Sunday, November 15, 2026

November 17, 2026 St. Johns County Board of County Commissioners Regular Meeting


ST. JOHNS COUNTY

ST. AUGUSTINE, FLORIDA

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS BOARD MEETING AGENDA

District 1 - Christian Whitehurst District 2 - Martin Pyszczymuka District 3 - Clay Murphy

District 4 - Krista Joseph District 5 - Ann Taylor County Auditorium

500 San Sebastian View

Joy Andrews, County Administrator

Rich Komando, County Attorney

Tuesday, November 17, 2026 9:00 AM

Please be sure all cellular devices are turned off for the duration of the County Commission Meeting

REGULAR MEETING

 Call to Order by Chair

 Roll Call by the Clerk of the Circuit Court and County Comptroller

 Invocation

 Pledge of Allegiance

 Proclamation Recognizing International Fraud Awareness Week

 Acceptance of Proclamations

 Deletions to Consent Agenda

 Approval of Consent Agenda

 Additions/Deletions to Regular Agenda

 Approval of Regular Agenda

 Public Comment

Presenter: Jennifer Ravan, St Johns County Tax Collector

1. Total Earned, Unused, and Undistributed Revenue. In compliance with Florida

Statute, 218.36, the St. Johns County Tax Collector, Jennifer Ravan, will present a

report of unused earned revenue collected for the 2025-2026 fiscal year. Please note

that these unused revenues have already been estimated as part of the County budget

process and therefore they do not necessarily represent additional County revenue.

Presenter: Angel King, Applicant

Staff Member: Evan Walsnovich, Planner

District 2

Public Hearing * ENCERT 2026-16 King. Application for Agricultural Enclave

Certification, pursuant to Sections 163.3162 and 163.3164, Chapter 2026-34, Florida

Statutes. This certification request includes approximately 36.63 acres of land. The

subject property is located at 9400 Byrd Road in Hastings, Florida.

2. Presenter: Zach Miller, Esq., Agent

Staff Member: Saleena Randolph, Senior Planner

District 5

3. Public Hearing * REZ 2026-17 Arapaho Commercial. Request to rezone

approximately 5.29 acres of land from Open Rural (OR) to Commercial Intensive (CI)

with conditions, located at 1470 Arapaho Avenue, 1480 Arapaho Avenue, and an

unaddressed Arapaho Avenue parcel. The Planning and Zoning Agency (PZA)

considered this request at its regularly scheduled public hearing on October 15, 2026.

The Agency discussed potential impacts of an entertainment complex compared to a

hotel, including tree preservation, roadway capacity, traffic, access, signalization at

U.S. 1, utility availability, and the costs of roadway improvements. Agency members

and members of the public also expressed concerns regarding the loss of mature trees,

increased traffic, roadway conditions, and the jurisdictional implications of

annexation. The applicant indicated that an entertainment complex could provide

greater open space than a hotel and agreed to provide a list of prohibited uses

consistent with the Agency’s discussion. Following deliberation, the Agency

recommended approval subject to a condition requiring the applicant to provide a list

of prohibited uses. The motion passed by a vote of 6-1, with Members Perkins,

Hilsenbeck, Matovina, Green, Labanowski, and Olson in support and Member Spiegel

opposed. Based on the hearing discussion, staff has included conditions in the

proposed Ordinance to address the prohibited uses.

4. Presenter: Brad Wester; Driver, McAfee, Hawthorne & Diebenow

Staff Member: Abrielle Genest, Senior Planner

District 2

CPA(SS) 2026-03 Tractor Supply. Request for a Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan

Amendment to change the Future Land Use Map designation of approximately 5.03

acres of land from Rural/Silviculture (R/S) to Rural Commercial (RC), specifically

located at 4430 State Road 16. This request is a companion application to PUD 2026-

02. The Planning and Zoning Agency (PZA) heard this request at its regularly

scheduled public hearing on October 15, 2026. Discussion focused on existing traffic

conditions along State Road 16 and the anticipated traffic impacts associated with the

proposed development. Two Agency Members expressed concern regarding approval

of the request and the potential for commercial development to extend farther east

along a portion of SR 16 that has historically been rural and residential in character.

There were no public comments. The Agency voted to recommend approval of the

Small-Scale Comprehensive Plan Amendment, with the condition that the site is

limited to the development of a Tractor Supply by a vote of 6-1. Support was made by

members Hilsenbeck, Speigel, Perkins, Green, Labanowski, and Matovina, with Olson

dissenting.

PUD 2026-02 Tractor Supply. Request to rezone approximately 5.03 acres of land

from Open Rural (OR) to Planned Unit Development (PUD) to allow for a maximum

48,745 square feet of Rural Commercial uses to include commercial retail with outdoor

display, specifically located at 4430 State Road 16. This request is a companion

application to CPA(SS) 2026-03. The Planning and Zoning Agency (PZA) heard this

request at its regularly scheduled public hearing on October 15, 2026. Discussion

focused on existing traffic conditions along State Road 16 and the anticipated traffic

impacts associated with the proposed development. Two Agency Members expressed

concern regarding approval of the request and the potential for commercial

development to extend farther east along a portion of SR 16 that has historically been

rural and residential in character. There were no public comments. The Agency voted

to recommend approval of the PUD rezoning by a vote of 6-1. Support was made by

members Hilsenbeck, Speigel, Perkins, Green, Labanowski, and Matovina, with Olson

dissenting.

5. 6. Presenter: Kent Bush - IME Civil & Surveying

Staff Member: Patrick Heekin, Planner

District 2

Public Hearing * REZ 2026-07 501 Comet Drive. A request to rezone approximately

0.59 of an acre of land from Open Rural (OR) to Industrial Warehouse (IW) with

conditions. This item was heard by the Planning and Zoning Agency at their regularly

scheduled public hearing on Thursday, October 15, 2026, and was unanimously

recommended for approval by a vote of 7-0.

Presenter: Jacob Smith, Planning Division Manager

Staff Member: Amy Ring, Special Project Manager

7. Public Hearing * LDCA 2026-06 Land Development Code Updates - First Reading.

LDCA 2026-06 amends Land Development Code (LDC) Articles II, III, VI, and XII to

maintain consistency with recent changes to Florida Statutes and to clarify certain

existing sections of the code. This ordinance also amends Ordinance 2025-19 to

authorize St. Johns County Assistant Directors and the Planning Division Manager to

process and render approval decisions for plats and replats, in addition to the Director

of Growth Management, pursuant to s. 177.071, Florida Statutes. Additionally, this

amendment amends the West Augustine overlay to add Food Truck Parks as an

allowed use and codify related design standards.

Presenter: Joy Andrews, County Administrator

8. Amendment 3: Financial Outlook and Resiliency Planning. Following the passage

of Amendment 3 in the November 2026 General Election, the County is evaluating the

anticipated impacts to property tax revenues and the resulting implications for future

budgets, services, and operations. This workshop will provide the Board with an

overview of the projected financial impacts, planning efforts and operational measures

underway, and opportunities for Board discussion and direction regarding the

County's approach to maintaining services and financial resiliency.

Presenter: Kealey West, Deputy County Attorney

9. Public Hearing * Public Hearing - Florida Power & Light Franchise Agreement

Ordinance. Florida Power & Light Company currently provides electric utility services

within portions of unincorporated St. Johns County utilizing County rights-of-way

and other public property for the placement and maintenance of electric transmission

and distribution infrastructure. The proposed non-exclusive Franchise Agreement

grants FPL the continued right to construct, operate, and maintain its electric facilities

within County rights-of-way and the nonexclusive right and privilege of supplying

electricity and other services in the portions of the County subject to the terms and

conditions of the Agreement. The Agreement establishes a franchise fee equal to 6%

of FPL's applicable gross revenues derived from the sale of electricity within the

unincorporated areas of the County it serves. The franchise fee will be collected by

FPL through customer billing and remitted to the County. The proposed Agreement

is consistent with franchise agreements utilized by counties and municipalities

throughout the State and provides compensation to the County for the private use of

public rights-of-way while preserving the County's police powers and regulatory

authority.

 Commissioners’ Reports

 County Administrator’s Report

 County Attorney’s ReportST. JOHNS COUNTY

ST. AUGUSTINE, FLORIDA

BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS BOARD MEETING AGENDA

District 1 - Christian Whitehurst District 2 - Martin Pyszczymuka District 3 - Clay Murphy

District 4 - Krista Joseph District 5 - Ann Taylor County Auditorium

500 San Sebastian View

Joy Andrews, County Administrator

Rich Komando, County Attorney

Tuesday, November 17, 2026 9:00 AM

1. Please be sure all cellular devices are turned off for the duration of the County Commission Meeting

CONSENT AGENDA

Motion to approve the Cash Requirement Report. For more information, contact

Donna Echegoyen, Deputy Director, BCC Accounting at 904 819-3680

2. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, approving and ratifying the County

Administrator's execution of Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission

Agreement No. 26142; recognizing and appropriating $299,179 in grant revenue for

the St. Johns County Incidental Take Permit Renewal and Habitat Conservation Plan

Update. For more information, contact Michael Lagasse, Environmental Manager at

904 209-0617

3. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, accepting a Bill of Sale with Schedule of

Values, a Release of Lien, and Warranty for water to serve 1350 Davis Warehouses

located off Northwood Drive. For more information, contact Corey Bowens, Director,

Land Management Systems at 904 209-0776

4. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, accepting an Easement for Utilities

associated with the sewer system and a Bill of Sale with Schedule of Values, Final

Release of Lien, and Warranty associated with the water, sewer and reuse systems

to serve Elm Ridge Silverleaf Parcel 32. For more information, contact Corey Bowens,

Director, Land Management Systems at 904 209-0776

5. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, granting and authorizing the County

Administrator, or designee, to execute and issue a non-exclusive, Construction and

Demolition Debris franchise agreement to Iron Ark, LLC for the collection and

transportation of construction and demolition solid waste, in substantially the same

form as attached hereto. For more information, contact Greg Caldwell, Director, Public

Works at 904 209-0266

6. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, granting and authorizing the County

Administrator, or designee, to execute and issue a non-exclusive,

Commercial/Industrial franchise agreement to Iron Ark, LLC for the collection and

transportation of commercial/industrial solid waste, in substantially the same form

as attached hereto. For more information, contact Greg Caldwell, Director, Public

Works at 904 209-02667. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026 – _____, authorizing the County Administrator, or

designee, to award RFQ No: 2835; Design, Permitting, and Construction

Administration of FEMA Category G Ponte Vedra Beach Restoration Project to

First Line Coastal, LLC., as the top ranked Respondent, and to execute a contract in

substantially the same form and format as attached in the amount of $3,624,521.62

to perform the required services in accordance with the negotiated contract. For more

information, contact Jaime Locklear, Director, Purchasing at 904 209-0158

8. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, authorizing the County Administrator, or

designee, to award RFP 2911; Grant Writing Services to Kimley-Horn and

Associates, Inc., as the top ranked Proposer, and to execute a contract in the same

form and format to perform the required services in accordance with the negotiated

contract. For more information, contact Jaime Locklear, Director, Purchasing at 904

209-0158

9. Motion to authorize the County Administrator, or designee, to donate a 2008 Ford

Ranger (CV#1138) to the SEA Community Help Resource Center, Inc. For more

information, contact Jaime Locklear, Director, Purchasing at 904 209-0158

10. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-

_______, recognizing and appropriating

unanticipated revenue; and approving the Fiscal Year 2026 end-of-year fund

reserve transfers per the attached schedule to ensure fiscal year-end positive account

balances per the St. Johns County Administrative Code. For more information,

contact Wade Schroeder, Director, Management & Budget at 904 209-0570

11. Motion to approve the calendar year 2027 holiday schedule for the Board of County

Commissioners. For more information, contact Desiree Woroner, Director, Human

Resources at 904 209-0622

12. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-

________, approving the Interlocal Agreement

between St. Johns County and the Statewide Guardian ad Litem Office for

reimbursement of Administrative Specialist services in an amount not to exceed

amount of $83,299; authorizing the County Administrator, or designee, to execute the

Interlocal Agreement and any related documents necessary to implement and

administer the Agreement. For more information, contact Desiree Woroner, Director

HR and Risk Management at 904 209-0622

13. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, approving the Agreement between St.

Johns County and the University of Florida Board of Trustees, on behalf of the

University of Florida Child Protection Team; authorizing the County Administrator,

or designee, to execute the Agreement; and authorizing the County Administrator to

execute subsequent amendments under certain conditions. For more information,

contact Shawna Novak, Director, Health at 904 209-6089

14. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-

________, approving and authorizing the County

Administrator, or designee, to execute a State Housing Initiatives Partnership

Grant Agreement, in substantially the same form as attached hereto, allocating

$250,000 to Operation Lifeline, Inc., for the purchase of property for affordable

housing. For more information, contact Joseph Cone, Assistant Director, Health and

Human Services at 904 827-689015. Motion to reappoint Harold Dockins Sr. as an at-large member of the Recreation

Advisory Board for a second full (4) year term, set to expire November 15, 2030. For

more information, contact Shelby Romero, Sr. Asst. to the Board of County

Commissioners at 904 209-0307

16. Motion to appoint Stephen Danner and Cecilia Birk to the Ponte Vedra Zoning and

Adjustment Board to a full (4) year term scheduled to expire on November 17, 2030;

and to shift John Patton, a current holdover member of the Ponte Vedra Zoning and

Adjustment Board, to serve, until filled by a qualified applicant, the partial term

scheduled to expire on October 3, 2027. For more information, contact Shelby Romero,

Sr. Asst. to the Board of County Commissioners at 904 209-0307

17. Motion to appoint Mollie Meikle, an at-large member of the Library Advisory Board

to the District 5 representative seat, set to expire November 4, 2029; and to appoint

Carl McGowan, as the at-large member of the Library Advisory Board for a full (4) year

term, set to expire November 17, 2030. For more information, contact Shelby Romero,

Sr. Asst. to the Board of County Commissioners at 904 209-0307

18. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-_____, approving the terms, conditions, provisions,

and requirements of a Grant Agreement in the amount of $250,000 between the

Florida Inland Navigation District and St. Johns County, Florida, for the Vilano

Boat Ramp dredging project, with $250,000 in matching funds allocated in the FY27

Tourist Development Tax (TDT) budget; and authorizing the County Administrator, or

designee, to execute the Grant Agreement. For more information, contact Ryan Kane,

Director, Parks and Recreation at 904 209-0324

19. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, approving and granting a Certificate of

Public Convenience and Necessity to RG Ambulance Service, Inc. dba Century

Ambulance Service, and authorizing the Chair to execute the Certificate on behalf of

the County in substantially the same form as attached hereto. For more information,

contact Jeremy Robshaw, Chief, Administrative Services at 904 209-1750

20. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, approving the Library’s Annual Plan of

Service 2026-2027, as required by the State Library of Florida in order to receive

annual State Aid to Libraries Grant funding. For more information, contact Debra

Rhodes Gibson, Director, Library at 904 827-6926

21. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, accepting the donation of furnishings for

the Main Library, and thereby the creation of an asset inventory record. For more

information, contact Debra Gibson, Director, Library at 904 827-6926

22. Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-________, accepting the donation of mobile

shelving for the Bartram Trail Library, and thereby the creation of an asset

inventory record. For more information, contact Debra Gibson, Director, Library at 904

827-6926

23. Motion to approve minutes:

• 11/3/2026, BCC Regular

No comments: