From KVUE:
Private prison was on sale for $75 million; ICE paid $495 million
APPLETON, Minn. — New records obtained by KARE 11 show the company that owned a vacant private prison in Appleton, Minnesota offered to sell it to the state in 2025 for $75 million.
One year later, the Trump administration agreed to use taxpayer funds to buy the same abandoned prison from CoreCivic, Inc., for $495.6 million.
The price difference, $420 million, is more than taxpayers are estimated to have lost in Minnesota’s much-publicized Feeding Our Future fraud scandal.
A Shuttered Prison
In the tiny western Minnesota town of Appleton, population less than 1,400, sits the site of what’s been described as the most expensive property purchase in Minnesota history: a 34-year-old vacant prison, shuttered for 16 years.
In August, the federal Department of Homeland Security purchased the Prairie Correctional Facility from CoreCivic, Inc, to use it as an ICE detention center.
Records filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission show CoreCivic sold it to the federal government for nearly half a billion dollars ($495,639,588.00).
That amount was more than six times the price CoreCivic was offering to sell the same prison to the State of Minnesota a year earlier, according to records obtained by KARE 11 through an open records request.
“I was stunned”
“It's unexplainable!” Minnesota Corrections Commissioner Paul Schnell said, when asked about the price the federal government paid to purchase the prison.
“Obviously, I was stunned given the reality of the offer that had been made to us just a little over a year prior to that,” Schnell said. “I still can't figure it out.”
The offer he's talking about? The public didn’t know about it - until now.
KARE 11 obtained an email dated May 7, 2025, from CoreCivic representative Kelly Durham to the Deputy Commissioner of the Minnesota Department of Corrections.
The CoreCivic email states: “Yes, we would be willing to sell the facility to the State.”
Then, CoreCivic states its asking price: “Sale price is $75M inclusive of the upgrades CoreCivic has identified would be needed to re-activate the facility.”
The offer he's talking about? The public didn’t know about it - until now.
KARE 11 obtained an email dated May 7, 2025, from CoreCivic representative Kelly Durham to the Deputy Commissioner of the Minnesota Department of Corrections.
The CoreCivic email states: “Yes, we would be willing to sell the facility to the State.”
Then, CoreCivic states its asking price: “Sale price is $75M inclusive of the upgrades CoreCivic has identified would be needed to re-activate the facility.”
So, instead of the nearly $500 million the federal government paid, the email shows CoreCivic was offering to sell the same abandoned Appleton prison for hundreds of millions less.
“And the federal government's gonna spend a half a billion dollars on that is beyond comprehension,” Schnell told KARE 11.
Minnesota declined CoreCivic’s $75 million offer. The state says it had concerns about staffing and the services needed to operate a prison in such a remote small town, roughly three hours’ drive from the Twin Cities.
Financial Windfall
During President Trump's immigration crackdown, CoreCivic has become a big financial winner.
Records show the Nashville-based company’s executives saw it coming.
“We're anticipating significant growth opportunities, perhaps the most significant growth in our company's history over the next several years,” CoreCivic’s then CEO Damon Hininger told investors during an earnings call shortly after Trump returned to the White House.
Hininger said Trump’s immigration policies were creating enormous business opportunities by increasing the demand for detention beds. “The change in presidential administration on January 20th has ushered in significant policy and legislative changes that directly impact our business,” he told investors.
Political Donations
The company wasn't just cheering for Trump's return. It helped pay for his inauguration.
Federal records show CoreCivic donated half a million dollars to the Trump-Vance inaugural committee.
Its CEO also made significant personal contributions to Trump-affiliated political committees.
KARE 11 asked for an interview with CoreCivic.
An unnamed public affairs spokesperson said they “aren’t able to participate in an on-camera interview.”
In a written statement, the company said, “independent appraisers used a cost-based methodology” and in bold print, “The federal government ultimately determined the sale price following its assessment process.”
Additional Prison Sales
The Minnesota prison was just one of a series of sales CoreCivic made to the federal government this year.
On the same day CoreCivic announced the Minnesota sale, the company also sold its facility in Kansas for $238 million.
A month earlier, records show CoreCivic sold two prisons in California for a combined $1.5 billion.
The total bill for taxpayers for the four prisons: more than $2.2 billion.
In addition to profiting from the prison sales, CoreCivic has federal contracts which pay the company to operate the facilities.
At the Minnesota facility alone, CoreCivic estimates that it will earn approximately $75 million a year once the prison reaches full capacity.
Spending Questions
Federal auditors are raising questions about ICE’s prison-buying spree.
The nonpartisan Government Accountability Office (GAO) recently found ICE’s detention facility purchases have “the potential to result in waste” because “ICE has not assessed the long-term affordability of owning these facilities.”
The headline from the GAO’s September report reads: “Urgent Planning Needed to Avoid Further Waste of Taxpayer Dollars.”
In addition to questioning the prison purchases, the GAO also criticized ICE’s decision in early 2026 to spend $1.07 billion to buy 11 warehouses. ICE said it planned to convert them into detention centers - but quickly reversed course. By June, ICE was telling investigators it planned to sell seven of the 11 warehouses.
But, by then, the GAO found that ICE had spent over $20 million on costs it can't recover, such as utilities, security, and other services.
Unanswered Questions
Last week, KARE 11 asked Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin for an interview about his department’s decision to buy the vacant Minnesota private prison.
We wanted to know how the federal government determined that taxpayers should pay more than six times the price CoreCivic had been asking for the Appleton facility - $495.6 million instead of the $75 million offer it made to Minnesota a year ago.
To date, Mullin’s office has not responded.
ICE may still need to answer questions from Congress.
Even before KARE 11 revealed CoreCivic’s offer to sell the prison to the state for a fraction of the price the federal government paid, Minnesota Rep. Betty McCollum, a Democratic member of the House Appropriations Committee, called for an investigation.
She questioned whether taxpayers were overcharged because the prison company’s owners are what she calls “mega donors” to President Trump and Republicans.
In a post to social media, McCollum wrote: “Congress must investigate this deal to protect American taxpayers.”
Meanwhile, the GAO report criticizing ICE’s spending decisions underscores questions about the priciest real estate sale Minnesota has ever seen.
“Did Minnesota miss out on the real estate deal of the century, or are taxpayers potentially getting taken for a ride here?” KARE 11’s A.J. Lagoe asked the man who turned down CoreCivic’s $75 million offer.
“Well, I mean, that's the only thing I can believe,” Schnell replied. “That the taxpayers - I don't know how they could justify this amount.”
Update following publication. While not addressing KARE 11's request for an on-camera interview or the questions submitted in writing, DHS provided the following statement on 11/02/26, attributed to an unnamed spokesperson:
“DHS acquired the Prairie Correctional Facility to strengthen America’s ability to enforce its immigration laws and carry out the American people’s mandate for mass deportations.
The 1,600-bed site gives ICE immediate capacity to detain and remove those who have no legal right to remain, protecting American communities and restoring the integrity of our borders without waiting years for new construction.
The purchase price was set through the standard federal appraisal process. Independent appraisers applied a replacement-cost method, current cost of equivalent secure space, adjusted for depreciation, land, and condition, including the security and fire upgrades required for ICE operations.
The $75 million figure was a preliminary, non-binding indication offered during earlier discussions with the Minnesota Department of Corrections. Those talks never advanced to formal appraisal or agreed scope. The number was not based on replacement-cost analysis and did not reflect the intervening rise in construction costs or federal operational standards. Minnesota’s own estimate to replace Stillwater was roughly $1.3 billion.”






