IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
THE NEW YORK TIMES COMPANY ,
620 Eighth Avenue
New York, NY 10018 ;
JULIAN E. BARNES
The New York Times Company
1627 I Street NW, Suite 700
Washington , DC 20006,
Plaintiffs
Washington , DC 20301
V.
PETE HEGSETH
in his official capacity as Secretary of
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE A/K/A
DEPARTMENT OF WAR
1600 Defense Pentagon,
Washington, DC 20301 ;
SEAN PARNELL
in his official capacity as ChiefPentagon
,
Defense, 1600 Defense Pentagon,
,
Spokesman, 1600 Defense Pentagon ,
Washington , DC 20301 ,
Civil Case No. 25-4218
COMPLAINT FOR DECLARATORY
AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF
Defendants .Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25
Page 2 of41
INTRODUCTION
1. Plaintiffs The New York Times Company ("The New York Times” or the “The
Times") and its reporter Julian E. Barnes (“Barnes”) bring this action to enjoin provisions of a
recently implemented policy of the United States Department of Defense or Department of War
("Department” or “Pentagon”) that violates their First and Fifth Amendment rights. If allowed to
stand, that policy will upend the longstanding and “healthy adversarial tension between the
government, which may seek to keep its secrets” and “the press, which may endeavorto" report
them, Alexander Bickel, The Morality ofConsent at 79 (1977), and will deprive the public ofvital
information about the United States military and its leadership.
2. On October 6, 2025, the Department promulgated a new policy pertaining to
PFACS Pentagon Facility Alternate Credentials. PFACS (also called Pentagon badges or
building passes) are credentials members ofthe press receive to access the Pentagon. The Times'
and its reporters' interests in maintaining their PFACs are exactly the type of “liberty interests"
the D.C. Circuit has held “may not be denied without due process of law under the fifth
amendment.
" Karem v. Trump, 960 F.3d 656, 660 (D.C. Cir. 2020). And the policy-which vests
Department officials with unbridled discretion to immediately suspend and ultimately revoke a
reporter's PFAC for engaging in lawful newsgathering, both on and off Pentagon grounds, or for
reporting any information Department officials have not approved is neither reasonable nor
viewpoint-neutral. It is exactly the type of speech- and press-restrictive scheme that the Supreme
Court and D.C. Circuit have recognized violates the First Amendment. See City ofLakewoodv.
Plain Dealer Publ'g Co., 486 U.S. 750, 757 (1988); Ateba v. Leavitt, 133 F.4th 114, 124–125
(D.C. Cir. 2025); see also Minnesota VotersAlliance v. Mansky, 585 U.S. 1 , 11–12 ( 2018).
1Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 3 of 41
3. The policy, in violation of the First Amendment, seeks to restrict journalists'ability
to do what journalists have always done— ask questions of government employees and gather
information to report stories that take the public beyond official pronouncements. If and when
they do and then publish anything that has not been approved by Pentagon officials, the policy
permits those officials to, at any time and without any standards to guide their decisions,
immediately suspend and ultimately revoke those journalists' PFACs in violation of the First
Amendment, the Due Process Clause, and binding D.C. Circuit precedent.
4. Specifically, the policy confers on Pentagon officials the unfettered discretion to
determine that ajournalist “pose[s] a security or safety risk to [Department] personnel or property,
"
see Ex. A (hereinafter the “ Policy”) at 8 , 12, based solely on a journalist's or news organization's
receipt, publication, or “solicitation” of any “unauthorized” information, regardless of secrecy
classification, id. at 12–13. It then provides that such a determination “may result in an immediate
suspension of Pentagon access "
Id. at 8, 12. The Policy also allows the Department to
suspend or revoke PFACs when Pentagon officials— again exercising standardless discretion?
determine journalists have engaged in “[u]nprofessional conduct that might serve to disrupt
Pentagon operations.
" Id. at 15; see Karem, 960 F.3d at 666.
5. The Pentagon has made clear that lawful, routine newsgathering techniques—
asking questions of government employees and interviewing them for stories—whether on or off
Pentagon grounds could, in the Department's view,
“constitute a solicitation that could lead to
revocation "oftheir PFACs. Ex. A at 11. But such communications are a core journalistic practice
and a public good—the kind of basic source work that led to some of the most important news
stories in history, including the Pentagon Papers. In addition, the Department has made clear,
those journalistic practices that can be sanctioned also include, for example,
"public
2Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page4 of 41
advertisements or calls for tips,
" including via “ social media.
” Id. at 10. Providing a means for
sources to convey information is, likewise, routine. The Times, for instance, has a “tips page” on
its website that “ offer[s] several ways to get in touch with and provide materials to [Times]
journalists.
" 1
6. Through the Policy, Pentagon officials have dealt to themselves the power to
suspend and eventually revoke journalists' PFACs for publishing stories that Pentagon leadership
may perceive as unfavorable or unflattering, in direct contravention of Supreme Court precedent.
7. In issuing the Policy, the Department insisted that journalists sign an
"Acknowledgment,
” Ex. A. at 12 , acceding to their “understand[ ing]” of the Policy in order to
maintain their PFACs. Reporters from every major news organization, including The Times,
refused to comply with that demand as a condition to access the Pentagon,
² and were compelled
to turn in their PFACsas a result.³
8. While Plaintiffs and many other journalists and news organizations no longer
possess PFACs because they refused to accede to a Policy that would restrict independent
1 See https://www.nytimes.com/tips.
2 Erik Wemple, SeveralNews Outlets Reject Pentagon's Reporting Restrictions, N.Y. Times
(Oct. 13, 2025), https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/13/business/pentagon-restrictions-news-
outlets.html ("Several news organizations, including The Washington Post, The New York
Times, Newsmax and NPR, have announced that their journalists will not sign a new setof
Pentagon restrictions affecting news gathering in the vast military complex. .... Other news
outlets, including The Guardian and CNN, have also said they would reject the policy. The
announcements reflect the news media's wide-ranging frustration with efforts by Pete Hegseth,
the defense secretary, to curtail the physical movement of reporters in the building and impose
fresh limits on their activities.
").
3 Erik Wemple, How the Pentagon Is Blocking Out News Organizations, N.Y. Times (Oct. 15,
2025), https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2025/10/15/business/media/pentagon-press-
rules.html; David Baudner, Journalists turn in access badges, exit Pentagon rather than agree to
new reporting rules, Associated Press (Oct. 15, 2025), https://apnews.com/article/pentagon-
press-access-hegseth-trump-restrictions-5d9c2a63e4e03b91fc1546bb09ffbf12.
3Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 5 of 41
reporting, the Department has welcomed what it calls the “next generation of the Pentagon press
corps” —individuals and media outlets strongly supportive of the Trump administration and
whose viewpoints the Department favors. Among that group are Mike Lindell, the chiefexecutive
ofMyPillow, who has promised to "make [the Administration] proud" with his Pentagoncoverage;
Laura Loomer, an influential pro-Trump activist; and Raheem Kassam, editor in chief of the
National Pulse, who described his publication as “basically an industry mag/site for MAGA
world.
" 6
9. These developments place the purpose and effect of the Policy in stark relief: to
fundamentally restrict coverage of the Pentagon by independent journalists and news
organizations, either by limiting what kind of information they can obtain and publish without
incurring punishment, or by driving them out of the Pentagon with an unconstitutional Policy.
While Plaintiffs' enterprising reporting on the military will continue, the Pentagon's Policy ensures
the suppression of certain newsworthy information—information, for instance, gathered by
directly questioning officials at press conferences or through routine unplanned interactions
between journalists and Pentagon personnel on Pentagon grounds.
10. The Policy abandons scrutiny by independent news organizations for the public's
benefit, and it violates the Constitution's guarantees of due process, freedom of speech, and
freedom of the press. The Policy fails to provide fair notice to Plaintiffs and other journalists and
news organizations of what, in the Department's “unbridled discretion,
" will (or will not) be
4 Sean Parnell (@SeanParnellASW), X (Oct. 22, 2025, at 1:21 PM),
https://x.com/SeanParnellASW/status/1981048206923329719.
5 See Ken Bensinger & Erik Wemple, New Pentagon Press Crew Is All In on Trump, N.Y. Times
(Nov. 4, 2025), https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/04/business/media/new-pentagon-press-crew-
is-all-in-on-trump.html
6Id.Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 6 of 41
deemed improper newsgathering or reporting that warrants the immediate suspension and eventual
revocation of a PFAC. City ofLakewood, 486 U.S. at 757; see also Ateba, 133 F.4th at 125. And
its incurably vague language and lack of standards invite arbitrary as well as content- and
viewpoint-based determinations as to which reporters and news organizations will be granted or
denied access to the Pentagon and for what reasons. Indeed, Department officials have made clear
their viewpoint discriminatory aim in promulgating and implementing the Policy: Department
officials have publicly derided journalists who declined to sign the Acknowledgement as
"activists" and "propagandists” who spread “lies . to the American people,
" while praising
individuals approved to receive PFACsunder the Policy as free from “a biased agenda.
”7
11. The fact that the Department has conditioned journalists' access on their
willingness to attest to their understanding of an inscrutable Policy that targets their exercise of
First Amendment rights inflicts separate and additional constitutional harm on top ofthe Policy's
already irreparable chilling effect.
12. As the Supreme Court has recognized, the First Amendment guarantees “a 'rightto
gather information" " because “without some protection for seeking out the news, freedom of the
press could be eviscerated.
” Richmond Newspapers, Inc. v. Virginia, 448 U.S. 555, 576 (1980)
(quoting Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S. 665 , 681 (1972)). The D.C. Circuit held nearly fifty years
ago in the context of media access to the White House that “press facilities having been made
publicly available as a source of information for [journalists] , the protection afforded
newsgathering under the first amendment guarantee of freedom ofthe press . . . requires that . . .
7
Sean Parnell (@SeanParnellASW), X (Oct. 22, 2025, at 1:21 PM),
https://x.com/SeanParnellASW/status/1981048206923329719;
(@DOWResponse), X (Dec. 2, 2025, at 11:21 am),
https://x.com/DOWResponse/status/1995890967002452302.
5
DOW Rapid ResponseCase 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 7 of 41
access not be denied arbitrarily or for less than compelling reasons.
” Sherrill v. Knight, 569 F.2d
124, 129 (D.C. Cir. 1977) (citations omitted). The D.C. Circuit has since reaffirmed that “ the
interests of a bona fide Washington correspondent in obtaining [such a] pass' is not only 'protected
by the first amendment' but also ‘ undoubtedly qualifies as [a] liberty [interest] which may not be
denied without due process of law under the fifth amendment.
” Karem, 960 F.3d at 660 (second
and third alternations in original) (quoting Sherrill, 569 F.2d at 130–131 ) .
13. The D.C. Circuit also has made clear that “the government creates a 'nonpublic
forum' when it provides ‘ selective access for individual speakers.
" " Ateba, 133 F.4th at 122
(citations omitted). Areas of the Pentagon, including the Pentagon Briefing Room, are nonpublic
forums under the First Amendment, and therefore any regulation on speech within those forums
must be reasonable and not intended to suppress expression based on the speaker's viewpoint. See
Minnesota Voters Alliance, 585 U.S. at 11-12. The Policy fails that test and violates the First
Amendment because it is “ an effort to suppress” speech and newsgathering based on viewpoint,
and because its restrictions are not reasonable “in light ofthe purpose served by the forum.
” Id. at
12-13 .
14. This binding precedent applies with full force here. There is no legitimate, letalone
compelling, justification for the provisions of the Policy targeting lawful newsgathering and
reporting purposefully vague and overbroad provisions designed to give Department officials
free rein to grant or deny Pentagon access to journalists and media outlets on the basis of viewpoint
and that are wholly untethered to any interest in the “safe, efficient and secure operation ofthe
Pentagon Reservation.
" 10 U.S.C. § 2674(c)(1). Those provisions violate the First Amendment.
City ofLakewood, 486 U.S. at 757; see also Ateba, 133 F.4th at 125. Further, because the Policy
permits the immediate suspension of a PFAC without providing reporters procedural protections,
6Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 8 of 41
it plainly violates the Due Process Clause. See Karem, 960 F.3d at 660; Sherrill, 569 F.2d at 130-
131.
15. The Policy marks a radical departure from longstanding tradition, violates the Due
Process Clause and the First Amendment, and is inflicting irreparable harm on The Times and its
reporters, including Barnes, and on the American public. By this Complaint, Plaintiffs seek a
declaration that the provisions of the Policy targeting the exercise of First Amendment rights are
unlawful and an order preliminarily and permanently enjoining Defendants from enforcing those
provisions ofthe Policy.
PARTIES
16.
The New YorkTimes Company is a privately owned for-profit corporation located
in New York. The Times is headquartered at 620 8th Avenue, New York , NY 10018. The Times'
Washington Bureau is located at 1627 I Street NW, Suite 700, Washington, DC 20006. Prior to
the implementation ofthe Policy, six Times journalists, including Barnes, held PFACs. The Times
and its reporters, including Julian E. Barnes , are eligible to and, if the challenged portions of the
Policy were enjoined, would reobtain their PFACs .
17. Julian E. Barnes is a national security reporter with The Times who focuses on the
Pentagon, United States intelligence agencies, and international security, among other subjects.
Barnes has been with The Times since June 2018. Prior to that, Barnes covered the Pentagon for
other news organizations including U.S. News and World Report, The Los Angeles Times, and
The Wall Street Journal. He was first issued a PFAC in 2004. With the exception of an
approximately 18-month period in 2016 and 2017, Barnes continuously held a PFAC from 2004
until the end of August 2025, when it lapsed. Though he was eligible to and invited to do so,
Barnes did not seek to renew his PFAC due to the Policy. As a result of the Policy, Barnes was
compelled to turn in his lapsed PFAC on October 15, 2025. Barnes resides in the District of
7Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 9 of 41
Columbia and is assigned to The Times' Washington Bureau.
18. Defendant United States Department of Defense, also known as the Departmentof
War, is an executive agency ofthe U.S. federal government tasked with overseeing the U.S. Armed
Forces. The Department is headquartered at the Pentagon and maintains offices and facilities in
Washington, DC, and conducts a substantial amount of official business in and relating to this
District. The Department's address is 1400 Defense Pentagon, Washington, DC 20301.
19. Defendant Pete Hegseth is the U.S. Secretary of Defense. He is sued in his official
capacity. Secretary Hegseth is responsible for overseeing the operations and administration ofthe
Department ofDefense and the U.S. Armed Forces, which include the Army, the Navy, theMarine
Corps, the Air Force, and the National Guard, as well as developing national defense policy. He
has ultimate authority over all Department policies, including the Policy at issue here, and he
conducts a substantial amount of official business in and relating to this District. As a member of
the President's Cabinet, Secretary Hegseth regularly performs his official duties within the District
ofColumbia.
20. Defendant Sean Parnell is the Chief Spokesman for the Pentagon and Assistant to
the Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs and conducts a substantial amount of official business
in and relating to this District. He is sued in his official capacity. Parnell serves as the
Department's principal spokesperson responsible for providing timely and accurate information
about the Department to the media, the U.S. Congress, and the public. He also coordinates and
conducts press briefings with members of the media. He issued the “Memorandum for Senior
Pentagon Leadership” (“Memorandum”) that, together with the “Pentagon Reservation In-Brief
for Media Members” (“In-Brief ”), constitute the Policy and, on information and belief, is
responsible for implementation ofthe Policy.
8Case 1 :25- cv- 04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25
Page 10 of 41
21 . This Court has subject-matter jurisdiction because this action arises under the
Constitution ofthe United States and federal statutes , 28 U.S.C. § 1331 , and because the individual
Defendants are U.S. officials sued in their official capacities , 28 U.S.C. § 1346(a)(2) .
22.
The Court is authorized to grant the requested relief under 28 U.S.C. §§ 2201 and
JURISDICTION AND VENUE
2202 , 5 U.S.C. § 706, Rule 65 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure , and pursuant to its inherent
equitable powers.
23. Venue is proper in this District under 28 U.S.C. § 1391 (b) and 28 U.S.C.
§ 1391(e)(1 ) because Barnes resides in this District, because The Times and its journalists,
including Barnes, regularly engage in newsgathering and reporting in this District, including at
The Times ' Washington Bureau , and because Defendants conduct a substantial amount of official
business in this District, and a substantial part ofthe events giving rise to the claims occurred in
the District of Columbia. In particular, among other things, Secretary Hegseth, as a member of
the President's Cabinet,
“ performs a significant amount of his official duties in the District of
Columbia," Bartman v. Cheney, 827 F. Supp . 1 , 2 n.2 (D.D.C. 1993 ) ( citation omitted); see also
Chin -Young v . Esper, 2019 WL 4247260 , at * 5 (D.D.C. Sep. 6 , 2019 ), and the Department's
decision -making with respect to the development and implementation of the Policy occurred , in
substantial part, within this District.
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS
The Pentagon Announces a New PFAC Policy
24. There is a long tradition ofjournalists covering the military from the grounds ofthe
Pentagon . That access has enabled , among other things , real- time , eyewitness reporting on the
Department's response to the terrorist attacks of September 11 , 2001 , including the attack on the
9Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 11 of 41
Pentagon itself coverage the Department has lauded. Indeed, the ability ofjournalists to cover
the military from Pentagon grounds benefits the American public, in part, because it gives
Department officials the ability to correct misinformation and get accurate information to
journalists and, in turn, to the public quickly when there is a crisis.
25. Since the Pentagon opened in 1942, Department officials have afforded qualified
members of the press, including reporters with The Times, access to the Pentagon complex to
report on the military and other defense activities.
" Hanson W. Baldwin, a Times reporter who
won a Pulitzer Prize in 1943 for his coverage of World War II, for example, routinely visited the
Pentagon to gather news and speak with Department sources.
26. Historically, the press has had unescorted access to areas including the Pentagon
Press Briefing Room. As Times opinion columnist Maureen Dowd described in an October 18,
2025 column about the Policy, journalists from The Times and other media outlets previously
"could stake out Jim Mattis, a defense secretary in President Trump's first term, when he picked
up his clothes at an in-house dry cleaners and have an off-the-record chat as he walked back to his
office, shirts slung over his shoulder” or “might bump into the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of
Staffat a Pentagon Starbucks and have a conversation that could turn into a story.
" 10
' In addition,
since the 1970s, the Pentagon provided reporters with dedicated office space in the building,
8 See, e.g. , Jim Garamone, Senior Pentagon Correspondent Recalls 9/11, DOD News (Sept. 7,
2021), https://www.war.gov/News/Feature-Stories/Story/Article/2765676/senior-cnn-pentagon-
correspondent-recalls-911/ (Department press office interview with then-ABC News producer
Barbara Starr recounting her coverage of 9/11 from the Pentagon).
9 Eleanor Watson, CBS News Ends Over 60-YearPresence at Pentagon After Declining to Sign
New Press Requirements, CBS News (Oct. 17, 2025), https://www.cbsnews.com/news/cbs-news-
pentagon-60-year-presence-press-requirements/.
10 Maureen Dowd, Fraidy-Cat at the Pentagon, N.Y. Times (Oct. 18, 2025),
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/18/opinion/pentagon-journalists-news-hegseth.html .
10Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 12 of 41
known as the Pentagon News Room, where reporters set up desks and TV network booths.
Qualified members ofthe press, including Times journalists, have had access to such areas within
the Pentagon building for more than eight decades. That access, which was not conditioned on the
perceived viewpoint ofjournalists and their news organizations, or the content of their reporting,
served the interests of the American public and posed no security or safety risk to Pentagon
property or personnel.
27. Since Secretary Hegseth tookoffice— and, in particular, since March of2025, when
Secretary Hegseth and other top officials inadvertently disclosed details regarding imminent U.S.
airstrikes in Yemen to journalist Jeffrey Goldberg of The Atlantic by adding him to a group chat
on the messaging platform Signal—the Department has sought to impose increasingly stringent
and unprecedented restrictions on journalists covering the Department and its leadership.¹¹
28. On May 23, 2025, Secretary Hegseth issued what he called “Updated Physical
Control Measures for Press/Media Access Within the Pentagon,
" imposing restrictions on
journalists' access to specific areas of the building, including in the vicinity of his office, and
requiring journalists to be accompanied by official “escorts” when visiting certain areas . See Ex.
F at 1-2. These changes were not precipitated by any security or safety incident involving a PFAC
holder. On the contrary, according to the “Memorandum for Resident and Visiting Press Assigned
to the Pentagon,
” these “updated security measures” were purportedly “needed to reduce the
opportunities for in-person inadvertent and unauthorized disclosures.
” Id.; see also Erik Wemple,
Inside Hegseth's Effort to Limit Press Access at the Pentagon, N.Y. Times (Oct. 10, 2025)
(“Under [Secretary Hegseth's] leadership, the [D]epartment has removed national news outlets
11 See JeffreyGoldberg, The Trump Administration Accidentally TextedMe Its WarPlans, The
Atlantic (Mar. 24, 2025), https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2025/03/trump-
administration-accidentally-texted-me-its-war-plans/682151/.
11Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 13 of 41
from a shared media workspace [and] has scaled back reporters' ability to roam Pentagon
corridors.
").12 These restrictions coincide with other efforts by the Department to restrictthe flow
of newsworthy information to the public, both via the press,
13
¹³ and via Congress.¹
14
29.
On September 18, 2025, Parnell issued a “Memorandum for Senior Pentagon
Leadership" ("September 18 Memorandum”) attaching a “Pentagon Reservation In-Brief for
Media Members” (“September 18 In-Brief ” ; together, the “September 18 Policy”). In the
September 18 Memorandum, which purported to implement the Department's “Updated Physical
Control Measures for Press/Media Access Within the Pentagon,
” Parnell announced new policies
governing the issuance, renewal, suspension, and revocation of PFACs that went even further than
the newly instituted “physical control measures.
” Ex. E at 3–10.
30. The September 18 Memorandum explained that “[a]ll members ofthe press issued
a [PFAC] will be required to read and sign a new in-brief form outlining information security
requirements, the new physical control measures, and [Department] expectations of their
compliance with safety and security requirements.
” Ex. E at 1 .
31. In addition to setting out specific requirements for physical presence within the
facility, including restrictions on journalists' access to certain floors of the Pentagon, Ex. E at 4,
the September 18 In-Brief also included provisions addressed to the “unauthorized” disclosure of
12 https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/10/business/media/hegseth-pentagon-press-access.html.
13 See, e.g., Dan Lamothe & Ellen Nakashima, Hegseth team told to stop polygraph tests after
complaint to White House, Wash. Post (July 26, 2025),
https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2025/07/26/pete-hegseth-leak-investigation-
trump/.
14 See , e.g., Ben Finley & Konstantin Toropin, Hegseth changes policy on how Pentagon
officials communicate with Congress, Wash. Post (Oct. 21, 2025),
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2025/10/21/defense-department-pentagon-hegseth-
congress/90711972-aef4-11f0-ab72-a5fffa9bf3eb_story.html .
12Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 14 of 41
information. Specifically, it stated that “[Department] information must be approved for public
release by an appropriate authorizing official before it is released, even if it is unclassified" because
"[u]nauthorized disclosure of CNSI [classified national security information] or CUI [controlled
unclassified information] poses a security risk that could damage the national security of the
United States and place [Department] personnel in jeopardy.
” Id. at 5.
32. The September 18 iteration of the In-Briefwas followed by an “Acknowledgment"
that required PFAC holders to agree that they could be “determined to pose a security or safety
risk . . . based on the unauthorized access, attempted unauthorized access, or unauthorized
disclosure of [classified national security information] or [controlled unclassified information],
”
and to initial next to other statements, including that “PFACs are a courtesy.
” Ex. E at 11 .
33. The September 18 In-Briefalso set forth a process for PFAC issuance, renewal, and
termination. It provided that "PFACs may be denied, revoked, or not renewed if a person is
reasonably determined to pose a security or safety risk to [Department] personnel or property[.]"
Ex. E at 6, 11. It further provided that “[a]n initial determination of security or safety risk may
result in an immediate suspension of Pentagon access during the process for making a final
determination,
" which “may be based on the unauthorized access, attempted unauthorized access,
or unauthorized disclosure" of Department information. Id. at 6; see id. at 11 .
34. An Appendix to the September 18 Policy provided that the grounds for determining
whether a journalist poses a security or safety risk “include, but are not limited to,
” convictions for
certain offenses or “actions other than conviction . such as attempts to improperly obtain"
Department information, or “being found in physical possession of " such information “without
reporting it.
" Ex. E at 13. This Appendix also stated that a PFAC holder would be notified of a
13Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 15 of 41
decision to deny, revoke, or not renew a PFAC in writing, including the basis for the decision,
after which the journalist would have 30 days to appeal that decision. Id. at 13–14.
Members ofthe Press Object to the Policy
35. The Department's announcement of its new Policy sparked widespread confusion
and concern among news organizations and journalists who cover the Pentagon. On September
22, the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press (the "Reporters Committee” or “RCFP")
sent a letter to Parnell asking for clarification as to how the Policy's restriction on disclosure would
be applied and whether the Acknowledgment was intended to require journalists to agree not to
publish information without first obtaining Department approval. Ex. B.
36. In a response letter dated September 24, Parnell wrote to "clarif [y]" that the
restriction against disclosure in the Policy is one that Pentagon personnel must follow, and "does
not impose restrictions on journalistic activities, such as investigating, reporting, or publishing
stories.
” Ex. C at 1 , 3. According to Parnell,
“it informs PFAC holders of [the Department]'s
internal policies and the process for managing building access, which is a privilege extended to
facilitate responsible coverage.
" Id. The letter disclaimed any attempt to require that
“reporters . . . seek [Department] approval for their stories or endorse any viewpoint on pre-
authorization,
" and stated that “[j ]ournalists remain free to gather information through legitimate
means, such as Freedom of Information Act requests, official briefings, or unsolicited tips, and to
publish as they deem newsworthy.
” Id. at 2.
37. This letter, however, provided cold comfort. According to Parnell, the "focus "of
the Policy was “on preventing active solicitation that encourages [Department] personnel to violate
these disclosure rules, as such conduct is not always protected by the First Amendment.
" Ex. C at
2. Parnell also confirmed that the First Amendment-protected receipt and publication of
14Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 16 of 41
unsolicited, classified or protected information “could factor” into the Department's wholly
“discretion[ary]” decision to revoke a reporter's PFAC. Id.
38. On September 28, 2025, Timothy Parlatore-Secretary Hegseth's private attorney
and advisor¹5 -circulated a redlined, revised version of the Acknowledgement to members ofthe
media integrating language from the Parnell letter. Ex. D. The revisions included a number of
statements that appeared designed to characterize the Policy, including the Acknowledgment
requirement, as“not impos[ing] any obligations on [PFAC holders] to refrain from constitutionally
protected journalistic activities.
” Id. at 2. But these statements contradicted other specific
statements in the Policy that do in fact directly intrude on “ constitutionally protected journalistic
activities.
" Id. For example, the Policy as revised continued to expressly claim that Department
officials had uncabined “ discretion[]" to immediately suspend a PFAC based on a determination
that activities protected by the First Amendment, including lawful newsgathering and publication,
posed a “security or safety risk.
” Ex. A at 10. And, according to the redlined Acknowledgement,
any “direct communications with specific [Department] personnel or general appeals, such as
public advertisements or calls for tips”—typical, lawful newsgathering techniques that journalists
routinely utilize— would constitute “solicitation” in violation ofthe Policy. Ex. D at 2.
39. News organizations and PFAC-holding journalists from numerous outlets,
including The Times, informed Pentagon leadership that the September 28, 2025 revisions to the
Policy did not cure its constitutional defects and that they could not sign the Acknowledgement
consistent with their rights and responsibilities as members ofthe press.
15 See Dan Lamothe, Hegseth's legalfixer at the center ofPentagon's new media restrictions,
Wash. Post (Oct. 15, 2025), https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-
security/2025/10/15/hegseth-media-restrictions-tim-parlatore/.
15Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 17 of 41
The Pentagon Announces Its Final Policy and Mandates That PFAC Holders Sign the
Acknowledgement
40. On October 6, 2025, the Department issued its final Policy, a true and correct copy
ofwhich is attached hereto as Exhibit A.
41 . The current and final version ofthe Policy includes an Acknowledgment that states:
I have received, read, and understand the “Pentagon Reservation In-brieffor Media
Members,
" with [relevant appendices] which address[] the standard and procedures
for denying, revoking, and not renewing a PFAC.
The in-brief describes
[Department] policies and procedures. My signature represents my
acknowledgement and understanding of such [Department] policies and procedures,
even if I do not necessarily agree with such policies and procedures. Signing this
acknowledgment does not waive any rights I may have under law.
Exhibit A at 14.
42. Even though the Policy invokes the Secretary's statutory authority under 10 U.S.C.
§ 2674 to safeguard the physical property of the Pentagon itself, the Policy was neither motivated
by nor narrowly tailored to any such interest. To the contrary, the Policy reaffirms the
Department's position that it possesses unbridled discretion to rescind a PFAC based on First
Amendment-protected newsgathering and reporting wherever it occurs. Specifically, the In-Brief
states that while allowing that “the receipt of unsolicited" classified or unclassified information
"and its subsequent publication is generally protected by the First Amendment and would not, on
its own, normally trigger denial, revocation, or non-renewal of a PFAC,
” if a journalist "solicit[s]
the disclosure of such information or otherwise encourages [ Department] personnel to violate laws
and policies concerning the disclosure of such information,
” the Department may deem the
journalist a "security or safety risk.
” Id. at 12.
43. Withrespect to what constitutes improper “solicitation” in the Department's view,
the In-Brief states that “solicitation” in violation of the Policy "may include direct communications
with specific [Department] personnel or general appeals, such as public advertisements or calls for
16Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 18 of 41
tips . ..
"
” and it cites “an advertisement or social media post by an individual journalist or social
media outlet that directly targets [Department] personnel to disclose non-public information
without proper authorization” as an “example” ofwhat “would constitute a solicitation that could
lead to revocation " of a PFAC. Ex. A at 12–13.
44. The Policy also takes an expansive approach to what “non-public information" the
Department may view as being off limits, and if “solicited,
” obtained or published could result in
the denial, suspension or revocation of a reporter's PFAC. According to the Policy, such
unclassified information “may include, but is not limited to, information protected by the Privacy
Act, information that is law enforcement-sensitive, and certain operational security information.
"
Id. at 6. And purportedly “ [t]o ensure the safety ofU.S. personnel,
” the Policy instructs journalists
“who find themselves in possession of information that appears to be [classified national security
information] or [controlled unclassified information]” to “discuss those materials with the
[Pentagon Press Operations] prior to publication.
” Id.
45. In addition to reiterating the Department's view that “members of the news media
do not possess a legal right to access the Pentagon" and that “such access is a privilege subject to
the discretion of government authorities,
” Ex. A, at 3 , the Policy explains that a PFAC "may be
denied, revoked, or not renewed if a person is reasonably determined to pose a security or safety
risk to [Department] personnel or property,
" and that “[s]uch determination may be based on
factors including, but not limited to, the unauthorized access, attempted unauthorized access, or
unauthorized disclosure of " classified or unclassified information “based on a reasonable
assessment informed by the unique facts and circumstances of each case.
" Id. at 12.
46. The Policy further states that Pentagon officials have the discretion to “deny,
revoke, or refuse to renew the PFAC of any person reasonably determined to pose a security or
17Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 19 of 41
safety risk to [Department] personnel or property.
” Ex. A at 15. It explains that " [p]ersons
presumed to present such a risk include, but are not limited to, those who have been convicted of
any offense involving ,
” among other things “[u]nprofessional conduct that might serve to disrupt
Pentagon operations.
” Id. (emphasis added). The Policy does not explain what type of
“conviction” it refers to with respect to “[u]nprofessional conduct,
” and expressly notes that
“actions other than conviction may be deemed to pose a security or safety risk.
” Id.
47. The Policy expressly states that an “initial determination” that ajournalist “pose[s]
a security or safety risk. . . may result in an immediate suspension” of a PFAC “while the
procedures preceding a final determination are pending.
” Ex. A at 12.
48. Following its issuance of the Policy on October 6, the Department gave PFAC
holders until October 14 to review and sign the Acknowledgment.
49. The decision to issue the Policy, as well as related decisions regarding the content
of the Policy, were made either in full or in substantial part by Secretary Hegseth and other
Department officials and advisors located in the District of Columbia.
The Department Revokes Reporters' Access
50.
Prior to the Department's deadline, journalists with PFACs at The Times and
virtually every other major news organization covering the Pentagon uniformly declined to sign
the Acknowledgment. Instead, they informed Pentagon officials that they believed the Policy, and
the Department's insistence that they sign the Acknowledgment, violated their First Amendment
rights. As a result, on October 15, 2025, they were compelled to turn in their PFACs. On
information and belief, of the 56 news outlets represented in the Pentagon Press Association
(PPA), only one agreed to sign the Acknowledgement.
18Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 20 of 41
The Department Selects a New “Pentagon Press Corps” Based on Viewpoint
51. Within days, Parnell took to his officialX account to “ announce the next generation
of the Pentagon press corps .
" In describing the “[n]ew media outlets” willing to accede to the
Department's “media access policy,
" Parnell wrote that they “circumvent the lies of the
mainstream media and get real news to the American people,
” and “[t]heir reach and impact
collectively are far more effective and balanced than the self-righteous media who chose to self-
deport from the Pentagon"-journalists “in the mainstream media” whom Parnell described as
"activists who masquerade as journalists.
"16
52. New PFACrecipients include the National Pulse, which was described by its editor-
in-chief as “an industry mag/site for MAGA world" ; Laura Loomer, an “influential pro-Trump
activist"; and former congressman Matt Gaetz, President Trump's one-time choice for Attorney
General of the United States, who is now affiliated with One America News .17 Many have
expressed ideological support for the Trump administration or indicated that they do not intend to
report critically on the Pentagon. 18 For example, Libby Emmons, the editor-in-chief of Human
Events and the Post Millennial who requested four passes for her staff after “receiv[ing] an
unsolicited invitation to apply for credentials,
" stated that “[t]here should be a place for reporting
on what they are doing without always trying to expose the dark underbelly,
” and Tim Pool, who
16 Sean Parnell (@SeanParnellASW), X (Oct. 22, 2025, at 1:21 PM),
https://x.com/SeanParnellASW/status/1981048206923329719.
17 Besinger & Wemple, New Pentagon Press Crew Is All In on Trump, supra n.5; David Bauder,
Somefriendly, some on-the-news questions atfirstbriefingfor new Pentagon press corps, AP
News (Dec. 2, 2025), https://apnews.com/article/pentagon-press-corps-access-journalists-
96163e7ac0c8a73a44178fb5bb852863.
18 Besinger & Wemple, New Pentagon Press Crew Is All In on Trump, supra n. 5 .
19Case 1 :25- cv- 04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 21 of41
event with Secretary Hegseth.20 In welcoming what she called the “ official new members of the
disclosed that his outlet would be getting a credential , explained that his is “not an investigative
19
news organization” and he did “not intend to maintain a significant presence in the Pentagon .
”"
53. Earlier this week, the Department held its first in-person press events on Pentagon
grounds since the Policy went into effect, which included a press briefing and a “meet- and - greet ”
Pentagon Press Corps ," Pentagon Press Secretary Kingsley Wilson ( "Wilson") specifically
focused on the Department's preference for their First Amendment activities. She criticized
journalists and news organizations, like Plaintiffs, who had previously held PFACs, calling them
"propagandists " who "stopped telling the truth,
” and she praised those the Department had selected
to cover the Pentagon , asserting that they “actually reach Americans, ask real questions , and don't
pursue a biased agenda.
54. ”21
Similarly, in determining when solicitation of unapproved information is
permissible, the Department has already drawn distinctions based on favored and disfavored
content and speakers . In her X post announcing that LOOMERED “is now a credentialed outlet
at the Pentagon,
” Loomer stated : “ I have developed a Rolodex of sources and if you have any tips ,
feel free to contact the Loomered Tip Line: the most influential Tip Line in all of DC.
”22 When
19 Id.
20
Scott Nover, Pentagon's right-wing, pared press corps gets a meet -and-greet, Wash . Post
(Nov. 29, 2025 ), https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2025/11/29/pentagon-press-policy-
hegseth/.
21 DOW Rapid Response (@DOWResponse) , X (Dec. 2 , 2025 , at 11:21 am ) ,
https://x.com/DOWResponse/status/1995890967002452302.
22
Laura Loomer (@LauraLoomer), X (Nov. 3 , 2025 , at 11:13 PM),
https://x.com/LauraLoomer/status/1985560924720124414 .
20Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 22 of 41
asked whether Loomer's “request for tips violates its new press policy,
"23 the Department
responded that it did not. Through a statement attributable to Wilson, the Department stated:
Unlike [the Washington Post's] solicitation, which explicitly and exclusively targets
military personnel and DoW employees, Laura Loomer's X post regarding tips to her news
outlet is a general tip line, which is constitutionally permissible. Therefore it does not
violate the Pentagon's media access policy. This distinction was explained in detail to the
Pentagon Press Association before they chose to engage in a dishonest and performative
walk out. IfFake News reporters actually had a brain and could read our policy correctly,
then maybe one day they will be as effective of a journalist as Ms. Loomer is.
24
This explanation came on the heels of another statement from Wilson in which she asserted that
"we have seen a lot of the mainstream media continue to lie.
"25
55.
In another instance, at the first official press conference held by Wilson on
December 2, 2025, James O'Keefe, founder of the conservative group Project Veritas, noted that
he had surreptitiously recorded a high-level Pentagon official making unguarded statements that
were plainly unapproved by Department leadership-newsgathering now ostensibly prohibited by
the Policy. Wilson, however, praised O'Keefe's work, which appeared to expose a critic of
President Trump, noting: “That's why the work you all do is so important.
"26
56. While the Pentagon has opened its press room to those who are willing to report
only the official line, the need for independent reporting has been underscored by the ongoing
public controversies involving the Pentagon. For example, on December 1 , 2025, The Times
23 Scott Nover (@ScottNover), X (Nov. 4, 2025, at 1:53 PM),
https://x.com/ScottNover/status/1985782401755128207.
24 Scott Nover (@ScottNover), X (Nov. 4, 2025, at 2:02 PM),
https://x.com/ScottNover/status/1985784630100804036.
25 Besinger & Wemple, New Pentagon Press Crew Is All In on Trump, supra n. 5.
26 James O'Keefe Asks Pentagon Press Secretary Question About Identifying Anti-Trump
Members ofDOD, Forbes Breaking News, YouTube (Dec. 2, 2025),
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BQfpJfAgIdU; see also James O'Keefe
(@JamesOkeefeIII) , X (Apr. 23 , 2025 at 3:46 PM),
https://x.com/JamesOKeefeIII/status/1915175452404035624.
21Case 1 :25- cv- 04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 23 of 41
of drugs.27 The Times' reporting was based on information gathered from “five U.S. officials,
reported that the U.S. military's strikes on a boat in the Caribbean Sea, which occurred on
September 2 , 2025 , were made in response to a directive by Secretary Hegseth that the strike
should kill the peopleon board and destroy the vessel and its contents , including a purported cargo
who spoke separately and on the condition of anonymity.”28
57.
In recent weeks , The Times also has reported , inter alia, on efforts by Secretary
Hegseth to fire or sideline generals and admirals,29 the Pentagon's inquiry into Senator Mark
Kelly's remarks urging members of the military not to follow illegal orders, 30 and significant
changes to United States military personnel policies and training requirements.³¹
58 . Attack butNotthe Killing ofSurvivors, Officials Say, N.Y. Times (Dec. 1 , 2025),
While reporters from The Times and other news organizations without PFACs have
continued and will continue to gather news and publish important stories about the Department
and the United States military, the Policy ensures that certain stories will no longer be available to
those journalists and news organizations and to the public that relies on their reporting. As one
new PFAC recipient put it earlier this week when asked why he was reporting from the Pentagon:
27 Charlie Savage , Julian E. Barnes , Eric Schmitt & John Ismay, Hegseth Ordered a Lethal
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/01/us/hegseth-drug-boat-strike-order-venezuela.html .
28 Id
.
29 Greg Jaffe, Eric Schmitt & Helene Cooper, Hegseth Is Purging Military Leaders WithLittle
Explanation, N.Y. Times (Nov. 7, 2025) ,
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/07/us/politics/hegseth-firing-military-leaders.html .
30
Greg Jaffee, Pentagon Opens Inquiry Into Senator MarkKelly Over WhatHegseth Calls
' Seditious ' Video, N.Y. Times (Nov. 24, 2025),
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/24/us/politics/mark-kelly-pentagon-investigation.html .
31
, e.g. , Dave Phillipps, Veterans See Costs and Risks in Hegseth's Military Rewind to 1990,
N.Y. Times (Oct. 2 , 2025 ), https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/02/us/hegseth-military-veterans-
standards.html ; John Ismay, What Women Heard in Hegseth's Remarks About Physical
Standards, N.Y. Times (Oct. 2 , 2025), https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/02/us/politics/women-
military-hegseth-physical-standards.html.
See
22Case 1 :25- cv- 04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 24 of41
"
Press have always worked at the Pentagon . ... Correspondents place themselves at the buildings
so when a major story breaks they're there to cover it.”³2
59 . Stories based on routine unplanned interactions between journalists and Pentagon
personnel on Pentagon grounds , stories based on probing questions asked at press briefings and
up questions posed to officials by reporters from other
person , and often spontaneous exchanges, in which reporters can judge the demeanor of
government officials as they respond to questions in real time and press for more information on
news conferences , stories built from follow-
outlets, and stories that capture the mood and atmosphere within the Pentagon during times of
consequential military operations are all examples of what Plaintiffs can no longer report. In-
the spot, are different in kind and can elicit different information than inquiries by phone or by
email . Without their PFACs, Plaintiffs and other journalists and news organizations are deprived
of unique , newsworthy information that can only be obtained in person and through such
exchanges . Cf. ABC , Inc. v Stewart, 360 F.3d 90, 99 (2d Cir. 2004) (
“
[O] ne cannot transcribe an
anguished look or a nervous tic.
"
).
CLAIMS FOR RELIEF
COUNT I
Violation ofthe Due Process Clause (Void for Vagueness)
( APA, 5 U.S.C. § 706 )
60. Plaintiffs incorporate by reference the allegations of the preceding paragraphs of
the Complaint.
61 . The Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment provides that “
No person shall
be . . . deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.” U.S. Const. amend . V.
32 Cam Higby (@camhigby ) , X (Dec. 1 , 2025 , at 4:45 PM),
https://x.com/camhigby/status/1995655541474165162.
23Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 25 of 41
The Times and its reporters, including Barnes, have both a liberty and a property interest in their
PFACS.
62. The Policy violates the Due Process Clause because it "fail[s] to provide the kind
of notice that will enable ordinary people to understand what conduct it prohibits” and
"authorize[s] and even encourage[s] arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement.
" City ofChicago
v. Morales, 527 U.S. 41 , 56 (1999). In both respects the Policy is unconstitutionally vague.
63. "A law is unconstitutionally vague if it fails to provide a person of ordinary
intelligence fair notice of what is prohibited or is so standardless that it authorizes or encourages
seriously discriminatory enforcement.
" Woodhull Freedom Found. v. United States, 72 F.4th
1286, 1303 (D.C. Cir. 2023) (quotations omitted). The vagueness doctrine serves to ensure that
“regulated parties [ ] know what is required of them so they may act accordingly” and “that those
enforcing the law do not act in an arbitrary or discriminatory way.
" FCC v. Fox Television
Stations, Inc., 567 U.S. 239, 253 (2012).
"When speech is involved, rigorous adherence to those
requirements is necessary to ensure that ambiguity does not chill protected speech.
" Id. at 253-
54; see also Grayned v. City of Rockford, 408 U.S. 104, 109 (1972) (“[W]here a vague statute
'abut[s] upon sensitive areas of basic First Amendment freedoms,
' it ‘ operates to inhibit the
exercise of [those] freedoms.
' Uncertain meanings inevitably lead citizens to ‘ steer far wider of
the unlawful zone'
... than if the boundaries ofthe forbidden areas were clearly marked.
” ” ).
64. It is “[a] fundamental principle in our legal system” that “laws which regulate
persons or entities must givefair notice of conduct that is forbidden or required.
” Karem, 960 F.3d
at 664 (quoting Fox Television, 567 U.S. at 253). As the D.C. Circuit has recognized,
“[s]uch
'[e]lementary notions of fairness'
...
'dictate that a person receive fair notice not only of the
conduct that will subject him to punishment, but also of the severity of the penalty that [the
24Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 26 of 41
government] may impose. 222
Id . (quoting BMW ofN. Am., Inc. v. Gore, 517 U.S. 559, 574 (1996)
(alternations in original)). Simply put, as the Supreme Court has made clear,
“the Due Process
Clause does not permit” the Department “to classify arbitrariness as a virtue.
" State Farm Mut.
Auto. Ins. Co. v. Campbell, 538 U.S. 408, 418 (2003) (quoting Pac. Mut. Life Ins. Co. v. Haslip,
499 U.S. 1 , 59 (O'Connor, J., dissenting) (explaining that the government “can have no legitimate
interest in deliberately making the law so arbitrary that citizens will be unable to avoidpunishment
based solely upon bias or whim")). These principles carry special force in the First Amendment
context, Karem, 960 F.3d at 660, and alone warrant injunctive relief, id. at 668.
65.
"[T]he suspension of a hard pass, like the denial of a hard pass ,
'implicate[s]'
'important first amendment rights,
" " and therefore must be “evaluate[ d] . . . under a particularly
'stringent vagueness [and fair-notice] test.
” Karem, 960 F.3d at 665 (quoting Sherrill, 569 F.2d
at 130). To afford adequate process, the government must provide sufficient advance notice
through “explicit and meaningful standard[s]" that are “formally articulated or published,
” and
specifically describe both the conduct that would warrant sanctions and the severity of the
sanctions that may be imposed . Id. at 660 (quoting Sherrill, 569 F.2d at 130–31).
66. The Policy fails to provide fair notice. Instead, it makes immediate suspension and
eventual revocation of a PFAC a wholly discretionary determination such that Department officials
"may " (or may not) determine that a PFAC holder is a “safety or security" risk based on a number
of factors, including the lawful newsgathering and reporting that Plaintiffs engage in every day
and intend to continue to engage in. See Ex. A at 12-13 . The Policy also threatens to revoke
PFACS when Pentagon officials in their sole discretion conclude journalists have engaged in
“[u]nprofessional conduct that might serve to disrupt Pentagon operations.
” Id. at 15. The Policy
is also internally contradictory; it claims not to target constitutionally protected activities but
25Case 1 :25- cv- 04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 27 of 41
creates a system that , on its face, does just that . The Policy's lack of objective, discernible
enforcement standards, coupled with its inherently contradictory provisions , deprive PFAC
holders ofthe requisite “fair notice" to satisfy the demands of Due Process.
67. The Act is independently void for vagueness because the law “is so standardless
that it authorizes or encourages seriously discriminatory enforcement.
” United States v. Williams,
553 U.S. 285 , 304
(2008)
.
Plaintiffs
68.
69.
In each respect, the Policy violates the Fifth Amendment facially and as applied to
.
Defendants ' adoption ofthe Policy constitutes final agency action reviewable under
the APA, 5 U.S.C. § 706 .
70. The Policy has caused Plaintiffs irreparable harm and is causing ongoing
irreparable harm to Plaintiffs as well as the public.
71 . The Court should declare specified provisions ofthe Policy contrary to law, enjoin
Defendants from implementing them, and vacate any agency action implementing those provisions
ofthe Policy.
COUNT II
Violation ofthe First Amendment
(
Unbridled Discretion)
(APA, 5 U.S.C. § 706 )
72. Plaintiffs incorporate by reference the allegations ofthe preceding paragraphs.
73 . The Supreme Court has long recognized “the time-tested knowledge that in the area
of free expression a licensing statute placing unbridled discretion in the hands of a government
official or agency constitutes a prior restraint and may result in censorship.
” City of Lakewood ,
486 U.S. at 757. “[E]ven if the government may constitutionally impose content -neutral
prohibitions on a particular manner of speech, it may not condition that speech on obtaining a
26Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 28 of 41
license or permit from a government official in that official's boundless discretion.
" Id. at 764.
That is because “a law or policy permitting communication in a certain manner for some but not
for others raises the specter of content and viewpoint censorship" and that "danger is at its zenith
when the determination of who may speak and who may not is left to the unbridled discretion ofa
government official.
” Id. at 763.
74. The Policy has established a licensing regime that conditions Plaintiffs' ability to
gather news on Pentagon grounds on obtaining a PFAC that can be suspended, denied, or revoked
in the Department's “boundless discretion,
" including for speech and newsgathering that takes
place off Pentagon grounds. Id. at 764.
75. The Policy expressly permits Pentagon officials to determine that a journalist
"pose[s] a security or safety risk to [Department] personnel or property,
” based on that journalist's
receipt, publication, or “solicitation” of any “unauthorized” information, Ex . A at 12-13, without
limitation, and expressly provides that such a determination “may result in an immediate
suspension of Pentagon access.
" Id. at 8, 12. This determination is made by Department
officials based on “the unique facts and circumstances of each case,
' "on a case-by-case basis,
"
and considering “the totality of the circumstances.
" Id. at 12-13. The Policy thereby vests
Department officials with unbridled discretion to suspend and/or revoke reporters' access to the
Pentagon for engaging in lawful newsgathering or for reporting any information not approved by
Department officials-regardless of whether such newsgathering occurs on or off Pentagon
grounds, and regardless of whether the information at issue is classified or unclassified. Id.; see
also Ex. C. at 2.
76. By vesting Department officials with unbridled discretion to cause the “immediate
suspension of [reporters'] Pentagon access” and to “ den[y], revoke[], not renew[], or suspend[]" a
27Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 29 of 41
reporter's PFAC based on the information that reporter has “solicited,
" received, written, or
published, Ex . A at 8, 12–13, 15, the Policy constitutes precisely the kind of “prior restraint”
described in City of Lakewood, 486 U.S. at 757. “[T]he mere existence of the [Department's]
unfettered discretion, coupled with the power ofprior restraint,
" is designed to “intimidate[] parties
into censoring their own speech, even if the discretion and power are never actually abused.
” Id.
The Policy is "unconstitutional, because without standards governing the exercise ofdiscretion,
"
the Department “may decide who may” access the Pentagon and "who may not based upon the
content ofthe speech or the viewpoint of the speaker.
” Id. at 763–64.
77. The risk of discretionary punishment based on protected newsgathering and
publication chills the exercise of First Amendment rights. The Policy as written necessarily forces
news organizations and journalists, including Plaintiffs, to weigh the risk of suspension or
revocation oftheir Pentagon access against the public interest in engaging in lawful newsgathering
and reporting. Id. at 757-58. In this way, the Policy impermissibly chills speech and
"discourage[s] the ‘ uninhibited , robust, and wide-open debate that the First Amendment is
intended to protect.
" See Counterman v. Colorado, 600 U.S. 66, 68 (2023) (quoting Rogers v.
United States, 422 U.S. 35, 48 (1975) (quoting Sullivan, 276 U.S. at 270)).
78. In this respect, the Policy violates the First Amendment facially and as applied to
Plaintiffs.
79. Defendants'adoption ofthe Policy constitutes final agency action reviewableunder
the APA, 5 U.S.C. § 706.
80. The Policy has caused Plaintiffs irreparable harm and is causing ongoing
irreparable harm to Plaintiffs as well as the public.
28Case 1 :25- cv- 04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 30of41
81 . The Court should declare specified provisions of the Policy contrary to law, enjoin
Defendants from implementing them, and vacate any agency action implementing those provisions
ofthe Policy
.
COUNT III
Violation of the First Amendment (Unconstitutional Denial of Access to Nonpublic Forum)
(APA, 5 U.S.C. § 706 )
82 . Plaintiffs incorporate by reference the allegations ofthe preceding paragraphs.
83 . News organizations and journalists , including Plaintiffs, have historically had
access to the Pentagon , including to the Pentagon Press Briefing Room , and such access has not
posed any risk to the safety or security ofPentagon property or personnel .
84. " Although the government is not required to open such spaces for any speech at all,
the government creates a ' nonpublic forum '
when it provides ' selective access for individual
speakers.
Pentagon Briefing Room , are nonpublic forums for First Amendment purposes . See Ateba, 133
F.4th at 121-22 (holding that White House press area was a nonpublic forum for First Amendment
purposes); see also United States v. Nassif , 97 F.4th 968 , 976–77 (D.C. Cir. 2024) (United States
Capitol buildings are nonpublic forums for First Amendment purposes).
forum "for its intended purposes, communicative or otherwise , as long as the regulation on speech
is reasonable and not an effort to suppress expression merely because public officials
" Ateba , 133 F.4th at 122 (citations omitted). Areas of the Pentagon , including the
85. As the Supreme Court has recognized, the government may reserve a nonpublic
the
oppose
speaker's view .
" Minnesota Voters Alliance, 585 U.S. at 11–12 .
86. Because the Policy is "an effort to suppress"
speech and newsgatheringon
Pentagon grounds by members of the press , including Plaintiffs, whose reporting and perceived
viewpoints the Department disfavors , the Policy violates the First Amendment. Id.
29 29Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 31 of 41
87. The Policy also violates the First Amendment because its provisions targeting
Plaintiffs' newsgathering and reporting are not reasonable “in light of the purpose served by the
forum.
” Minnesota VotersAlliance, 585 U.S. at 12–13 (citation omitted). Those provisions ofthe
Policy were not prompted by any specific security or safety concern or security incident involving
a PFAC holder and are unrelated to the “security or safety" of "[Department] personnel or
property,
" objectives they purport to further. Ex. A at 12.
88.
That the Policy provides that a PFAC can be suspended, denied, or revoked in the
Department's standardless and “boundless discretion,
" City ofLakewood, 486 U.S. at 764, alone
makes the provisions targeting Plaintiffs' newsgathering and reporting unreasonable.
See
Minnesota VotersAlliance, 585 U.S. at 21–22 (holding that a state's “indeterminate prohibition”
on certain apparel in polling places—nonpublic forums— was unreasonable and therefore violated
the First Amendment including because it failed to include “objective, workable standards” for
enforcement); see also Ateba, 133 F.4th at 125 (explaining that “the exercise of unbridled
discretion to deny access to a nonpublic forum is unreasonable” (citing Am. Freedom Def .
Initiative v.Wash. Metro. Area TransitAuth. 901 F.3d 356, 364 372 (D.C. Cir. 2018))).
89
.
In this respect, the Policy violates the First Amendment facially and as applied to
Plaintiffs.
90. Defendants' adoption ofthe Policy constitutes final agency action reviewableunder
the APA, 5 U.S.C. § 706.
91. The Policy has caused Plaintiffs irreparable harm and is causing ongoing
irreparable harm to Plaintiffs as well as the public.
3030Case 1 :25- cv- 04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 32of41
92 . The Court should declare specified provisions of the Policy contrary to law, enjoin
Defendants from implementing them, and vacate any agency action implementing those provisions
ofthe Policy.
Count IV
Violation of the First Amendment (Content- Based and Viewpoint- Based Restraint on
Newsgathering and Publication)
(APA, 5 U.S.C. § 706 )
93 . Plaintiffs incorporate by reference the allegations ofthe preceding paragraphs .
94 .
“The First Amendment guarantees a free press primarily because of the important
role it can play ‘as a vital source of public information . ”” Zerilli v. Smith, 656 F.2d 705 , 710 (D.C.
Cir. 1981 ) (quoting Grosjean v. American Press Co., 297 U.S. 233 , 250 ( 1936)).
“Without an
unfettered press, citizens would be far less able to make informed political, social, and economic
choices,
" and "journalists frequently depend on informants to gather news .” Id. at 711. The First
Amendment protects not only the right to publish but also journalists ”
“right to gather information ”
because "without some protection for seeking out the news , freedom of the press could be
eviscerated .
" Richmond Newspapers, Inc. , 448 U.S. at 576 (quoting Branzburg, 408 U.S. at 681 ).
95. The First Amendment right to gather information protects reporters' ability to
that the “public harm that would flow from undermining all source relationships would be
receive information, including by developing and speaking to sources. In re Grand Jury Subpoena ,
immense"
).
JudithMiller, 438 F.3d 1141 , 1168 (D.C. Cir. 2006) (Tatel , J., concurring in judgment) ( explaining
96. The newsgathering and publication of information about the Department and its
leadership that Plaintiffs engage in routinely, including the publication of stories based on
information PFAC holders learn from
sources and newsgathering efforts off Pentagon property,
31Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 33 of 41
are protected by the First Amendment. Plaintiffs have continued and intend to continue to engage
in such First Amendment-protected activity, including lawful speech and newsgathering that the
Department deems in violation of its Policy.
97. In its “inevitable effect ” and “stated purposes,
" the Policy is a content-based and
viewpoint-based restriction on such newsgathering and publication; it is therefore subject to strict
scrutiny. Sorrell v. IMS Health, Inc., 564 U.S. 552, 565 (2011) (citation omitted); Reed v. Town
of Gilbert, Ariz. , 576 U.S. 155, 163 (2015) (explaining that content-based restrictions "are
presumptively unconstitutional and may be justified only if the government proves that they are
narrowly tailored to serve compelling state interests"); see also Rosenberger v. Rector & Visitors
of Univ. of Va., 515 U.S. 819 , 829 (1995) (explaining that viewpoint discrimination is an
"egregious form of content discrimination").
98. The In-Brief explains that Plaintiffs' “PFACs may be denied, revoked, or not
renewed if a person is reasonably determined to pose a security or safety risk to [Department]
personnel or property.
” Ex. A at 8, 12. In describing what might make an individual “a security
or safety risk,
" the Policy adopts a content-based standard: such a “determination may be based on
factors including, but not limited to[, ]" the “solicitation” or “unauthorized disclosure" ofclassified
or unclassified information. Id. at 12. The Policy thus permits Department officials, in their
discretion, to cause the “immediate suspension of [Plaintiffs'] Pentagon access” and to "den[y],
revoke[], not renew[], or suspend[]" Plaintiffs' PFACs based on that First Amendment-protected
activity. Id. at 8, 12–13, 15.
99. The Policy is intended to and is being implemented to restrain and chill the speech
and newsgathering activity ofjournalists and news organizations, including Plaintiffs, on the basis
of content and perceived viewpoint. In a recent X post, Parnell explained that the Policy forced
32Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 34 of 41
journalists and news organizations, including Plaintiffs, to “self-deport[]" from the Pentagon,
asserted that those journalists and news organizations “lie[],
” do not report “real news” and are
"activists who masquerade as journalists,
" and called them less “effective and balanced" than their
"new media" replacements,33 who have evinced support for the Trump administration.³4 Such
"viewpoint discrimination is poison.
” Frederick Douglass Found. , Inc. v. District ofColumbia,
82 F.4th 1122, 1141 (D.C. Cir. 2023) (quotations omitted).
100. The Department has made clear that for certain disfavored journalists and news
organizations, providing a means for potential sources to give their journalists tips violates the
Policy. Ex. D at 2. At the same time, the Department has made clear that this same activity, when
engaged in by a favoredjournalist or media outlet, will not be considered by the Department to be
a violation. 35
101. The provisions of the Policy that target speech and newsgathering by members of
the press, including Plaintiffs, are not narrowly tailored to any compelling government interest.
102.
There is an unbroken history of journalists, including journalists with The Times,
reporting from Pentagon grounds without posing any risk to the safety or security of Pentagon
personnel or property and the Policy was not motivated by or implemented to address any
legitimate, specific safety or security concern. The Policy is wholly untethered to any legitimate
interest in preventing “security or safety risk[s ] to [Department] personnel or property,
” Ex. A at
33 Parnell (@SeanParnellASW), X (Oct. 22, 2025, at 1:21 PM).
34 See Besinger & Wemple, New Pentagon Press Crew Is All In on Trump, supra n . 5.
35 Scott Nover (@ScottNover), X (Nov. 4, 2025, at 2:02 PM),
https://x.com/ScottNover/status/1985784630100804036; James O'Keefe Asks Pentagon Press
Secretary Question About Identifying Anti-Trump Members ofDOD, Forbes Breaking News,
YouTube(Dec. 2, 2025), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BQfpJfAgIdU.
33Case 1:25-cv-04218 Document 1 Filed 12/04/25 Page 35 of 41
15, and it fails to leave open adequate "alternative observation opportunities,
” Reed v. Lieurance,
863 F.3d 1196, 1212 (9th Cir. 2017) .
103. Even ifthe Policy did address a legitimate concern about safety or security at the
Pentagon, it is hopelessly overbroad. It seeks to restrain and chill constitutionally protected
newsgathering and reporting that occurs both on and off Pentagon grounds, including "direct
communications with specific [Department] personnel or general appeals, such as public
advertisements or calls for tips ....
" Ex. A at 12-13; see also, e.g. , Grayned, 408 U.S. at 114 (“A
clear and precise enactment may nevertheless be ‘ overbroad' if, in its reach it prohibits
constitutionally protected conduct.
”) .
104. The Policy's ever-present threat ofPFAC suspension or revocation for “ soliciting,
”
receiving, or publishing information about the Department that has not been officially approved
chills the exercise of First Amendment rights in multiple ways. It imposes a gag on allDepartment
employees' communications with the press outside of pre-approved situations. It also states that
a “security or safety risk” determination—warranting potential suspension or revocation of a
PFAC?can be based on “unauthorized access [or] attempted unauthorized access” of classified
or unclassified information. Ex. A at 12. And it provides for potential suspension or revocation
of a PFAC if a reporter “solicit[s] the disclosure of such information or otherwise encourage[s]
[Department] personnel to violate laws and policies concerning the disclosure of such
information.
" Id.
105. As the Supreme Court has recognized,
“self-censorship w[ill] result,
” if
government is permitted to sanction the use of “routine newspaper reporting techniqu[es].
” The
Fla. Star v. B.J.F., 491 U.S. 524, 538 (1989). And“state action to punish the publication of truthful
information seldom can satisfy constitutional standards.
” Smith v. Daily Mail Publishing Co., 443