Thursday, August 06, 2026

Gainesville Chief Circuit Judge William Elbridge Davis assigned to trial of State of Florida v. SARAH SALLEY ARNOLD, et al.

William E. Davis
Florida 8th Circuit Court

On July 27, 2026, a new judge was assigned to the State of Florida's criminal case against two St. Johns County Commissioners and a St. Augustine Beach City Commissioner, and former Mayor.

The Honorable William Elbridge Davis, Chief Judge of the 8th Judicial Circuit, from Gainesville, has been assigned to preside at the trial of the criminal case of State of Florida v. SARAH SALLEY ARNOLD, CHRISTIAN GREGORY WHITEHURST, DYLAN RUMRELL, et al.   

Circuit Judge William Elbridge Davis is the Chief Judge of Florida's Eighth Judicial Circuit.

Here is the biography of Judge Davis from the Criminal Law Section of The Florida Bar:

Bio:
Judge Davis was appointed as a county judge for Alachua County in 2006 and served in both criminal and civil assignments. Elected as a circuit judge for the Eighth Judicial Circuit in 2008 (re-elected in 2014), He is currently serving a criminal assignment for Alachua, Levy and Gilchrist counties. His previous circuit assignments include Delinquency, Dependency, Family and Civil. Former statewide committees include the Steering Committee for Family & Children in Court for the Florida Supreme Court; Court Interpreter Certification Committee (chair); and the Executive Committee for the Conference of Circuit Judges. Judge Davis is a former prosecutor, special public defender and adjunct law professor at the University of Florida College of Law. He graduated from the University of Florida Law School and earned his B.A. from the University of Arizona. Judge Davis is a former U.S. Army officer who served with the 24th Infantry Division during combat operations Desert Shield and Desert Storm. Judge Davis previously served in law enforcement for over two years as a dispatcher, correctional officer (Hernando and Sumter County Sheriff’s Offices) and later as a police officer with the Leesburg Police Department.

Pretrial hearings 

A status conference is set before Judge Davis by Zoom on August 7, 2026 at 10 AM.

A felony pretrial conference is set before Judge Davis on September 15, 2026, 1 PM at St. Johns County Courthouse, Room 328.

Here is the docket:

blank
Judge:
DAVIS, WILLIAM E 
Case Number:
26000985CFMB 
Clerk File Date:
7/6/2026 
Total Fees Due:
0.00 
Agency Report Number:
EI320288 
Court Type:
Criminal Felony 
Uniform Case Number:
552026CF000985XXBXMX 
Status Date:
7/6/2026  
Custody Location:
NOT IN CUSTODY 
Case Type:
 
Status:
OPEN  
Waive Speedy Trial:
Agency:
FDLE 
TYPEPARTY NAMEATTORNEY
DEFENDANT 
Active COXE, HENRY M III (Main Attorney)
PLAINTIFF 
STATE OF FLORIDA
Active YAZDIYA, RALPH M (Main Attorney)
0
COUNTDESCRIPTIONLEVELDEGREEPLEADISPOSITIONDISPOSITION DATE
CONSPIRACY (106.1436 1 2 3 4 & 777.04)     
UNAUTHORIZED VOTER GUIDE (106.1436 1 2 3 4 & 777.011)     
DATEEVENTJUDGELOCATIONRESULT
9/15/2026 1:00 PM FELONY PRETRIAL DAVIS, WILLIAM E Courtroom 328  
8/7/2026 10:00 AM FELONY STATUS CONFERENCE DAVIS, WILLIAM E Zoom  
8/3/2026 1:30 PM FELONY ARRAIGNMENT FEREBEE, CHRISTOPHER S Courtroom 328 PLEA FILED  
SEQ#IMAGEDINDATEENTRY
29   29 8/5/2026FELONY STATUS CONFERENCE SET FOR 08/07/2026 AT 10:00 AM IN ZOOM/ , JDG: DAVIS, WILLIAM E 
28  28 8/5/2026ORDER SCHEDULING STATUS CONFERENCE 
27  27 7/31/2026NOTICE MAILED/EMAILED TO DEFENDANT 
26  26 7/31/2026NOTICE MAILED/EMAILED TO ATTORNEY (DEFENDANT) 
25   25 7/31/2026FELONY PRETRIAL SET FOR 09/15/2026 AT 1:00 PM IN 328/ , JDG: DAVIS, WILLIAM E 
24  24 7/29/2026DESIGNATION OF EMAIL ADDRESS 
23  23 7/29/2026NOTICE OF DISCOVERY 
22  22 7/29/2026NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 
21  21 7/29/2026PLEA OF NOT GUILTY AND WAIVER OF ARRAIGNMENT 
20   20 7/29/2026DEFENSE ATTORNEY: COXE, HENRY M III ASSIGNED 
19   19 7/27/2026JUDGE DAVIS, WILLIAM E: ASSIGNED 
18  18 7/27/2026SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA - ASSIGNMENT ORDER 2027-11 
17  17 7/13/2026DESIGNATION OF E-MAIL ADDRESS FOR E-SERVICE 
16  16 7/10/2026CRIMINAL SUMMONS STATUS SET TO RETURNED SERVED ON 07/10/2026 - OTHER SERVICE/INVESTIGATOR HATHCOCK OFFICE OF SAO 
15  15 7/8/2026ORDER OF RECUSAL 
14   14 7/7/2026CRIMINAL SUMMONS STATUS SET TO SENT TO SHERIFF ON 07/07/2026 
13  13 7/7/2026CRIMINAL SUMMONS ISSUED FOR SWORN COMPLAINT FILED 
12   12 7/6/2026FILED SEQ: 1 AMENDED - (106.1436 1 2 3 4 & 777.04) CONSPIRACY 
11   11 7/6/2026FILED SEQ: 2 AMENDED - (106.1436 1 2 3 4 & 777.011) UNAUTHORIZED VOTER GUIDE 
10   10 7/6/2026PROSECUTOR: YAZDIYA, RALPH M ASSIGNED 
 7/6/2026INFORMATION 
 7/6/2026ORDER ON STATE'S MOTION FOR SINGLE CASE NUMBER ASSIGNMENT 
 7/6/2026STATE'S MOTION FOR SINGLE CASE NUMBER ASSIGNMENT 
13  7/6/2026SWORN AFFIDAVIT 
  7/6/2026SWORN COMPLAINT COUNT: 1 - (106.1436 1 2 3 4 & 777.04) UNAUTHORIZED VOTER GUIDE 
  7/6/2026SWORN COMPLAINT COUNT: 2 - (106.1436 1 2 3 4 & 777.011) CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY 
  7/6/2026PROSECUTOR: OFFICE, STATE ATTORNEY'S ASSIGNED 
  7/6/2026JUDGE FEREBEE, CHRISTOPHER S: ASSIGNED 
  7/6/2026CASE FILED 07/06/2026 CASE NUMBER 26000985CFMB 
blank