From The Washington Post:
COP31 negotiations break down as countries fail to agree on climate deal
The exclusion of any mention of fossil fuels caused a rift, and the talks had become the longest in summit history, going into a second day of overtime.
The draft text of the agreement excluded any explicit reference to fossil fuels despite attempts to find a compromise after the issue threatened to derail the talks. Instead, it referred indirectly to an agreement reached at COP28 in Dubai, which committed countries to a transition away from fossil fuels, without repeating that pledge.
Negotiations among the nearly 200 participant countries were in their second day of overtime — making the climate summit the longest in history. It surpassed COP25, held in Madrid in 2019, which ran more than 40 hours beyond its scheduled conclusion.
The European Union formally objected to the COP31 draft, arguing that it “falls well short” of what is needed to address climate change.
Irish Climate Minister Darragh O’Brien, speaking on behalf of the bloc, said the E.U. was “profoundly disappointed” with the draft text, circulated early Sunday, and would not endorse an agreement that “does not even mention fossil fuels.”
We will not accept negotiating backward in time, and we will not accept a COP that greenwashes fossil fuel,” O’Brien told the conference.
Several other countries also rejected the text, including Panama and the Marshall Islands, a central Pacific nation at high risk from the effects of climate change.
“We came here expecting the world to deliver a comprehensive and urgent response on reducing emissions, on protecting our people and on providing the finance to do this. We have been let down on all sides,” the delegate for the Marshall Islands said, adding: “We will not compromise our future to benefit fossil fuel interests. We will not accept an outcome that undermines our security and threatens our future.”
The conference caps off a year that could be the warmest on record, nearing the previous hottest in 2024, with heat waves across the northern hemisphere killing thousands and fueling wildfires.
The summit’s negotiators had to contend with the certainty that the world will miss a central goal from the 2015 Paris Agreement on climate change: Holding global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial times.
Missing that goal means more intense heat and storms, placing renewed emphasis on adapting to the extremes that can no longer be avoided.
But little progress was made in negotiations to increase funding for climate adaptation, as debate broke down over familiar lines. Developing countries demanded more funding from rich nations to confront climate change, in exchange for agreeing to more ambitious goals.
Environmental groups tracking the two-week conference wrote to the COP31 presidents lamenting that the meeting was on track to be “one of the most disappointing COPs” ever because it lacked determination to address the worsening climate crisis.
“The Global South is being abandoned,” said the letter, co-signed by 100 environmental organizations. “Developed countries have blocked progress across the negotiations and arrived with no new finance commitments.”
The draft “is a gift to the fossil fuel industry,” the letter went on. “The major cause of the climate crisis — coal, oil and gas — fails to rate a mention.”
Li Shuo, a Washington-based climate analyst at the Asia Society Policy Institute, said, “The big picture storyline here is the tremendous amount of challenges that the international climate agenda is facing.” He pointed to geopolitical and economic challenges such as President Donald Trump’s tariffs and the Ukraine war’s impact on Europe — as well as the United States’ lack of participation in the talks after Trump withdrew from the U.N. climate treaty this year.
With the United States, the world’s richest nation, and its financial muscle absent from the talks, countries could not reach a deal to increase funding commitments. With the European Union also tightening its belt and weaking its climate policies, developing nations failed to secure an agreement to triple adaptation financing to $120 billion by 2035. China, which sees itself as a developing nation despite being the world’s second-largest economy, has not filled the financial void left by the U.S.
Saudi Arabia and other major oil and gas producers pushed back hardest against having any fossil fuel language, and a slimmed-down draft published Thursday was stripped of all references to ending their use following its objections.
Petro-states argued that individual countries should decide for themselves how to meet their energy needs, and they pushed heavily for carbon-capture technologies instead of a collective commitment to phase out.
As talks ran into overtime, a coalition led by France and Panama was fighting to restore the language on fossil fuels.
But Russia also opposed a faster move away from hydrocarbons. Ruslan Edelgeriyev, the country’s climate envoy, told reporters last week that with the energy market already under “excessive pressure” from “the well-known strait [issue] and other factors,” a reference to the U.S. blockade of the Strait of Hormuz during its war with Iran, he said talk of such a phase-out is “absolutely inappropriate, because it will additionally affect the price.”
Edelgeriyev’s remarks at this year’s gathering in Turkey are in line with the campaign Russia has pursued at recent summits, often with success. At COP28 in Dubai, countries led by Russia, the world’s second-biggest gas producer, won a paragraph recognizing that “transitional fuels” can play a role in the energy transition. At COP30 in Brazil, Russia and Saudi Arabia opposed creating a process or timetable to move away from fossil fuels, and the final agreement did not mention fossil fuels at all.
The most recent draft proposed increasing electrification of the global economy to 35 percent by 2035. Unlike Thursday’s version, however, Sunday’s text removed explicit references to tripling global renewable-energy capacity and doubling the rate of energy-efficiency improvements by 2030. Instead, it called more broadly for efforts to “increase clean energy”, improve energy efficiency and deploy other low-emission technologies.
That shift left the commitment less specific about how countries should achieve the target. The draft did not require the additional electricity to come from renewable sources such as wind and solar, leaving the door open to electrification powered by coal and natural gas.
But it no longer makes sense to judge the summit’s success based solely on the outcome of talks, said Sue Biniaz, former deputy climate envoy under President Joe Biden. The governments and companies that come to the conference to announce actions on climate change are increasingly the focus.
“Now, particularly with the U.S. out, the action side is compensating for what is lacking on the consensus side,” Biniaz said.
For example, the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank agreed to provide a record $1.6 billion to host country Turkey to pursue climate policies.
More than 150 countries, 37 cities and 250 businesses worldwide announced a package of actions they are taking voluntarily to boost electrification rates, amounting to billions of dollars in investments.
“What we are seeing is a pivot to implementation,” said Nat Keohane, president of the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, an environmental nonprofit. “The COP has an important role, but it’s far less about the details of the text than about how the multilateral framework can drive change on the ground.”
The lack of an adopted agreement at COP31 leaves the focus on whether countries and businesses can translate these voluntary announcements into concrete action, particularly as the world falls further behind on its climate targets.
Next year’s summit is set to be held in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, with expectations of another low-key year, probably without the United States present.
Chinese delegates told negotiators at the summit that their country would not seek to host the 2028 climate summit, a critical moment for setting the next set of climate goals. That conference will be held somewhere in Asia, with no countries expressing formal interest so far, and will take place just after the next U.S. presidential election.
No comments:
Post a Comment