Is this the most important legacy of Texas Attorney General WARREN KENNETH PAXTON, JR? You tell me. Our 120th Congress must pass the law again, with full quorum, post-COVID. From The New York Times:
Federal Court Halts Pregnant Workers’ Protection Law
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals said the law was unconstitutional because it was passed with proxy voting during the Covid pandemic. It is expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court.

A divided Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals found that Congress did not have a legal quorum when it passed a law that requires employers to provide accommodations to pregnant women, and it ruled that the measure had been passed in violation of the Constitution.
Legal experts said the decision would effectively invalidate the law in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi, home to about 20 million women, and would likely have ripple effects nationally.
The law protects accommodations for pregnant workers such as bathroom and water breaks, relief from heavy lifting and time off for prenatal appointments. The decisionis expected to be appealed to the Supreme Court.
The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled 9 to 8 that the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act was passed by Congress in violation of the Constitution’s quorum clause, which requires a majority of members in each chamber of Congress to be present to conduct official business.
The law was passed as part of a broader $1.7 trillion spending bill during the peak of the Covid-19 pandemic, as lawmakers authorized remote and proxy votes as a safety precaution.
We conclude that the Act’s passage was unconstitutional because the Quorum Clause does not allow proxies to be included when establishing a quorum,” the judges wrote, saying that the proxy system established during the pandemic was at odds with the standards established by the framers of the Constitution. “At the Constitutional Convention, the Framers vigorously debated a quorum threshold for Congress to conduct business,” the judges wrote. “Indeed, early legislatures never attempted to ameliorate such concerns via proxies, even though the Founding generation was surely aware of the existence of that device.”
The court’s decision was a victory for outgoing Texas attorney general Ken Paxton, who had brought the suit on behalf of the state as an employer.
The suit said that the law “purports to subject [the state] to the costs, hassles, and attendant risks of administrative proceedings, investigations, and lawsuits, by both private individuals and the federal government.”
The decision immediately ends the requirement for the state of Texas, as an employer, to enforce the pregnant workers’ law. It also means, legal experts said, that any other employer in the jurisdiction of the Fifth Circuit that was challenged to enforce the law could assume that they would prevail in such a challenge.
The law has drawn opposition from employers as pregnant workers have used it to demand on-the-job protections. A Texas accountant won $376,000 in damages in a court decision this year maintaining that her employer had violated the law by refusing to allow her to work remotely while pregnant. Warehouse workers have used the law as the basis of a class-action lawsuit claiming that Amazon denied accommodations to thousands of pregnant employees.
Women’s rights advocates and experts in constitutional law said the implications of halting enforcement of the law could be profound.
“This decision effectively erases essential rights to pregnancy accommodations for workers across Texas, Louisiana, and Mississippi,” said Inimai Chettiar, president of A Better Balance, a women’s legal advocacy group that wrote an amicus brief in favor of upholding the law. “The Fifth Circuit has put the health, livelihoods, and economic security of millions of American women and their families at risk.”
The decision “will have dramatic and destructive real-world consequences,” said William Eskridge, a scholar of constitutional law at Yale University.
Mr. Eskridge and other legal experts said it was highly unusual for the court to declare Congress’s use of proxy and remote voting during the Covid pandemic to be unconstitutional.
It’s breaking down the separation of powers if the courts get to second-guess the choices that the House made about its own rules in terms of how it was going to count votes,” said Deborah Widiss, a professor of law at Indiana University Bloomington.
Even Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, formerly a Senate Republican leader, filed an amicus brief in favor of upholding the law. “The core question in this case is whether the courts can review the internal affairs of Congress, when such affairs are textually committed to each house by the Constitution,” he wrote. “They cannot.”
Experts also pointed out that the decision now throws into legal question the status of the $1.7 trillion spending bill that had been the legislative vehicle for passage of the pregnant workers’ act.
That bill also included about $858 billion in defense spending, including $436 million for military facilities in Texas.
While the judges’ decision halted only enforcement of the pregnant workers’ provisions, the dissenting judges wrote, “There is no explanation offered to explain why, if the entirety of the statute was unconstitutionally passed, this court’s judgment should be limited only to one small sliver of the multitrillion dollar bill.”
Ms. Widiss, the law professor, said the decision opens the door to legal challenges to the other spending, which could potentially also be considered unconstitutional. She said, “If the Fifth Circuit’s constitutional reasoning is correct, then the whole bill and the entire $1.7 trillion that it authorized was passed improperly.”
Coral Davenport covers energy and environment policy, with a focus on climate change, for The Times.
No comments:
Post a Comment