Thursday, June 09, 2016

BURCHFIELD PERJURY DOCUMENTS OFF-LIMITS?

Update 11:57 AM:  All documents have now been released. 



June 9, letter to St. Johns County Clerk of Courts and Comptroller HUNTER CONRAD:

Dear Mr. Conrad:
1. Every single document -- some 80 of them -- in Dr. Dwight Hines, Ph.D.  v. Timothy Burchfield, William B. Harriss, City of St. Augustine, et al., CA06-0319 is currently off-limits on the Clerk's computer system.  Why?   (See below).  
2. This is the epic case where a possibly penurious affidavit was filed by Mr. Timothy Burchfield, then and now the Assistant City Manager, falsely claiming there were "no documents" responsive to Dr. Hines' request -- in 2007, represented by SIDENY FRANKLYN ANSBACHER, our City of St. Augustine belatedly produced some 45 pounds of paper documents, plus electronic records.
3. This case arose out of the City of St. Augustine dumping a landfill in a lake.  The City refused to provide documents.  The lawsuit was filed. Then two maladroit then-Commissioners, Joseph Lester Boles and Susan Burk, both attorneys, retaliated and publicly threatened to make Dr. Hines "pay the piper" for filing a "frivolous" lawsuit they had not read, with Commissioners agreeing to seek sanctions as a SLAPP suit to discourage Open Records litigation   None were deserved -- the City ended up paying Dr. Hines' fees after the City hired private counsel, SIDNEY FRANKLYN ANSBACHER.
4. Please ask the Clerk's Fraud, Waste and Abuse investigator to investigate and report on why access was cut off to the public.  
5. A 2013 docket notation refers to a "child support" matter -- this is erroneous  
6. What happened here?
7. I have sent a copy of this e-mail to Ms. Patricia Gleason, Esq., Assistant Attorney General, who can instruct you on your legal duties on Sunshine and Open Records.
8. I look forward to meeting you and discussing this with you.  You are new on the Clerk's job, having only recently been appointed (at age 29) by anti-Sunshine Governor Richard Lynn Scott, apparently at the behest of Sheriff David Shoar, other local politicians and lawyers in preference to the longtime career deputy whom the judiciary had appointed as Acting Clerk of Court in Ms. Cheryl Strickland's place after Governor Scott failed to act timely on a replacement.  We, the People expect you to do your job without fear or favor.
9. Kindly make all documents in Hines v. Burchield available to the public on the Clerk's website no later than noon today, June 9, 2016
Thank you.

With kindest regards, I am,
Sincerely yours,
Ed Slavin
904-377-4998
www.edslavin.com





blank
Judge:
TRAYNOR, J. MICHAEL
Case Number:
CA06-0319
Clerk File Date:
4/11/2006
Total Fees Due:
0.00
Agency Report Number:
Court Type:
Circuit Civil
Uniform Case Number:
552006CA000319A000XX 
Status Date:
3/15/2007
Booking Number:
Custody Location:
Case Type:
Other Civil
Status:
CLOSED
Waive Speedy Trial:
Agency:
TYPEPARTY NAMEATTORNEY
PLAINTIFF 
Active ANDREWS, TANNER  
DEFENDANT 
Active ANDREWS, TANNER  
DEFENDANT 
DEFENDANT 
DEFENDANT 
DATEEVENTJUDGELOCATIONRESULT
4/16/2007 9:00 AM TRIAL (CIVIL) TRAYNOR, J. MICHAEL 
4/9/2007 1:30 PM HEARING (CIVIL) TRAYNOR, J. MICHAEL 
COUNTCODEDESCRIPTIONASSESSMENTPAIDWAIVEDBALANCEPAYMENT PLAN / JUDGMENTDUE DATE
No Fees on Case
DATERECEIPT #APPLIED AMOUNT
No Receipts on Case
DINDATEENTRY
 809/20/2013NOTICE OF HEARING BEFORE CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT HEARING OFFICER 
  793/15/2007DISMISSAL 
 763/15/2007NOTICE OF VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL/ OR 2884 PG 1575-1576 
 713/8/2007NOTICE OF DISCLOSURE OF NON EXPERT WITNESSES/ SUPPLEMENTAL 
 782/22/2007WITNESS LIST/ NON EXPERT 
 652/16/2007ORDER APPOINTING MEDIATOR AND GOVERNING MEDIATION 
 702/15/2007NOTICE OF DISCLOSURE OF NON EXPERT WITNESSES 
 602/13/2007STIPULATION TO MEDIATOR 
 772/12/2007WITNESS LIST/NOTICE OF EXPERT 
 692/5/2007NOTICE OF DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES 
 741/16/2007MOTION TO REFER MATTER TO MEDIATION/AGREED 
 641/10/2007NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY 
 731/4/2007MOTION TO REFER MATTER TO MEDIATION 
 7510/3/2006ORDER SETTING JURY TRIAL/NON ETC 
  6210/3/2006TRIAL (CIVIL) SET FOR 04/16/2007 AT 09:00 WITH J MICHAEL TRAYNOR 
  6110/3/2006HEARING (CIVIL) SET FOR 04/09/2007 AT 01:30 WITH J MICHAEL TRAYNOR 
 669/27/2006NOTICE OF TRIAL 
 729/14/2006MOTION TO STRIKE DENIALS IN REPY BY D E HINES 
 679/13/2006ANSWER TO AFF DEFENSES 
 639/6/2006MOTION TO DISMISS/MOTION FOR MORE DEFINITE STATEMENT AND ANSWER ETC 
 689/5/2006NOTICE OF VACATION/ATTNYS 
 598/16/2006HINES' FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/081806-BC 
 588/14/2006HINES FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT/081706-BC 
 578/11/2006ORDER ON PETITIONER'S ORE TENUS MOTION TO AMEND PETITION081606-BC 
 568/9/2006LETTER TO TANNER ANDREWS FROM ROBIN UPCHURCH 081006 LGB 
 558/9/2006COURT NOTES 081006 LGB 
 548/8/2006RESPONDENT'S STIPULATION REGARDING NINE PUBLIC RECORDSOF CITY VEHICLES 080906 DLB 
 538/8/2006NOTICE OF HEARING SET FOR 8-8-06@ 3:30 080906 DLB 
 528/7/2006NOTICE OF DEPO OF JACK BODTOFER (FAXED COPY) 080706-AH 
 518/4/2006RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ETC/08/07/06/LGB 
 508/4/2006RESPONDENTS RESPONSE TO PETITIONERS MOTION FORCOMPULSORY JUDICIAL NOTICE OF EXISTENCE OF CITYRECORDS PROVIOUSLY DENIED BY CITY/08/07/06/LGB 
 498/3/2006HINES' SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWER TO CITY'S MOTION FOR SUMMJUDGMENT - 080706/LBS 
 488/1/2006LETTER TO ATTY ANDREWS FROM SIDNEY ANSBACHER 080206KD 
 478/1/2006HINES' SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWER TO CITYS MOTION FOR SUMMARYJUDGMENT 080206KD 
 467/31/2006NOTICE OF CONTINUANCE OF DEPOSITION 080106KD 
 457/31/2006SUPPLEMENTAL NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE WITH PETITIONER'SREQUEST FOR NOTIFICATION 080106KD 
 447/31/2006NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF DWIGHT E. HINES 080106KD 
 437/28/2006PETITIONERS MOTION TO CONTINUE HEARING SECHEDULEDUNILATERALLY BY RESPONDENTS IN VIOLATONS OF JUDGEBERGERS COURT ORDER AND AN AXIOM OF FLORIDA LAW/07/31/06/LGB 
 427/27/2006RESPONDENTS' RESPONSE TO 'PETITIONER'S MOTION TOCONTINUE HEARING SCHEDULED UNLATERALLY BY RESPONDENTSIN VIOLATIONS OF JUDGE BERGER'S COURT ORDER AND ANAXIOM AND AN AXIOM OF FLORIDA LAW' 072806MG 
 417/27/2006NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE WITH PETITIONER'S REQUEST FORNOTIFICATION 072806MG 
 407/26/2006PETITIONER'S MOTION TO CONTINUE HEARING SCHEDULEDUNILATERALLY BY RESPONDENTS IN VIOLATIONS OF JUDGEBERGER'S COURT ORDER AND AN AXIOM OF FLORIDA LAW072706/MG 
 397/24/2006RESPONDENTS' NOTICE OF FILING DOSSIER SOFTWARE LICENSE& SERVICE AGREEMENT 072606/MG 
 387/24/2006AMENDED NOTICE OF DEPO OF JACK BODTOFUER 072606/MG 
 377/20/2006PETITIONER'S OBJECTIONS AND MOTION TO STRIKE RESPONDENTSMOTION TO COMPEL 072106/MG 
  367/20/2006NOTICE OF DEPO OF JACK BODTOFUER SEE PAPER 50 080706-AH 
 357/17/2006NOTICE OF HEARING SET FOR 8/8/06 - 071806/MG 
 347/11/2006MOTION TO COMPEL 071306/MG 
 337/10/2006PETITIONER'S NOTICE TO COURT REPORTER ON PROPER BILLINGFOR TIME LOST DIE TO MISSED DEPO 071206/MG 
 327/10/2006PETITIONER'S NOTICE OF MISPLACED CASE FILE AND OFVACATION FOR REMAINDER OF JULY, 2006 071206/MG 
 316/29/2006PETITIONER'S OBJECTIONS AND MOTION TO STRIKE RESPONDENTSNOTICE OF DEPO DUCES TECUM OF DWIGHT HINES 063006-MG 
 306/29/2006NOTICE OF ADDRESS CHANGE 063006-MG 
 296/28/2006PETITIONER'S NOTICE OF HEARING ON INJUNCTION ANDSELECTED MOTIONS 062906-MG 
 286/26/2006PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR COSTS FOR RESPONDENTS' BADFAITH AFFIDAVITS AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW 062806/MG 
 276/22/2006REPONDENT'S NOTICE OF DEPOTITION DUCES TECUM 06206SV 
 266/8/2006LTR FROM EAKIN & SNEED TO DR HINES DTD 7JUN06 -060906/LBS 
 256/6/2006PETITIONER'S MOTION TO STRIKE RESPONDENTS' MOTION FORSUMMARY JUDGMENT BASED ON LETHAL ERRORS OF RULES, LAWSAND FACTS, AND PETITIONER'S VERIFIED MOTION FOR SUMMARYJUDGMENT 060806/MG 
 246/5/2006LETTER TO DR. HINES FROM ROBIIN H. UPCHURCH 060706/MG 
 235/26/2006RESPONDENTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 053106/MG 
 225/26/2006LETTER FROM ROBIN H. UPCHURCH TO DR. HINES DATED 5/25/06053106/MG 
 215/23/2006NOTICE OF PRODUCTION TO MICHELLE PINKEL, TRACY HARTMAN,SIDNEY ANSPACHER, ROBIN UPCHURCH 052406-AH 
 205/22/2006PETITIONER'S MEMORANDUM OF LAW ON INEXTRICABLEINTERWINING IN SUPPORT OF ENJOINING RESPONDENTS'COMPLIANCE WITH CHAPTER 119, FLA. STAT. (2005) ANDOPPOSED TO RESPONDENTS' MOTION TO DISMISS 052206/MG 
 195/18/2006PETITIONER'S NOTICE OF CITY OF ST. AUGUSTINE'S RESPONSETO FLORIDA DEPT. OF ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION'S CRIMINALINVESTIGATION OF CITY'S ILLEGAL DUMPING ET AL 051906/MG 
 185/11/2006PETITIONER'S MOTIONS OPPOSING RESPONDENTS' DEFENSESAND MOTIONS AND TO ENJOIN RESPONDENTS' COMPLIANCE WITHCHAPTER 119, FLA.STAT. (2005) 051506-MG 
 175/5/2006FAXED ORDER ON RESPONDENTS' MOTION TO CONTINUE HEARINGON INJUNCTION, COMPULSORY JUDICIAL NOTICES AND MOTIONFOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT/050906-BC 
 165/4/2006PETITIONER'S NOTICE OF ATTEMPTS TO RETAIN ATTY, MEDIAAND FIRST AMENDMENT AMICI 050806/MG 
 155/3/2006RESPONDENTS' MOTION TO CONTINUE HEARING ON INJUNCTION,COMPULSORY JUDICIAL NOTICES, AND MOTION FOR SUMMARYJUDGMENT 050806/MG 
 145/2/2006RESPONDENTS' MOTIONS DIRECTED TO PETITIONER'S PETITIONFOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION, DECLARATORY RELIEF ANDPERMANENT INJUNCTION AND ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVEDEFENSES 050406/MG 
 135/2/2006RESPONDENTS' RESPONSE TO PETITIONER'S MOTION FORPRIORITY HEARING STATUS 050406/MG 
 125/1/2006NOTICE OF HEARING ON INJUNCTION, COMPULSORY JUDICALNOTICES, AND MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT SET FOR5/10/06 - 050406/MG 
 115/1/2006PETITIONER'S MEMORANDUM OF LAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FORPRIORITY HEARING STATUS 050406/MG 
 104/27/2006PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR COMPULSORY JUDICIAL NOTICE OFEXISTENCE OF CITY RECORDS PREVIOUSLY DENIED BY CITY/050206-BC 
 94/27/2006PETITIONERS MEMO OF LAW SUPPORTING MOTION FORCOMPULSORY JUDICIAL NOTICE OF FACTS PREVIOUSLY DENIEDBY CITY/050206-BC 
 84/17/2006PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR COMPULSORY JUDICIAL NOTICE OF NODAUBERT-FRYE CONFLICT ET AL 042106/MG 
 74/17/2006PETITIONER'S MEMORANDUM OF LAW SUPPORTING MOTION FORCOMPULSORY JUDICIAL NOTICES OF DOCUMENTS AND INTERNETSOURCES IN PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS 042106/MG 
 64/12/2006SUMS TO WILLIAM B. HARRISS AKA BILL,CITY MGR OF STAUGUSTINE RTD 4/11/06 SRVD 041906-AH 
 54/12/2006SUMS TO TIM BURCHFIELD CHIEF ADMIN. OFFICER RTD 4/11/06041906-AH 
 44/12/2006SUMS TO CITY OF ST AUGUSTINE RTD 4/11/06 SRVD 041906-AH 
 34/11/2006PETITIONERS MOTION FOR PRIORITY HEARING STATUS 041106DLB 
 24/11/2006CIVIL COVER SHEET 041106/DLB 
 14/11/2006PETITION FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION, DECLARATORY RELIEFAND PERMANENT INJUNCTION SUMS ISS/DEL TO SJSO 041106DLB 

No comments: