Friday, January 26, 2018

Retaliatory Code Complaint Against St. Augustine Beach Commissioner Maggie Kostka

Blatant case of retaliation by City Manager BRUCE MAX ROYLE against Commissioner Maggie Kostka's calling for a national search for a new City Manager, and standing up for women's rights, after ROYLE's non-investigation of alleged sexual harassment by triple-dipping Building Official GARY LARSON. Despicable.

I've asked ROYLE to name the alleged complainant. No response. Badge of fraud and retaliation -- claim of "multiple complaints," and it looks like the only complainer was paranoid MAX ROYLE, who rightly fears firing for incompetence. Listen to the malarkey he told the Record: According to Royle, he didn’t make the complaint but forwarded a complaint about flutter signs in front of Obi’s Fillin’ Station on A1A Beach Boulevard from a person who did not want to be named — that person and others don’t like to be named “given the viciousness (sic) of the personal (sic) attacks going on these days,” according to Royle. Royle didn’t name the person on Thursday."

1. I've asked St. Augustine Beach Police Chief Robert Hardwick for a copy of the .wav file reflecting the St. Augustine Beach City Attorney and City Clerk telephone request for police presence at the meeting.
2. This police call was blatant retaliation for several of us exercising our First, Ninth and Fourteenth Amendment protected activity rights in questioning City Attorney James Patrick Wilson's unctuous, unconstitutional ukase that public comment was forbidden, also a violation of F.S. 286. Jim Wilson was heard saying that people who wanted public comment should be ejected from the meeting.
3. Wilson's officiousness and effrontery is an embarrassment to the people of St. Augustine Beach.
4. Jim's petulance reminds me of the time when Barbara Bosanko (wife of former St. Johns County Attorney Daniel Bosanko, was chair of the Anastasia Mosquito Control Commission of St. Johns County (AMCD).
5. AMCD Chair Barbara Bosanko said in 2007, "I'm calling the cops," when former Army Captain Don Girvan was at the podium, questioning the illegal $1.8 million no-bid helicopter purchase of a luxury Textron Bell Jet helicopter that was incapable of killing a single skeeter.
6. AMCD Chair Bosanko and AMCD Commissioner Linda Wampler were caught red-handed, violating Sunshine after the meeting, with their lawbreaking recorded on videotape. A Daytona Beach law firm resigned as AMCD's outside counsel because one of its lawyers was heard talking about "security" with two Commissioners, violating Sunshine. Lawbreaking AMCD Chair Bosanko and board member Wampler were NEVER prosecuted.
7. On the illegal helicopter purchase, "We the People" were "warned" by AMCD Chair Bosanko, but "nevertheless [we] persisted." (In the words of Mitch McConnell re: Senator Elizabeth Warren.)
8. We got the illegal helicopter contract cancelled. We won a full refund of our deposit. We're not taking "no" for an answer.
9. Likewise, release of the exact spoken words of whatever was said to the police in requesting officers attend the usually dull Code Enforcement Board meeting is in the public interest.
10. We have a Right to Know. Now. Still waiting for the .wav file.


Signs again cause a stir in St. Augustine Beach
By Sheldon Gardner
St. Augustine Record
Posted at 12:01 AM
Updated at 8:14 AM

A decision to enforce a portion of the city of St. Augustine Beach’s sign code that should have already been changed created confusion at Wednesday’s code enforcement board hearing, which focused in part on a city commissioner’s business.
The city’s code enforcement officer found Commissioner Maggie Kostka’s business, Cone Head’s Ice Cream on A1A Beach Boulevard, in violation of City Code because Kostka had used the prohibited flutter signs on the business property.
But Kostka, who had the signs taken down before the hearing and was no longer in violation of code, said her time had been wasted by the issue since commissioners had already supported changing that section of the code to allow the signs. The problem was, the change was never completed even though it had been planned to be done in 2017.
“This issue has taken my time, energy and resources to address, and the reality is it’s a non-issue,” she said, later offering criticism of the city manager.
City Attorney Jim Wilson said the City Commission changed the sign code “in a gigantic hurry” because of a lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court that claimed the city’s sign regulations were unconstitutional. Part of clearing up the suit involved adopting a revised sign code quickly, he said.
But commissioners found multiple issues with the existing code and planned to revise it; during one discussion they agreed to allow up to two signs or banners on commercial parcels like Kostka had, Wilson said. Kostka had her signs up thinking she was complying with the commission’s will, he said.
“Sometimes haste makes waste, and there were some things done there that were unlike what other code, former codes had and things that caused some consternation among the commissioners,” Wilson said.
Wilson said he took the blame for having not provided new code updates yet, “but there’s a bunch of other issues involved.” He also said he doesn’t think the code enforcement board should enforce City Code if someone has two flutter signs or less. He suggested delaying the case until the commission could change the ordinance, and if that happened the case could be dropped.

But code board members disagreed, with Chair Ernesto Torres saying it was the job of the board to enforce what’s on the books.
“My problem is that if we’re going to say, ‘Hey, we’re going to allow businesses to have two signs per storefront that’s on A1A,’ next thing in a weekend or two from now we’re going to have nothing but signs,” Torres said.
Kostka’s concerns extended to City Manager Max Royle. While a notice of violation she received about her business cited multiple complaints, she requested those complaints and only found one — from Royle.
According to Royle, he didn’t make the complaint but forwarded a complaint about flutter signs in front of Obi’s Fillin’ Station on A1A Beach Boulevard from a person who did not want to be named — that person and others don’t like to be named “given the viciousness of the personal attacks going on these days,” according to Royle. Royle didn’t name the person on Thursday.
After the complaint came in, Royle told the code enforcement officer about it, and he asked the officer to check other businesses to see if there were any violations of the sign code to be fair, he said.
″[Kostka] has not been singled out,” Royle said.
Royle said whether the flutter signs will be allowed in the future is something commissioners will have to decide, and there are other issues that need to be addressed with the current code such such as how to handle political signs.

Signs are not allowed on public right-of-way if they’re stuck in the ground, but people can carry a sign or put it on a vehicle or do similar things, and the issue needs to be clarified. The City Code used to reference political signs but part of the code update put in place a blanket ban on signs on City Hall property because regulating the content of signs would be unconstitutional.
Board members voted unanimously Wednesday that there was no longer a violation on Kostka’s property. They also voted the same in the following hearing for the prohibited signs in front of Obi’s because those signs had also been taken down.
City Planning and Building Director Brian Law said he plans to work with Wilson to bring a proposed revision to the sign code to the February City Commission meeting to allow up to two flutter signs per business.






  • Edward Adelbert Slavin
  •  
  • Rank 0
1. City Manager Max Royle should resign or be fired.
2. His lack of candor on alleged "multiple complaints" is a badge of fraud and retaliation.
3. Royle and his henchmen retaliated against reform Commissioner Maggie Kostka.
4. Commissioner Kostka spoke out about Royle's lax response to alleged sexual harassment by disgraced triple-dipping Building Official Gary Larson, who was the Building Official for St. Augustine Beach and two other towns.
5. Commissioner Kostka spoke out about the need for a national search to select the next City Manager.
6. Royle retaliated with his complaint about flutter signs.
7. This same itty-bitty City allowed the colossally ugly Embassy Suites and Salt Life Food Shack to be built without enough parking..
8. On June 7, St. Augustine Beach Commissioners had a special meeting on sign ordinance and minutes reflect a consensus to allow no more than twi flutter signs per business, among other changes. The changes were supposed to be brought back for first and second ordinance readings at the July and August meetings. That never happened. Royle dropped the ball, as did City Attorney James Patrick Wilson..
9. Chairman Torres apologized to Commissioner Kostka for his interrupting her presentation, which violated her Due Process rights. This was in response to my public comment at the end of the meeting, calling out Torres for sexism and misogyny.
10. At the behest of City Attorney, Torres ignored public comment cards during the discussion of this selective enforcement outrage. Wilson called the police. In Board member comments, board member Trish Gilpin agreed with me about public comment, saying it has always been allowed, although residents rarely come to board meetings. Wilson owes an apology for his noisy, noisome intimidation tactics.« less
  • 12 minutes ago
Tom Reynolds
  • Tom Reynolds
  •  
  • Rank 0
The first agenda item involved a City Beach Commissioner and it was very clear from the start there was no legitimate complaint or violation of any kind to warrant a hearing or even a citation. It was the City Manager, Bruce Max Royle, and City Commissioner Richard O'Brien FABRICATED CODE COMPLAINT!

Now the City Contracted Attorney Coquina Law Group s Jim Wilson had a SUPER SERIOUS MELTDOWN BEFORE THE MEETING EVEN STARTED! That was very SCARY for a FEW MOMENTS! I really did think Jim Wilson was going to attack a Mr. Ed Slavin. I HAVE NEVER SEEN SUCH RAGE IN A CITY GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS FACE AS I DID IN JIM WILSON, PLUS HIS LOUD VOICE TONE WAS HEARD IN THE ENTIRE LARGE ROOM. THE POLICE HAD TO BE CALLED IN THE MEETING ROOM by A CITY EMPLOYEE NAMED BONNIE. BY THE TIME Lt. Commander Thomas ASHLOCK HAD ARRIVED, Mr. WISON HAD CALMED DOWN. I SEEN NO REASON TO MAKE A FORMAL COMPLAINT AT THE TIME. I SUSPECT JIM WILSON TO BE HUNG OVER or ON MEDS or MAYBE JUST VERY ANGRY BECAUSE OF WHAT CITY MANAGER BRUCE MAX ROYLE and CITY COMMISSIONER RICH O'BRIEN HAD CREATED. YES ... I SUSPECT THIS RETALIATION/WRONGLY WRITTEN FABRICATED COMPLAINT WAS BECAUSE of COMMISSIONER MAGGIE KOSTKA BEATING ANDREA "ANGRY" SAMUELS. SHE WAS ALWAYS IN COLLUSION WITH RICH O'BRIEN TO KEEP GIVING AWAY and USING THE CITY FOR THEIR OWN PERSONAL USES and THIER FRIENDS OWN PERSONAL USES. PLUS ... COMMISSIONER MAGGIE KOSTKA CALLED FOR A NATIONAL SEARCH FOR A NEW CITY MANAGER. OF COURSE, THAT IS A BIG FEAR OF RICH O'Brien s TO HAVE SOMEONE NEW AS A CITY MANAGER. BAD folks ALWAYS GET NERVOUS WHEN " SOMEBODY NEW COMES AROUND!« less


REALTIME
Edward Adelbert Slavin
  • Edward Adelbert Slavin
  •  
  • Rank 0
1. Twenty minutes before the meeting, City Manager Bruce Max Royle was seen bicycling away from St. Augustine Beach City Hall, which has some of the elements of a crime scene.  
2. Thus, Royle was not present at the Code Enforcement Board meeting to answer questions or defend his actions.  
3. Paperwork reflects Royle and henchman Gary Larson filed the complaint.  
4. To hide his tracks, did he Royle to the St. Augustine Record?  
5. Article states, “According to Royle, he didn’t make the complaint but forwarded a complaint about flutter signs in front of Obi’s Fillin’ Station on A1A Beach Boulevard from a person who did not want to be named — that person and others don’t like to be named ‘given the viciousness of the personal attacks going on these days,’ according to Royle. Royle didn’t name the person on Thursday.” Royle is a serial recidivist prevaricator. He should resign or be fired. 
6. As they say in Latin, “De minims non curat lex.” (“The law does not deal with trifles.”) 
7. “Nothing great was ever accomplished by being small.” Royle is a vicious, small-time bully. Time for him to go.« less
  • 1 hour ago (edited)
Edward Adelbert Slavin
  • Edward Adelbert Slavin
  •  
  • Rank 0
@Edward Adelbert Slavin  
1. To cover his tracks, did City Manager Bruce Max Royle lie to The St. Augustine Record about the etiology of the “complaint(s)?”  
2. What gives Royle the right to withhold the name of the alleged “complainant(s)?”  
3. There are none -- just him, right? 
4. I’ve asked Royle for a response. Still waiting.
  • 1 hour ago (edited recently)
Ed Hutchins
  • Ed Hutchins
  •  
  • Rank 0
Those small, stick in the ground signs should be illegal if they’re not, the article was unclear. You can count dozens of them between Winn-Dixie and Amici’s on A1A. Unsightly.
  • 6 hours ago
sheldonrgardner
  • sheldonrgardner
  •  
  • Rank 0
@Ed Hutchins Hi Ed, here’s a link to the code enforcement meeting packet. It includes photos of what a flutter sign looks like and a page that shows what signs are prohibited in St. Augustine Beach. Sorry for the confusion. http://www.staugbch.com/sites/default/files/fileattachments/code_enforcement_board/meeting/packets/37621/january_24_2018_code_enforcement_book.pdf
  • 5 hours ago
Edward Adelbert Slavin
  • Edward Adelbert Slavin
  •  
  • Rank 0
@Ed Hutchins Agreed, but these were not small stick in the ground signs. Flutter flags. Not signs.
  • 1 hour ago

Beach Commissioner faces Municipal Code Enforcement Board
January 25, 2018
Historic City News

Historic City News was informed that St Augustine Beach Commissioner Maggie Koskta was summoned to appear before the Municipal Code Enforcement Board of the City of St. Augustine Beach on Wednesday, January 24, 2018, at 2:00 p.m. in the City Commission Meeting Room at City Hall, 2200 State Road A1A South, St. Augustine Beach.

Genesis Property & Management Group LLC, was issued a citation pertaining to a notice of violation of St. Augustine Beach Code Section 8.00.03, prohibiting flutter signs like the ones installed at Cone Heads Ice Cream, 570 A1A Beach Boulevard.

“I performed a site inspection of your property on 11/01/2017 relative to multiple complaint(s) and noted a continuing condition that required your immediate attention,” Code Enforcement officer Bill Ward wrote in a letter submitted to the Board. “During that inspection, and in a follow-up visit, I interviewed a manager-on-duty and explained the need to remove the referenced signs that are prohibited as outlined in the SAB City Code Sec. 8.00.03.”
Commissioner Kostka, the owner of the business, provided local reporters with a copy of her position on the charges, asking that they be dropped.

I started my business in Feb of 2008 and moved it to St. Augustine Beach in 2012 after purchasing the property where my business is currently located at 570 A1A Beach Blvd.

I was Granted a Certificate of occupancy, Feb, 2012 and
Opened for business March 3, 2012.

My business has been continuously using flags since 2013 with no notice of violation to code.

I would like to draw your attention to several facts pertaining the issue of the sign ordinance.

Originally the change to the sign code was forced to occur due to a lawsuit brought against the city in April 2016 pertaining to the old sign code. The previous sign code was found to be in violation of the 1st and 9th amendments and only after the lawsuit, was our code forced to be changed. A document was then hastily drafted by a legal firm hired by the city to meet the terms of the lawsuit. In reality it was the same sign code the legal firm drafted for a Jacksonville City. The document was plagued with errors, inconsistencies and redundancies. I have stated on numerous occasions I don’t believe this particular document to be a good fit for our community for a number of reasons, but… none the less, it was adopted in June to cover exposure brought by the pending lawsuit at the time, with the understanding the errors would be addressed and resolved. The code was posted on the city webpage in April, 2016.

From sometime in April 2016 through November, 2016 this sign was posted at City Hall that only added to the confusion. (Exhibit A)

Discussion, workshops and special meetings were conducted in an effort to resolve the issues within the new code by the Commission culminating with a special meeting on June 7, 2017 (more than a year since the first draft). This was a very important meeting. I would like to point out that both the city manager, Max Royal and the previous building official, Gary Larson were present and participated in this meeting, along with the full Commission.

Please allow me to share some important facts concerning that meeting.

1. Exhibit B shows the Agenda for that meeting had planned for discussion to allow certain types of signs.

• At every Commission meeting, it is common for the city manager to make recommendations to the board concerning agenda items. This meeting was no different. As a matter of fact, the city manager recommended allowing banner or flag signs as shown in Exhibit C. On Page H the recommendations given to the commission by city manager, Bruce Royale state, “ To allow Flutter/flag signs, To allow portable signs, To delete section 8.00.04 concerning umbrella signs.

• During the meeting, Gary Larson and Max Royal spoke supporting these types of signs: Exhibit D; Page 4 of the meeting minutes show Building Official Larson advised flutter signs could be taken in at night and put out in the morning (paragraph 7) and also commented the Avenue of Palms project was taking away visibility of business owners’ signs.

• After much discussion by the commission and public comment, it was the consensus of the commission to allow 2 temporary signs per business, including flutter signs. Exhibit E; On page 8, the minutes clearly state it was the consensus of the Commission to allow…flutter signs, sandwich boards during the day and a total of 2 temporary signs per business.

2. It was also Commission Consensus to bring the ordinance back for 1st reading at the July, 2017 meeting and 2nd reading at the August 2017 meeting. Exhibit F. City Attorney Jim Wilson advised he could amend the sign ordinance in several different ordinances and discussion ensued further (on page 9) regarding bringing the ordinance back for the 1st reading in July and the second reading in August.

3. It was never put on the agendas for those meetings as Exhibit G shows the agendas for those dates. As a notation, it is the city manager who creates the agendas for Commission meetings.

I would like to address the 2 certified letters I received pertaining to this alleged violation…RE: Notice of Violation to City Code regarding signs Exhibit H. The letters state a site inspection of my property was conducted on 11/1/17 relative to multiple complaints and states my manager was interviewed.

1. Upon investigating this issue, I did NOT find security footage of Mr. Ward inside of my business on 11/1/17, I did note him on footage Wednesday, November 15th, validated by Mr. Ward and Mr. Larson’s email exchange. Exhibit I

2. Upon requesting copies of the multiple complaints that were referred to in the letter, I received only one, made from the city manager, Max Royale. Exhibit J.

In December I then received a citation to appear, even though my business was closed from Nov. 28-December 26th for regularly scheduled maintenance and cleaning and flags were not put out. Exhibit K

The most troubling part of this situation is that the people who knew the changes in the code and were responsible for the final drafting of the code are the very same individuals who brought these allegations against me and my business.

These inconsistencies and incompetence does not encourage community wellbeing. This issue has taken my time, energy and resources to address and the reality is that it is a non-issue as shown here today.

Thank you for your time and service. I certainly hope that your board can be better directed in the future.

Saturday, January 06, 2018

St. Augustine Beach Commissioners Vote 3-2 to Curb Your Free Speech Rights

Tired of criticism of government officials, St. Augustine Beach Vice Mayor MARGARET ENGLAND, newly appointed Commissioner DONALD SAMORA and disgraced ex-Mayor RICHARD BURTT O'BRIEN voted  Saturday January 6, 2018 to limit public comment on agenda items to two minutes.

Their action was in response to newly-appointed Commissioner DONALD SAMORA's attack at his very first meeting last year.  SAMORA was supported for the gig by St. Augustine Vice Mayor TODD DAVID NEVILLE a/k/a "ODD TODD.".

Dissenting were new Mayor Undine Pawlowski George and Commissioner Maggie Kostka.

Commissioners had no factual or legal research -- it was a bare naked violation of First and Ninth Amendment rights.  Every single public comment speaker was against it.

Who benefits? (Cui Bono?

Developers.

Vendors.

Corrupters.

Lobbyists.

Enemies of free speech.

SAMORA must run for office this year if he wants to retain his seat.

Vice Chair MARGARET ENGLAND must run for re-eletion if she wants to retain her seat.

Mayor George must run for re-election if she wants to retain her seat.

The line of candidates opposed to SAMORA and ENGLAND has already formed.

Rosetta Bailey has filed to run against SAMORA (she filed for the seat last year, after Commissioner Sherman Gary Snodgrass told me he would  not run for re-election, and before he resigned.)

ROSETTA BAILEY is running against authoritarian Commissioner DONALD SAMORA

Here's the contact information for St. Augustine Beach Commissioners:



Commission

Portrait of Commissioner Rich O'Brien.Rich O'Brienex-Mayor/Commissioner(904) 814-2080comrobrien@cityofsab.org
Portrait of Commissioner Undine GeorgeUndine GeorgeMayor/Commissioner(904) 687-1492comugeorge@cityofsab.org
Commissioner Don SamoraDon SamoraCommissioner(904) 460-4404comdsamora@cityofsab.org
Portrait of Commissioner Maggie KostkaMaggie KostkaCommissioner(904) 669-5132commkostka@cityofsab.org
Portrait of Commissioner Margaret EnglandMargaret EnglandVice Mayor/ Commissioner(904) 461-3454commengland@cityofsab.org

Sheriff SHOAR's overt acts of retaliation against FDLE agent are unrebutted: NY Times reporter Walt Bogdanich




In response to reporter Jake Martin's December 31, 2017, New York Times reporter Walt Bogdanich wrote the St. Augustine Record, noting that NONE of the facts in Walter Botdanich's articles have ever been challenged or rebutted by Sheriff DAVID SHOAR.  NO retraction was corrected.  SHOAR lives in an  emotional, fact-free zone;


NYT Reporter: Shoar hasn’t asked for retraction

Editor: I noticed that in your paper’s recent list of the most important stories of 2017 (http://bit.ly/2CcytmY), you included my article documenting Sheriff Shoar’s attempt to discredit a state law enforcement officer who had found serious shortcomings with the sheriff’s investigation of the Michelle O’Connell shooting. Sheriff Shoar was understandably not pleased with my report, and you said as much. What you did not say is that the sheriff has never once sought a retraction or cited any errors of fact in the thousands of words I have written about the case.
Readers who may have missed my article, which was based on thousands of pages of previously undisclosed public records and dozens of interviews, can find it at: http://nyti.ms/2lG7Ctg.
Walt Bogdanich
Investigative reporter,
The New York Times
































Monday, January 01, 2018

Sheriff DAVID SHOAR's obstruction of justice -- obvious and ongoing -- is featured in Record's year-end review article




Controversial St. Johns County SHERIFF DAVID BERNARD SHOAR continues to duck questions about obstruction of justice.
(NY Times photo)

SHOAR, who legally changed his name from "HOAR" in 1994, faced increased scrutiny 2013-2017 over the September 2, 2010 Michelle O'Connell homicide.

Will SHOAR/HOAR leave office in 2018? 


Good year-end article by St. Augustine Record reporter Jake Martin, including 351 words about Sheriff DAVID SHOAR's campaign of intimidation and harassment against FDLE Special Agent Rusty Rodgers.  (Except for line about how SHOAR "didn't have a voice" in article -- SHOAR repeatedly refused New York Times interview requests, 2013-2017.)

Any residual respect for Sheriff David Shoar rapidly dissipated in response to the June 2017 New York Times article about Sheriff Shoar's efforts to prosecute and fire FDLE Special Agent Rusty Ray Rodgers for doing his job "too well" on the Michelle O'Connell shooting investigation.

Sheriff Shoar refuses to be interviewed by internationally respected reporters with critical thinking skills, on the record, including The New York Times, PBS Frontline and three-time Pulitzer Prize winner Walt Bogdanich.

Sheriff Shoar's rodomontade, like that of President Donald Trump, masks deep-seated inadequacies, insecurities and potential criminal liability.

Sheriff Shoar obstructed justice, 2010-2017, and has no defense.

Sheriff Shoar's former associates are distancing themselves.

Sheriff Shoar is rarely seen in public any longer.

Sheriff Shoar may resign and be replaced by a Governor Rick Scott appointee.

Thanks to the Times' work, St. Johns County residents now know that government corruption in this one-party Republican oligarchy (the wealthiest per capita income county in Florida), extends to local lawmen covering up a homicide in a deputy's home with the deputy's service weapon, calling it a "suicide" without scientific support, then mounting a four-year campaign of intimidation and harassment directed against the special agent who Shoar selected to do an investigation of Deputy Jeremy Banks.

We now know that Sheriff Shoar has no moral compass. Sheriff Shoar spent hundreds of hours and thousands of dollars in his obstruction of justice scheme, trying to ruin the career of a decorated FDLE investigator.

Until the Time's article, Sheriff Shoar did this with impunity and apparent immunity, as a result of Shoar's relationships with Governor Rick Scott and other members of Shoar's party.

Enough. We look forward to the FBI and U.S. Attorney doing their job in 2018, bringing the Michelle O'Connell and Rusty Rodgers cases to a federal grand jury. Enough corruption in St. Johns County.





Posted December 31, 2017 06:10 am - Updated December 31, 2017 09:34 am
By JAKE MARTIN jake.martin@staugustine.com
YEAR IN REVIEW: 2017 brings Irma, Confederate monuments debate, vagrancy concerns and more


Another year, another storm.

For what seemed like an eternity but what was actually only a week or so in early September, the entire state of Florida watched Hurricane Irma pick up steam in the Atlantic, then in the Caribbean, as it made its way toward the vulnerable peninsula.

Just days before the storm struck, no one could be sure which side of the state it would even make landfall.

Although Hurricane Irma had significantly weakened by the time she made it to St. Johns County, after slamming into the Keys as a Category 4 storm, her track, size and interaction with a nor’easter here meant she still packed a powerful punch. Uncalled for, really.

The hurricane passed much of Northeast Florida to the west, exposing the region to the dangerous northeast quadrant that national meteorologists had been circling and drawing arrows toward all weekend.

Apart from the strong winds and rains of these outer bands, their collisions with the separate storm system coming in from the Atlantic resulted in a number of tornadoes, one of which ripped entire walls and roofs off condos at the Summerhouse Beach & Racquet Club and nearby homes in Crescent Beach.

Swollen creeks and rivers plus heavy rains equaled flooding for many residents along those waterways, especially in Hastings and Flagler Estates.

Many residents in Davis Shores who were just getting back to normal after Hurricane Matthew in October 2016 soon found themselves ripping out baseboards, sweeping muck out of their homes and doing all the other things they didn’t care to relive.

In Vilano Beach and points north, Irma stirred up violent seas that once again undermined a number of homes built along the beach. A fallen house in Vilano Beach — just barely holding on to a tiny piece of sand dune that kept it from tumbling into the ocean — became the defining image for much of the country of Irma’s effects, at least in this corner of the state.

Recovery from Irma, and even from Matthew, continues.

The county is seeking reimbursement for a number of hurricane recovery efforts related to both storms from the Federal Emergency Management Agency through its Public Assistance program. Officials say it will be a years-long process.

In the meantime, it’s a good bet fingers are crossed from the banks of the St. Johns River to what’s left of the Atlantic coastline that next hurricane season will be a little kinder.

Monuments debate

Like other cities throughout the South this year, St. Augustine saw a debate over the future of its Confederate monuments simmer and boil over numerous times.

City Manager John Regan in October asked commissioners to keep one such monument in the Plaza de la Constitucion, but to also add context (to be determined by a committee of citizens). His recommendation came after an August meeting where public comment lasted hours as residents shared their opinions on the monument.

Some said it symbolizes racism, hatred and slavery and should be moved. Others said it’s a memorial to local men who died that should be kept alongside other war memorials as well as tributes to other causes in that same plaza.

The monument was built by the Ladies Memorial Association in the 1870s. A marble plaque on the west face of the monument reads, simply, “Our Dead.” Other marble tablets contain names of the dead and eulogies.

Another monument, to Confederate Gen. William Loring’s service in the Civil War and other conflicts, is in another area of the plaza that is not under city control but under the University of Florida’s.

That monument was installed in 1920 by the Daughters of the Confederacy and bears relief carvings of both the Confederate flag and the American flag. It also refers to Loring as a “distinguished American soldier” whose ability was recognized by three governments. Loring’s ashes are buried on the site, although they’ve been buried elsewhere before, including in New York City, where he died in 1886.

UF officials have said it won’t be until at least spring that they decide what, if anything, to do about the monument.

Ahead of the lighting ceremony in November to kick off the Nights of Lights, the Rev. Ron Rawls of St. Paul AME Church and hundreds of fellow protesters, black and white, marched on the Plaza chanting “Take them down.” But their chants were countered with chants from some in the crowd of “No one cares,” as well as chants from St. Augustine Tea Party members and Three Percenters of “Leave them up.”

Most people, waiting out the unrest on their blankets or in their fold-out chairs with their kids, seemed to want no part of it.

City tackles vagrancy

Residents and business owners this year put the pressure on officials to crack down on panhandling and vagrancy in the downtown area as the city continues to face challenges addressing its homeless population.

“It’s getting worse. It’s not getting better,” Regan said in October. “It’s not lost on the city.”

A Facebook group called the St. Augustine Vagrant Watch Group began documenting instances of local panhandling and vagrancy, with the stated goal being to motivate elected leaders and law enforcement to take action. Officials said they would prefer such documentation be shared directly with them, along with descriptions of what was witnessed and how it affected their experience or their business.

Since 2016, the city has not enforced anti-panhandling laws because of a U.S. District Court decision in Tampa that questioned their constitutionality. Rules against aggressive panhandling still can be enforced, however.

The city is currently considering a rewrite of its panhandling laws. In the meantime, the police department has ramped up its presence in the St. George Street area.

Sheriff back in spotlight

A front-page story published in a Sunday edition of The New York Times in June once again put the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office, and its handling of the Michelle O’Connell death investigation, on a national stage.

The story this time around was not about what did or did not happen in a bedroom in the home of deputy Jeremy Banks, where, on Sept. 2, 2010, his girlfriend, the 24-year-old O’Connell, was found dead of a gunshot wound. Instead, in a five-page story just short of 7,000 words, three-time Pulitzer Prize winning investigative journalist Walt Bogdanich focused on what he portrayed as a disinformation campaign waged by Sheriff David Shoar to cast doubt on the Florida Department of Law Enforcement’s investigation of the case.

At the center of the story was FDLE agent Rusty Rodgers, who was assigned to the case after O’Connell’s family raised concerns about the original investigation, conducted by the Sheriff’s Office, that ultimately concluded the death was a suicide.

Shoar didn’t have a voice in the Times’ story and told The Record the day after he hadn’t read it. He called Bogdanich “one of the most dishonest men I’ve met in my life” and claimed that he refused to look at anything “that had to do with the culpability of Rodgers.”

Shoar maintained that Rodgers manufactured and exaggerated evidence during his investigation (claims that are at least partially substantiated by FDLE’s own internal review of Rodger’s conduct in the case) and that he came to the case with the assumption that Banks was guilty of homicide. He came to view Bogdanich’s stories in a similar light.

“Bogdanich, the day he showed up here, already had his stories written and his mind made up on everything,” Shoar said. “The guy’s a narcissist, he’s full of himself, and when he came down here I didn’t kiss his ass.”

If you can stomach a pot of coffee and have a morning to spare, go to http://nyti.ms/2rONQfi to read an online version of the Times’ story, “A Mother’s Death, a Botched Inquiry and a Sheriff at War.”


Hastings dissolution

In November, the people of the Town of Hastings spoke.

Residents there voted overwhelmingly to dismantle their town government and revoke its charter. More than 82 percent of votes, 136, were in favor, while 29 people cast votes against the proposal, according to the St. Johns County Supervisor of Elections.

“I’m OK with it. … I kind of pictured it rolling this way,” Mayor Tom Ward said after the results came in.

The vote came about a year after town commissioners voted to study what dissolution would look like, which was a direct result of residents expressing concerns about water rates and the financial stability and viability of the town.

St. Johns County will take over operations and assume the town’s assets and liabilities by the end of February.

Bathroom policy challenged

In June, Drew Adams, a junior at Allen D. Nease High School, filed a lawsuit against the St. Johns County School District over what he sees as discrimination in being denied access to the male restrooms.

Adams was entering his freshman year at Nease when he let school administrators know that though he was born a girl, he was transgender. Transitioning meant having surgery, taking hormones, using male pronouns and availing himself of the boys bathroom.

For a few weeks, things went fine. But then the school district informed him he was not allowed to use the boys bathroom and told him to use the girls bathroom or a gender-neutral one instead.

The school district’s bathroom policies, which require students use the bathroom of their biological sex, aren’t written anywhere. The only written guidelines don’t explicitly ban students from using the bathroom of their gender identities.

Adams’ lawsuit against the school district comes down to one question: By refusing to let the transgender teen use the boys bathroom, did the district violate his rights? The case has made it all the way to the federal court.

A three-day, non-jury trial began Dec. 11 at the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida in Jacksonville, with Judge Timothy J. Corrigan presiding.

As Corrigan has said: “What this case is about — what it’s only about is — notwithstanding whatever well-intentioned motives the district has, does the district’s policy nevertheless violate Title IX (education laws) or does it violate the Equal Protection Clause of the United States Constitution?”

Corrigan will tour Nease High School for himself in January; both sides will then file a document summarizing the law, the facts and their positions; oral arguments will be heard in February; and then Corrigan will issue an order. He has said he wants to make a ruling before Drew starts his senior year next fall.

favorite son dies

April saw the passing of historian Michael Gannon, 89, in Gainesville. Gannon was celebrated locally for his role in keeping St. Augustine in the national spotlight as the United States of America’s oldest continually-occupied European settlement.

He was so protective of St. Augustine’s 1565 founding that he often provoked the residents of Jamestown, Virginia, and Plymouth, Massachusetts, with his now famous quote: “By the time Jamestown was founded in 1607 and Plymouth in 1620, St. Augustine was up for urban renewal.”

Among his lasting visible accomplishments in the city was the construction and oversight of the 208-foot Great Cross at Mission Nombre de Dios to celebrate the city’s 400th anniversary in 1965.



2 Comments
Alexander Shiraz · 

It’s shocking the Record doesn’t mention the record breaking protest held in solidarity with the DC Women’s March on January 21, 2017. How could you possibly miss that?
LikeReply14h
Edward Adelbert Slavin · 

This was a local year-end story.
LikeReply26m
Edward Adelbert Slavin · 

Any residual respect for Sheriff David Shoar rapidly dissipated in response to the June 2017 New York Times article about Sheriff Shoar's efforts to prosecute and fire FDLE Special Agent Rusty Ray Rodgers for doing his job "too well" on the Michelle O'Connell shooting investigation.

Sheriff Shoar refuses to be interviewed by internationally respected reporters with critical thinking skills, on the record, including The New York Times, PBS Frontline and three-time Pulitzer Prize winner Walt Bogdanich.

Sheriff Shoar's rodomontade, like that of President Donald Trump, masks deep-seated inadequacies, insecurities and potential criminal liability.

Sheriff Shoar obstructed justice, 2010-2017, and has no defense.

Sheriff Shoar's former associates are distancing themselves.

Sheriff Shoar is rarely seen in public any longer.

Sheriff Shoar may resign and be replaced by a Governor Rick Scott appointee.

Thanks to the Times' work, St. Johns County residents now know that government corruption in this one-party Republican oligarchy (the wealthiest per capita income county in Florida), extends to local lawmen covering up a homicide in a deputy's home with the deputy's service weapon, calling it a "suicide" without scientific support, then mounting a four-year campaign of intimidation and harassment directed against the special agent who Shoar selected to do an investigation of Deputy Jeremy Banks.

We now know that Sheriff Shoar has no moral compass. Sheriff Shoar spent hundreds of hours and thousands of dollars in his obstruction of justice scheme, trying to ruin the career of a decorated FDLE investigator.

Until the Time's article, Sheriff Shoar did this with impunity and apparent immunity, as a result of Shoar's relationships with Governor Rick Scott and other members of Shoar's party.

Enough. We look forward to the FBI and U.S. Attorney doing their job in 2018, bringing the Michelle O'Connell and Rusty Rodgers cases to a federal grand jury. Enough corruption in St. Johns County.