Clearcutting will continue unabated here in St. Johns County, thanks to three unjust stewards, double-minded puppets of devious developers.   See Jessica Clark's First Coast News story, here.
Watch video here:

Two of the three developer toadies were appointed by Governor RONALD DION DeSANTIS.  

Slouching toward the 2024 election, what rough beasts voted to defeat proposed tree protection laws?
  • Extremist rebarbative anti-LGBTQ Republican apparatchik ROY ALYRE ALAIMO, JR. (left), a former DeSANTIS Congressional staffer, was appointed County Commissioner by Governor RONALD DION DeSANTIS, who said in a press release ALAIMO's "business" is "ALAIMO STRATEGIES," a new LLC established days before the appointment.  ALAIMO has ignored my questions about his business. Recently ALAIMO said he wants to give developers more "tax incentives."  
  • SARAH ARNOLD (center) was appointed County Commissioner by Governor RONALD DION DeSANTIS; she was elected in a closed 2022 Republican Primary, with giant signs bragging on the DeSANTIS appointment, outspending better candidates like Charles Labanowski.
  • CHRISTIAN WHITEHURST (right) was elected in 2020 and his term expires in 2024.
Clearcutting developers are generous campaign contributors to St. Johns County's controlling Republicans and our former Congressman, RONALD DION DeSANTIS, a flailing presidential candidate who never did anything for our District, 2013-2018, while appearing on faux Fox News forty (40) times.



Owner of one of the fastest-growing real estate firms in the Nation, conflicted Developer-Senator 
TRAVIS JAMES HUTSON with newly elected cat's paw Commissioner, now Commission Chairman 
 CHRI$TIAN WHITEHUR$T and conflicted Republican Executive Committee Chair and DeSANTIS appointee as Clerk of Courts and Comptroller BRANDON J. PATTY, on election night 2020.

Developers' orgy of deforestation will continue, by 3-2 vote by our all-Republican Commissioners.  Three louche developer lapdogs voted against the tree ordinance discussion proposed by new Commissioner Krista Keating Joseph and seconded by Commissioner I. Henry Dean.   Supporting clearcutting developers were the usual suspects, these three uneducated developer cat's paws County Commission Chairman CHRISTIAN WHITEHURST, who has a business replacing watch batteries, and his pal, Vice Chair SARAH ARNOLD (neither one a college graduate), and newly appointed Commissioner ROY ALYRE ALAIMO, JR., who did go to college).  

100 countries have pledged to end deforestation by 2030.  But money-hungry developers still rule St. Johns County, a/k/a "God's Country," which developers are trying to turn into an unreasonable facsimile of Broward County, Florida or Richardson, Texas, the two places where misanthropic MICHAEL DAVID WANCHICK worked before he was County Administrator here, 2007-2019. Both sibilant Stepford Wife SARAH ARNOLD and supercilious homophobe ROY ALYRE ALAIMO, JR. are appointees of Florida Republican Governor RONALD DION DeSANTS, a presidential candidate.  ARNOLD was elected  in 2022.  Their machine's benefactors, large multinational corporate developers, landowners and their keiretsu, got another shot in the arm on Tuesday, after some 40 witnesses, mostly opposed to clear-cutting and tree killing.  Clearcutting regulations were rejected on a tense 3-2 vote in the St. Johns County Commission, after a limp, wimpy staff report, in putative response to Commissioner Krista Keating Joseph's fourteen-point initiative.      Opponents, including Commissioner WHITEHURST, used smear and fear tactics, suggesting that killing trees makes money and creates jobs, while protecting trees would cause economic hardship.  Chairman WHITEHURST, speaking de hors the record, even suggested the law would somehow violate the Bert J. Harris Private Property Protection Act.  Our orotund County Attorney, DAVID MICHAEL MIGUT, stayed silent, allowing the disinformation to be spewed. No economic analysis.  None.   No environmental impact report on the effects of clearcutting and overdevelopment on our wildlife, wetlands and way of life. Faster than a speeding dump truck, what we know and love about St. Johns County is being destroyed by clearcutting and overdevelopment.  Dozens of witnesses at the St. Johns County Commission meeting on October 17, 2023 testified eloquently about the destruction of wildlife and the willful heedless destruction of natural beauty.It was to no avail, as good 'ole boy slogans and shibboleths were spewed.  There was no economist testimony in support that protecting trees would hurt anyone's precious profits.  St. Johns County has a chief economist, but he did not testify: if he did, he'd have to agree that trees are beneficial. 

Rev. Dr.  Martin Luther King, Jr. called St. Johns County "the most lawless" place in America.  He was right in 1964, and he'd be right now.  A former St. Johns County Commission Chairman went to federal prison for bribery. The recently resigned St. Johns County Administrator, an unindicted coconspirator (Clerk E) in a federal bribery case, never had a background check and got the job without an application, and without considering any other candidates.

Since 2000, only Republicans have served on St. Johns County Commission, the result of 1998 gerrymandering, which eliminated two at-large seats and five single-member districts, while substituting five Commissioners from districts, elected County-wide.  Every single vote for overdevelopment was by Republican County Commissioners.









Three unqualified, other-directed St. Johns County Commissioners voted in lockstep.  As if afflicted by lockjaw, they couldn't say anything substantive in response to reform Commissioner Krista Keating Joseph's fourteen points. 



Our planet is being turned into a "piece of filth" by overdevelopment, pollution and human greed, as Pope Francis wrote in his encyclical, Laudato Si. 


Under one-party rule, Commissioners funded by developer-Senator TRAVIS JAMES HUTSON rule the County.

Our one-party rule County Commission has now continued the trend with their gutless 3-2 vote not to pursue tree protection laws in the face of deforestation by developers, led by developer-Senator TRAVIS JAMES HUTSON.   

Here in the county that includes St. Augustine , named for the African bishop and scholar, our putative County leader

Thanks to Commissioners Krista Keating Joseph and I. Henry Dean for their environmental stewardship.  

No thanks at all to developer-Senator TRAVIS HUTSON's three unctuous, nasty unjust stewards, former DeSANTIS Congressional staffer ROY ALYRE ALAIMO, Jr., whom DeSANTIS appointed to a vacant County Commission seat before Christmas in 2022, and the dupery duo of CHRISTIAN WHITEHURST and SARAH ARNOLD, whom DeSANTIS appointed to a vacant Commission seat in December 2021, both Christmas presents for halfwit half-a-billionaire developer-Senator TRAVIS JAMES HUTSON.


Like slavery, strip-mining, child labor, pollution and other substantive evils, deforestation  clearcutting is evil and must be ended.  

Remember when there were good Republicans, like Abraham Lincoln, who worked ceaselessly to abolish slavery?




Krista Keating Joseph and Henry Dean were right, listening to the people about our environmental crisis, almost Churchillian in their courage against the feculent fascist forces of environmental crimes.

Do developer-Senator TRAVIS JAMES HUTSON and other devious developers own and control our County Commissioners, or just  rent them?  You tell me.

At least two of our five Commissioners are listening to us, like British Prime Minister Sir Winston Spencer Churchill.    




We will halt hurtful tree-killing.  

As Pope Francis has said in 2015 and 2023, we face a global environmental crisis.

It is no time for HUTSON's hick hacks to malign our response.  Enough flummery, dupery and nincompoopery. 

My father volunteered for military service, the day after Pearl Harbor, in 1941, at age 28.

Today's deforestation is our generation's Pearl Harbor.,

We know what needs to be done.

Now. As President Franklin Delano Roosevelt said, "Do not tell me it can't be done." 



As Churchill said, "We shall never surrender."



Be sure to watch Commissioners Arnold, Alaimo and Whitehurst in their sophistry. Disgraceful and disrespectful.  
They lack self-respect, making hollow arguments they don't believe in, benefitting their benefactors.  
They showed disrespect to Commissioner Joseph, whom we elected to take on overdevelopment.  Both Alaimo and Whitehurst must face the voters in 2024. Let's send them out door in 24.


Sunday, November 05, 2023

November 5, 1999

In August 1993, the late David Brian Wallace and I visited St. Augustine and St. Johns County, twice, on the way to and from visiting South Florida.  I was exhausted after the sixteen day trial in the whistleblower case of C.D. Varnadore v. Oak Ridge National Laboratory. 

That month, we both fell in love with St. Augustine and St. Johns County and its history and nature.  Georgio Moroder's "From Here to Eternity" was playing on Brian's fancy-bears CD player in his pale baby-blue 1984 Toyota lift- back automobile, an almost-antique, one that was substantially unencumbered by air conditioning (and the AC conversion kits, which the Maryland or D.C. used car salesman told him about during my absence while trying the Varnadore v. ORNL trial no longer existed).

On November 5, 1999, we moved together to St. Augustine.  That was 24 years ago.  Glad we did.  So much history, some of it documented on this blog.  Corruption exposed, wrongdoers punished, American values protected and defended against the formidable forces of fascism in our town and our time, in a place that the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. called "the most lawless" in America.

Earlier today tonight, several fine St. Augustine friends and I attended a Democratic fundraiser in St. Johns, Florida, in a neighborhood bordering Jacksonville and Duval County.  

President Franklin Delano Roosevelt said at Franklin Field, in Philadelphia, in 1944, "I felt the crowd, and it warmed me." I was not yet born. My father was recovering from Nazi shrapnel that hit is knee in Normandy, recovering in Army hospitals, including Amarillo, Texas. 

A year from tonight is the 2024 General Election.


What's next?

To be continued..... 

Friday, November 03, 2023

Ex-State Department official sentenced to nearly 6 years in prison for Capitol riot attacks. (AP/WaPo)

It happened in America, on January 6, 2021: a Marine Corps veteran and DONALD JOHN TRUMP political appointee to the State Department, now sentenced to nearly six years in prison for attacking our United States Capitol Police officers.  From AP/Washington Post: 


Ex-State Department official sentenced to nearly 6 years in prison for Capitol riot attacks

Add to your saved stories

WASHINGTON — A Marine Corps veteran who served as a politically appointed State Department official in former President Donald Trump's administration was sentenced on Friday to nearly six years in prison for attacking police officers during the Jan. 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capitol.


Federico Klein joined other Trump supporters in one of the most violent episodes of the Jan. 6 siege — a mob’s fight with outnumbered police for control of a tunnel entrance on the Capitol’s Lower West Terrace. Klein repeatedly assaulted officers, urged other rioters to join the fray and tried to stop police from shutting entrance doors, according to federal prosecutors.

Klein “waged a relentless siege on police officers” as he tried to enter the Capitol and stop Congress from certifying Joe Biden’s electoral victory over Trump, prosecutors said in a court filing.


Klein, who didn’t testify at his trial, declined to address the court before U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden sentenced him to five years and 10 months in prison.

“Your actions on January 6th were shocking and egregious,” the judge told Klein.

McFadden also ordered Klein to pay a $3,000 fine and $2,000 in restitution. He will report to prison at a date to be determined.

Klein worked in the State Department’s office of Brazilian and Southern Cone Affairs from 2017 until he resigned from that position on Jan. 19, 2021, a day before Biden’s inauguration.

Prosecutors said Klein’s participation in the riot was likely motivated by a desire to keep his job as a presidential appointee.

“As an employee of the federal government, Klein was endowed with the trust of the American people and to uphold the law. He violated that trust on January 6 when he attacked the very country for which he was paid to work,” prosecutors wrote.

Defense attorney Stanley Woodward has accused prosecutors of exaggerating Klein’s role in the riot due to his political connection to the Trump administration.

“Accordingly, Mr. Klein should be sentenced for his actual role in the events of the day, and not the more egregious conduct of others with which the government would have Mr. Klein be found guilty by association,” Woodward wrote.

Prosecutors had recommended a 10-year prison sentence for Klein, an Alexandria, Virginia, resident who was 42 years old at the time of the riot. Klein was arrested in March 2021.

In July 2023, McFadden heard trial testimony without a jury before he convicted Klein and a co-defendant, Steven Cappuccio, of assault charges and other Capitol riot-related offenses.

Klein and Cappuccio were among nine defendants charged in a 53-count indictment. The judge convicted Klein of 12 counts, including six assault charges.

McFadden is scheduled to sentence Cappuccio later on Friday. McFadden allowed Klein to remain free under house arrest after his conviction but ordered Cappuccio to be jailed immediately after the verdict.

Prosecutors recommended a prison sentence of 10 years and one month for Cappuccio, who was arrested at his home in Universal City, Texas, in August 2021.

Klein and Cappuccio separately attended Trump’s “Stop the Steal” rally on Jan. 6 before marching to the Capitol. Klein was in the first wave of rioters to enter the tunnel, according to prosecutors. They said he pushed hard against officers, telling them, “You can’t stop this!”

Klein also wedged a stolen police riot shield between two doors, preventing officers from closing them, prosecutors said. Video captured Klein encouraging other rioters to attack police, repeatedly yelling, “We need fresh people!”

McFadden told Klein on Friday that his conduct “prolonged the mayhem” in the tunnel.

“You were front and center in that chaos,” the judge said.

Cappuccio yelled, “Storming the castle, boys!” and chanted, “Fight for Trump!” and “Our house!” as he reached the Lower West Terrace. In the tunnel, he joined other rioters in pushing against the police line, prosecutors said.

When another rioter pinned Metropolitan Police Officer Daniel Hodges against a door, Cappuccio ripped a gas mask off the officer’s face and dislodged his helmet, prosecutors said.

Klein, who served in the Marine Corps for roughly nine years, was deployed to Iraq as a combat engineer in 2005. In January 2017, he went to work for the State Department as a desk officer specializing in the South American region.

Klein also worked for Trump’s 2016 campaign and took time off from work after the 2020 presidential election and traveled to Nevada to help investigate the baseless claims of voter fraud promoted by Trump and his allies, prosecutors said.

Nearly 1,200 people have been charged with Capitol riot-related federal crimes. Over 800 of them have pleaded guilty or been convicted by a jury or judge after a trial. Approximately 700 of them have been sentenced, with roughly two-thirds receiving terms of imprisonment ranging from three days to 22 years.

Judge rejects deal in Jacksonville redlining case. (Charlie McGee, The Tributary)

Thank you, U.S. District Court Judge Marcia Morales Howard!  We, the People, expect federal judges to review such settlement agreements with a gimlet eye, in the public interest, in the spirit of the late John J. Sirica (D.C.) and Miles Lord (Minnesota).  Good call, your Honor!  From The Tributary, by Charlie McGee):


Judge rejects deal in Jacksonville redlining case

Published on November 2, 2023 at 6:21 pm

A federal judge has rejected a settlement between the U.S. Department of Justice and Ameris Bank as written when the government publicly rolled out a case last month accusing the lender of discriminating against Black-majority neighborhoods in Jacksonville.

On Wednesday, U.S. District Judge Marcia Morales Howard denied a 28-page settlement jointly filed last month by the Justice Department and Ameris, a regional bank. 

Jacksonville Today thanks our sponsors. Become one.

Howard said one sweeping paragraph wasn’t enforceable because all it required was for Ameris to obey existing anti-discrimination laws. “It appears to do no more than instruct [Ameris] to obey the law,” Howard wrote.

She said that while she “wishes to support the parties in their efforts to resolve this case,” they would need to refile the settlement without that paragraph or by explaining why they think Howard’s decision was wrong.

U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland personally appeared in Jacksonville to announce the settlement last month, two years after he launched the Justice Department’s Combating Redlining Initiative, an effort to go after discriminatory lending practices.

As part of the settlement, Ameris has agreed to pay $9 million to help Black- and Hispanic-majority neighborhoods.

While Ameris disputed that it had violated federal housing laws, it said it agreed to settle to “avoid prolonged litigation.”

The settlement requires Ameris to invest $7.5 million of that $9 million in a loan subsidy fund that residents of Black-majority and Hispanic-majority census tracts can use for down payments, to lower their interest rates or to make home improvements. The bank also must spend $900,000 to reach residents, and it must invest $600,000 in community partnerships to increase access to mortgages and financial education.

The bank also agreed that at least three of its mortgage loan officers will be dedicated to serving Black- and Hispanic-majority neighborhoods, and the bank must hire a director of community lending to oversee its lending to those neighborhoods.

In an email to The Tributary, Ameris spokesperson Sheryl Touchton said the settlement “was sent back to rectify a minor issue” that doesn’t affect the overall contours of the deal.

“Ameris and the DOJ are working to make the necessary changes and will resubmit in the near future,” Touchton wrote. The Justice Department declined to comment.

The paragraph in question is an injunction barring any affiliate of Ameris “from engaging in any act or practice that discriminates on the basis of race, color or national origin that violates the [Fair Housing Act] in any aspect of a residential real estate-related transaction.” It also barred any future action that violates the federal Equal Credit Opportunity Act.

That’s too broad of an order, Howard wrote in the order Wednesday. By broadly barring Ameris “from engaging in any discriminatory act or practice that violates” specific laws going forward, “it appears to do no more than instruct [Ameris] to obey the law.”

The Justice Department informed Ameris it was being investigated for redlining in Jacksonville in January 2022.

Redlining originated when the U.S. government steered private lending in the 1930s away from Black-majority neighborhoods, depriving those neighborhoods of needed investment. The Fair Housing Act of 1968 and other civil rights laws outlawed the practice, but discriminatory lending has never been fully eradicated.

From 2016 to 2021, Ameris didn’t receive a loan application in one-third of the area’s Black- and Hispanic-majority census tracts, according to the government’s complaint. Among all of its loans in Jacksonville’s Urban Core, only two went to Black borrowers and none went to Hispanic borrowers.

At one point, Ameris sent 22,000 mailers advertising free checking services meant to target low- and moderate-income areas, but allegedly didn’t send a single one to a resident in a majority-Black or Hispanic neighborhood. The mailers featured exclusively white models.

The bank, which currently has 18 branches in the Jacksonville area, closed two branches “it had identified as having ‘minority’ populations ‘higher’ than adjacent Ameris branch[es]” in 2019. It had previously listed one of those branches among its “best financial performers,” per the complaint.

Ameris has denied the allegations. The Atlanta-based bank wrote in the proposed consent order that it agreed to settle the case only “to resolve this matter in order to avoid prolonged litigation.”

“We strongly disagree with any suggestion that we have engaged in discriminatory conduct,” Ameris chief executive Palmer Proctor said in a statement last month.

This story is published through a partnership between Jacksonville Today and The Tributary. 

Charlie McGee covers poverty and the safety net for The Tributary. He’s also a Report for America corps member with The GroundTruth Project, an independent, nonpartisan, nonprofit news organization dedicated to supporting the next generation of journalists in the U.S. and worldwide. McGee may be reached at charlie.mcgee@jaxtrib.org. Follow him on Twitter @bycharliemcgee.

Lead image: U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland came to Jacksonville in October to announce a settlement with Ameris Bank over redlining. | Will Brown, Jacksonville Today


author imageReport for America corps memberCharlie McGee reports on poverty in Jacksonville. He is a Report for America corps member who previously wrote for the regional paper in California’s High Desert. He has written for outlets including The Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg News, Rolling Stone and Vice News. His journalism life began at The Daily Tar Heel. You can reach him at